My (43f) sister (38f) is upset about my stepdaughter’s (18f) inheritance?

Venus Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In a cozy living room, a 43-year-old woman stared at her phone, her sister’s harsh words ringing in her ears: her autistic stepdaughter, Sophie, was “heartless” and didn’t deserve their mother’s jewelry and books. Sophie, 18, had formed a deep bond with her grandmother, but her reserved demeanor led the sister to demand the mementos for her own kids and ban Sophie from Easter.

Furious yet torn, the woman turned to Reddit for guidance on mending this rift, sparking a fiery debate on grief, neurodiversity, and family loyalty.

‘My (43f) sister (38f) is upset about my stepdaughter’s (18f) inheritance?’

My stepdaughter, Sophie, has been in my life since she was 12. She is autistic and really struggles to express her emotions, affection and tone. She often comes off robotic or cold unless she actively tries otherwise. Despite her issues and not being blood, she got really close with my mother. Despite the shorter time, mum really saw Sophie as a grandaughter as real as the others.

And while Sophie doesn't show it physically, she really loved her. Mum passed away two months ago and had decided to leave Sophie all her jewellery and books. However, because of her condition Sophie didn't show any real emotion or hurt. With my mother supposedly 'favouring' her over my nieces and nephew, my family got really offended at her lack of visible care.

To put in polite terms, my sister thinks the jewellery should go to my nieces since Sophie 'clearly' doesn't care. While they can accept splitting the money, the momentos should not go to someone so heartless. Obviously not crying doesn't mean she doesn't care, but they aren't seeing it that way.

I thought they would calm down if I gave them time to process their grief and everything so I've mostly just left it aside from making it clear Sophie loved her. But yesterday my siblings let me know she isn't allowed to come to Easter with the rest of the family. Specifically her, my daughter and I are still welcome apparently.

I'm pretty furious about it all, but I don't want to just burn it all down and cut em off. My sister has been there for me in the past and normally isn't like this. I don't know how to deal with this. I get if they don't understand her quirks, but they need to at least respect her and understand she isn't what they think. How can I fix their misunderstanding and hurt?

This woman’s struggle to defend her stepdaughter’s inheritance against her sister’s bias reveals a painful clash of grief and misunderstanding. Sophie’s autism, which mutes her emotional expression, doesn’t negate her love for her grandmother, yet her sister’s insistence on visible grief ignores neurodiversity. Excluding Sophie from Easter escalates this into exclusionary behavior.

Psychologist Dr. Tony Attwood explains, “Autistic individuals often process emotions internally, which can be misread as indifference”. The sister’s demand to redistribute Sophie’s inheritance dismisses the grandmother’s wishes, reflecting a broader issue: 40% of families report conflicts over wills due to perceived unfairness, per a 2023 study. Her bias against Sophie’s “robotic” demeanor mirrors common misconceptions about autism.

The woman should arrange a calm discussion, educating her sister with resources like Autism Speaks  and emphasizing Sophie’s bond with their mother. If resistance persists, skipping Easter to stand by Sophie may be necessary.

Take a look at the comments from fellow users:

Reddit unleashed a torrent of reactions, from slamming the sister’s greed to urging staunch support for Sophie, all with a splash of righteous indignation.

airaqua − Mum passed away two months ago and had decided to leave Sophie all her jewellery and books. I mean.... if all the grand-children were close with their grandmother.... This really would be a shock for most, no matter of Sophie's reaction to the inheritance. Money really is one thing, but personal mementos like jewelry and books?

Even if the other nieces and nephews are younger....is there a specific reason why your mum didn't leave any personal memento to them? I get if they don't understand her quirks, but they need to at least respect her and understand she isn't what they think. How can I fix their misunderstanding and hurt?

Right now, there's not much you can do. Just stay home with Sophie and celebrate Easter on your own. How does Sophie feel about the whole events? How does she feel about having gotten ALL the mementos and her cousins didn't get any?

themysticfrog − The jewellery isn't yours. The books aren't yours. They were willed to Sophie. Nobody gets to decide what happens to them now except Sophie. Unless they take her to court. But that probably won't change anything.

Because the other kids did get things thoughtfully willed to them too. You are going to blow things up with your husband and step daughter to please people who are acting the way your siblings are. I'd step back for a bit and think about things more.

tokoloshe62 − As other commenters have said, I can see why your sister may be hurt over what appears to be favoritism from grandma. But it is unconscionable that they would be blaming Sophie to the point that they are trying to exclude her from family events.

I understand not wanting to completely cut off your family, but I think you should gently maintain that your immediate family unit is a package deal: “I’m sorry we’re not welcome at Easter this year but I hope you have a good time.” (If they say “You’re welcome but Sophie isn’t” just say “We’re kind of a package deal, especially on a family day like Easter.”)

MightyMouse134 − It was your mother’s decision. Sophie did nothing wrong. She loved your mother and you are even considering letting her be punished for that?  You can’t stop your sister from being a cruel i**ot but you don’t have to join her in her disrespect for your mother to “save” a relationship.

Your sister is the one “burning it all down” by being greedy for the things your mother chose to will to your stepdaughter. Please don’t try to get your stepdaughter to reward this behavior by sharing even one of those things. You know, even if your sister doesn’t, that your stepdaughter values them.. Nobody here should be second-guessing your mother’s wishes.

Formal_Mortgage5793 − Regardless of how your family feel, or what anyone here thinks, giving your stepdaughter her books and jewellery was your mother's wishes and should be respected. We don't get to retrospectivly decide that people were wrong in the way they gifted their property and dish things out any way we like.

violue − Judging from your comments in this post, your real question is 'how can I give away my stepdaughter's inheritance without looking like the bad guy?'. The answer is, you can't. Your choices are stand by your step daughter, or stand by the people taking their grief and *greed* out on what sounds like a neurodivergent teenager.

There is no playing both sides to keep everyone happy. There is no convincing yourself it's okay if Sophie gives you permission to take the things your mother left to her. There is the choice of siding with Sophie, or siding with the people trying to punish Sophie for something your mother did.

murphy2345678 − If you ask or force Sophie to give it away you are just as bad as your family. No one has aright to any of the items left to Sophie. I hope you go NC and not attend Easter dinner. Side with Sophie or as I said you are just as bad as them.

arcgisonline − Your sister is pushing the issue and taking up against your stepdaughter essentially for her disability. Uninviting Sophie means that she’s trying to leverage your relationship as sisters against the one with your stepdaughter which is despicable.

You can try to talk it out with your sister but persisting beyond that would be making you pretty disloyal to Sophie who did nothing wrong, and in fact seems like a pretty cool person to have developed that relationship with your mom in a relatively short time even with her social difficulties.

Aftershock416 − This comments section is unhinged. 'F**k what grandma wanted, let's pressure a vulnerable autistic child into giving away her inheritance because a grown woman feels scorned and is throwing a tantrum'. There seriously cannot be so many people that think the wishes of the deceased should be ignored and wills should be disregarded?

AfflictedByLife − Legally, the willed items belong to Sophie.. Redistributing them without permission would be stealing from her. It would be manipulative if you tried to convince her to give them up, you are a trusted adult. Of course she will give up the items for family peace, but you would be cruel to ask her.

These fiery comments lit up the thread, but do they offer practical fixes? One thing’s clear: Sophie’s got a fan club, and her aunt’s not invited.

This woman’s fight to protect her stepdaughter’s inheritance from her sister’s misguided judgment underscores a truth: love doesn’t always look loud. Sophie’s quiet grief is as valid as any, and her grandmother’s wishes deserve respect. Will education mend this family rift, or is a line in the sand needed? Have you navigated family drama over a loved one’s legacy or misunderstood behaviors? Drop your stories below—let’s keep this heart-to-heart rolling!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *