AITA for telling my wife that I do not miss her?

She returned from a full day spent navigating anxious social interactions, hoping for a warm reunion. Instead of the expected embrace of reassurance, she was met with a chart of call durations—proof that they had talked more than anyone else that day. His instinct for precision overshadowed her need for emotional comfort.

The moment highlighted a deeper mismatch in their communication styles. What he perceived as a logical clarification felt to her like a dismissal of her feelings. In a relationship built on mutual support, this brief encounter revealed how easily empathy can be sidelined by literal truths.

‘AITA for telling my wife that I do not miss her?’

My wife and I have a great relationship, generally. We work together but today she wasn't in the office because she was at an all-day social gathering with a person who sometimes causes her anxiety. Based on my call log, my wife called me at 9:28 a.m. and we talked for 2-and-a-half minutes, she called at 10:56 a.m.

and we talked for less than a minute, she called at 11:50 a.m. and we talked for 12 minutes, she called at 12:31 p.m. and we talked for 21 minutes, she called at 1:39 p.m. and we talked less than a minute, she called at 2:01 p.m. and we talked less than a minute, she called at 3:49 p.m.

and we talked less than a minute, and she called at 6:20 p.m. and we talked for 34 minutes. During this final call, she was driving to the office. We hung up while she was in the office with me. She walked over and hugged me and said, 'Did you miss me?'. I hesitated. 'Uhhhh ... sure, I guess.'.

She got angry. 'You didn't miss me?'. 'Well, baby,' I said, 'I've talked to you more than I've talked to anyone else today.'. 'No you didn't,' she said. I pulled out my call log and showed her.. 'Well, I'm going to find a man who appreciates my calls!'

'I didn't say I don't appreciate your calls,' I said. 'It's just not logical to be talking to someone all day and then ask them if they missed you.' That got me nowhere. I was probably using too much logic. She was clearly seeking comfort because she was in an uncomfortable situation all day.

When she returned to me, she was probably looking for a little celebration and support, since she made it through today's emotional difficulties. I didn't give it to her, thereby making me the a**hole. Now she's in her office talking to someone else on the phone. And I'm in my office justifying myself on Reddit.

EDIT: 'I was probably using too much logic' was a poor choice of words. By that phrase, I only meant that I was being emotionally insensitive, which is my tendency. I didn't mean to suggest that my wife is fundamentally illogical. I love my wife dearly and I think highly of her. I hope that helps.

Research in relationship dynamics shows that small bids for emotional connection like the question “Did you miss me”—serve a vital role in reinforcing intimacy. These moments are less about the factual content and more about expressing vulnerability and seeking validation.

Dr. John Gottman’s work emphasizes that responding to such bids with empathy strengthens the emotional bond. When a partner is in distress, acknowledging their feelings first and foremost communicates care and understanding even if the literal data suggests otherwise.

ADVERTISEMENT

Balancing logical accuracy with emotional attunement can be challenging for individuals who lean toward analytical thinking. Therapy approaches often recommend a two-step response: first mirror the emotion (“I know that day was tough, and I missed you so much”), then offer any necessary clarification or context.

By adopting this practice, couples can ensure that neither partner’s needs are overlooked. Emotional validation paves the way for deeper connection, while logical follow-up can provide reassurance that the supportive intent is grounded in reality.

Heres what people had to say to OP:

Redditors noted that while facts have their place, they should not replace expressions of warmth when a loved one seeks comfort. Many agreed that a simple “I’ve missed you” would have honored her emotional state and diffused the tension.

ADVERTISEMENT

Commenters advised that a quick apology followed by genuine reassurance—reflecting both care and awareness of her feelings—would help restore the balance between logic and empathy in future interactions.

[Reddit User] − YTA for your condescension. “I was probably using too much logic” tells me everything I need to know about how you view your wife.

[Reddit User] − NAH because I genuinely believe this is just two people interpreting the situation differently. However, just a suggestion for you. You clearly did not enjoy her calls, and instead of just saying that to her, you essentially said 'I didn't miss you because you wouldn't stfu' at the end of the day. That's why she's mad.

ADVERTISEMENT

Just say after the second call next time 'I'm sorry, I have something I need to get done today. Can I call you later or talk when you get back?' There, done. Your wife doesn't know she's annoying you unless you say something to her.

deboned_chuckschumer − 'I was probably using too much logic.'. .....ESH. She sounds exhausting, but you sound like you think of your wife as a lesser person.

xXKK911Xx − Completely NTA. She says that she will find a man who misses her? In what world is this even close to being acceptable to say? Even though it most probably wasnt with complete seriousness, she was threatening to replace you, over such a little incident.

ADVERTISEMENT

Besides, you just said the truth, just because you didnt miss her, it doesnt mean, that you dont love her/value her/appreciate her presents.. Besides its great that you assisted her with so many calls.

tinyahjumma − You both sound exhausting, to be honest.. Honey did you miss me?. Of course I did, darling! How hard is that? On the other hand, how long has she known you? I imagine she should be used to your non-abstract thinking.

QuinGood − NTA. When did you have TIME to miss her?. She called 7 times during a 9 hour period when there was not a family emergency.. She sounds insecure and needy.. Good Luck

ADVERTISEMENT

someone-w-issues − 'Yes so much, it was just awful without you'. It's not that hard dude but I won't say you're AH for it only slightly stupid. NAH

Evil_Mel − She was clearly seeking comfort because she was in an uncomfortable situation all day.. You are probably correct. That many calls indicates she needed your strength to help her through the day.. NAH

Leto-ofDelos − You are shockingly self aware for an AITA poster. I'm going to say NAH because it seems like you both came into the interaction with different expectations, and both had something different in your blind spot that you realized shortly after.

ADVERTISEMENT

She had an emotionally exhausting day and came to you looking for comfort, but didn't realize that she called you as much as she did so her question came off a bit odd. You heard her odd question and gave her a logical response to explain why it was odd

but didn't realize she was emotionally exhausted and seeking comfort. You're both equally right and equally wrong. If you want to be the bigger person since she had a rough day, go apologize anyway and let her vent about her day.

Traditional-Bed9449 − Uuggghhhh. Seeing the list of calls tires me out and I wasn’t on them. There’s no way I could be in a relationship (or married to) someone who needs that kind of attention.. NTA - you didn’t have time to miss her

ADVERTISEMENT

Effective communication requires both accuracy and attunement. When logic overshadows compassion, even small moments can spiral into hurt feelings. Couples who learn to recognize and respond to emotional bids build stronger, more resilient bonds. How have you navigated similar situations where empathy and rationality clashed? Share your approaches and insights below.

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *