AITA for not working with the father of my children to make his and his wife’s relationship with the kids better?

A 36-year-old mom discovered her partner’s devastating lie mid-pregnancy: he was never divorced, had reunited with his still-legal wife, and together they seemed to view her twins as their ticket to parenthood since the wife couldn’t conceive.

For years, the couple fought aggressively for custody, pushed the wife as “mommy,” attempted parental alienation, and tried to marginalize her role entirely – even wanting the wife at the birth. She held firm with lawyers and boundaries, securing 50/50 custody eventually.

‘AITA for not working with the father of my children to make his and his wife’s relationship with the kids better?’

The relationship seemed solid until the shocking truth emerged during pregnancy:

I (36f) have 9 year old boy/girl twins with my ex (40m). We were together for three years and when he got me pregnant he left me to go back...

For context. When we met he told me he was divorced and he had friends who backed him up. He never gave any vibes that would make me think otherwise...

He told me he wasn't close to his family but his friends were like his family and I bought that too. They were around us enough. The truth came out...

He told me it wasn't working and he wanted us to co-parent instead. I found out within weeks that he was "back together" with his ex-wife and they supposedly remarried.

But they were never divorced. I don't know if they had broken up and separated over her not having kids or whether there was a plan to get kids some...

The couple’s aggressive push to claim the twins intensified post-discovery:

They tried to force me to let her be present at the birth. I found out he was close with his family and they had no idea he'd been with...

My ex said they'd happily raise the babies together and I could call once a year and I said no. I didn't invite him to the hospital to see them...

ADVERTISEMENT

I had a lawyer by the time I delivered the twins so I was working with her to get the best outcome because I knew they'd fight me for custody.

I communicated with him only through text and email at first. And for the first year the twins remained with me despite CPS being called (and I know it was...

Custody battles raged with ongoing boundary violations:

ADVERTISEMENT

50-50 custody was established once the twins were one. But it was hell. There was a lot of attempts to make decisions they legally could not make without me,

and I had to document that, they called her mommy around the twins, encouraged her to have this "special bond" with the twins and even sent videos of her being...

A few minutes or hours. I had to be firm and set clear boundaries and point out the custody order. When the twins were 5 after a lot of parental...

ADVERTISEMENT

There was some back and forth regarding that because every time he'd progress to every other weekend they would be back to their old ways and trying to influence the...

and attempting to essentially steal the kids from me. By the time the twins were 7 he was back to 50% custody. But the twins relationship with them was not...

Now the ex seeks her active help to repair the damage:

ADVERTISEMENT

This has been a problem for two years now and he has told me about it via email a few times. But has asked me for help lately. My ex...

He mentioned how they wanted to sit in on a therapy session with the kids, since I have them in therapy, but the kids said no to his wife being...

I have refused to help him and work with him on this. He sent some strongly worded emails about us needing to work together for the sake of the kids.

ADVERTISEMENT

I admit a part of me is so happy about it after all they put me through and how they tried to take my kids, after using me the way...

This situation reeks of reproductive coercion and attempted parental erasure – using deception to conceive, then aggressively sidelining the biological mom. Courts rightly rejected full takeover bids, but ongoing alienation efforts damaged the kids’ bonds naturally.

Refusing to “fix” relationships the ex-couple broke isn’t withholding cooperation; it’s protecting hard-won boundaries. Forcing warmth toward a stepmom who pushed “mommy” status risks further confusion. Therapy should prioritize kids’ voices, not adult agendas.

ADVERTISEMENT

Co-parenting requires mutual respect, absent here from day one. Family experts advise documenting violations, using apps for communication, and considering GALs (guardians ad litem) for high-conflict cases. Kids rejecting manipulators is often self-protection – support that, don’t override it. Long-term, stability with the primary attachment figure (OP) matters most.

Here’s what people had to say to OP:

Overwhelming NTA, with many suspecting deliberate surrogacy plot and praising her protection:

Strong suspicions of premeditated deception:

ADVERTISEMENT

Any-Expression2246 - To me, it sounds like this could have actually been planned out. She can't have kids. He finds a girl, friends back up the story he's divorced. She...

They are the type of people to lie and manipulate to try and get the kids, not too far fetched they didn't hatch a plan to begin with.

BonusMomSays - Sounds to me like your ex and his wife intentionally found someone to carry his kids. They planned for you to be their surrogate without having to pay...

ADVERTISEMENT

PFyre - I can imagine the conversation: - "We could use a surrogate. " - "They're expensive. " - "How about getting a girl pregnant and stealing the kids. "...

Clean_Factor9673 - NTA. Your ex's wife couldn't get pregnant so it sounds like your whole relationship was about getting kids gor them... Stay strong. You don't have to help them.

Silver-Appointment77 - Looks like hes got the go ahead to find someone else to carry a baby from his wife, , so they could tey and keep it... Thats why...

ADVERTISEMENT

Calls to stay vigilant and limit contact:

Doc-Brown1911 - NTAH. F__k him and go to court, get child support and get full custody and move far away.

BeachinLife1 - Hell to the no! They have literally created this situation and they've spent 7 years creating it!... Do people really think kids don't eventually figure out what's going...

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] - Nta. You were essentially the surrogate... Always be on guard... Continue to protect them.

[Reddit User] - NTA keep every communication... I expect this is going to be an on going problem until your kids are 18.

NixKlappt-Reddit - NTA Your ex and his wife are creeps. I would be scared that they harm you to get full custody... So protocol everything...

ADVERTISEMENT

Cybermagetx - Nta. They are giving your kids a lifetime of therapy as is.

Some nuanced advice on therapy and boundaries:

ADVERTISEMENT

NYCStoryteller - NTA... Do your kids have a GAL appointed?... If your ex and his wife have 50/50 custody... it's probably in their best interest... to have therapy sessions... She...

Others pure support:

SparkyandDolche - No, you’re NTA. It sounds like you were used to have the children and you’re doing the best you can under the circumstances.

ADVERTISEMENT

starrybabe99 - Honestly, if they wanted the kids to call her 'Mommy,' maybe they should’ve thought about that before doing a surprise marriage revival!

[Reddit User] - NTA! You poor thing!!

Verdict rings clear: NTA – the ex-couple manufactured this rejection through years of manipulation and alienation attempts.

ADVERTISEMENT

Kids sensing the truth and protecting themselves isn’t something to “fix” for the adults’ convenience. What do you think – planned surrogacy scam, or just opportunistic cruelty? Would you ever cooperate in therapy, or keep walls high?

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *