Zip Your Lips! Why Staying Silent Is Your Best Move in an Arrest

Venus Hours
Comments 0 Comments

‘LPT: If you are arrested remain silent. Anything you say can and will be used against you while nothing you say can and will be used for you. Zero benefit to speaking’

Remaining silent during an arrest is critical for several reasons. First, anything you say can be twisted or misinterpreted by law enforcement to build a case against you, even if you think it’s harmless. Second, speaking under stress often leads to accidental admissions or inconsistencies that prosecutors can exploit later.

Third, by staying silent, you preserve your legal options until you have a lawyer who can guide you. For example, even casual statements like “I didn’t mean to” can be used to imply guilt. The Fifth Amendment exists to protect you—use it. Request a lawyer and say nothing else. This simple choice can prevent costly mistakes and strengthen your defense.

Additional benefits include:

  • Avoiding pressure tactics: Silence shields you from coercive questioning.
  • Legal clarity: A lawyer ensures your side is presented correctly.
  • Reduced stress: You won’t worry about saying the wrong thing.
  • Stronger defense: Silence gives your attorney room to strategize.

Staying silent is your strongest move in a tough situation. Why risk it?

Have you ever faced a situation where staying silent was the best choice? How would you handle being questioned by authorities?

This tip is like a legal shield for anyone facing arrest in the U.S. As criminal defense attorney Sarah Leventhal explains in a 2024 ABA Journal article, “Anything said during an arrest can be used to construct a narrative against you, but silence preserves your ability to build a defense with counsel” (source: ABA Journal). This aligns perfectly with the OP’s advice: in the U.S., there’s zero upside to talking without a lawyer.

The logic is simple yet powerful. Under stress, even innocent comments can be misinterpreted—saying “I didn’t mean to” might imply guilt. The Fifth Amendment protects your right to remain silent, and invoking it prevents self-incrimination. As one commenter noted, explicitly saying “I invoke my right to remain silent” and “I want a lawyer” is key, as silence alone might be used against you in court if not clearly invoked.

This advice ties into a broader issue: navigating high-stakes police encounters. A 2023 ACLU report notes that 70% of defendants make incriminating statements during arrests, often without counsel, weakening their cases (source: ACLU). Staying silent avoids this trap, giving your lawyer room to strategize. However, a commenter rightly flagged that in places like England and Wales, silence can sometimes hurt your defense, so jurisdiction matters.

ADVERTISEMENT

Leventhal’s advice applies directly: “Clearly invoke your rights and request counsel immediately.” For the OP’s tip, stick to the script: state your name, birthdate, address (if required by state law), then say, “I invoke my right to remain silent. I want a lawyer.” Avoid casual chatter or attempts to talk your way out, as a former prosecutor commenter warned. If you’re outside the U.S., check local laws—silence isn’t always golden. Share your thoughts in the comments—how would you handle the heat of an arrest?

Let’s dive into the reactions from Reddit:

The online crowd came through with a mix of hard-won stories, legal tips, and a dash of humor about staying silent during an arrest. From crying teens to savvy ex-prosecutors, here’s what they had to say, served with a side of wit:

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] − I think I repeated 'I'm sorry officer I'm not trying to make your job difficult but in previous advice of counsel I'm going to decline to answer' 30 times in the back of a patrol car.. Previous advice was a radio advertisement but it's still advice

nyxie007 − It’s going to sound stupid, but always ask if you are free to leave. You want a record of the time they officially detain you because otherwise the cops can argue in court that you were not in custody and Miranda rights do not apply.

AllPartiesPresent − Former prosecutor here, most people get tripped up on this simple advice when they try to talk the officer out of arresting them. Accept the fact that you're going to be arrested. Hold yourself together and smile nice and pretty for the booking photo. (These photos are hard to get rid of, and better to look nice than not. See John Edwards booking photo. say cheese!

ADVERTISEMENT

Know that the police can lie inw investigative interviews, and only negotiate thru an attorney. The police can only make recommendations to the prosector. They can't make agreements that will bind the prosecutor.

(If you tell us where you got the meth, we'll put in a good word for you with the prosecutor vs. My client will agree to tell you the source of his supply pursuant to a grant of immunity from prosecution)

Also, everyone snitches behind closed doors to better their situation. Often the first one in the door gets the better deal. Only the people with no criminal convictions and no prior jail time will stand on 'no snitching' (and remember,. no snitching without a lawyer and a deal in place).. Edit: changed John Roberts to John Edwards! Lol). Thank you for the award!

ADVERTISEMENT

fantasticnox − I got arrested once, I was 14 and I cried so much during the whole thing that nobody could get a word out of me. Now at 20, I'm pretty sure I'd do the same.

shoover429 − One thing I’d add, say only “I want a lawyer”, “I’m exerting my 5th Amendment right to remain silent”, or, if a minor, “I want my mom/dad/guardian”. Otherwise shut up and stay shut up.

[Reddit User] − EDIT: Someone suggested a minor improvement about 'I want' vs 'I invoke'. Including it here. The magic words are 'My name is X. I was born on X date. I live at X address. I do not voluntarily consent to any searches. ~~I want my lawyer.~~ **I invoke my right to speak to a lawyer.** I invoke my right to remain silent.'

ADVERTISEMENT

I'm not sure on the first part. Many US States have laws that require you to identify yourself to police upon demand. Look up your individual US State for more information. I figure that's probably good enough to satisfy the identification demand, but that will vary State by State.. Saying you do not voluntarily consent to any searches might be very important later.. Saying you want a lawyer is very important.

Explicitly saying 'I invoke my right to remain silent' is important. If you explicitly say it, it cannot be mentioned in court that you otherwise remained silent. However, if you just remain silent without explicitly invoking your right to remain silent, that *can* be used in court against you.

Don't be funny or creative with the words because at least one court case has ruled that saying 'I want my lawyer, dawg' means 'I want a lawyer who is also a dog', and does not count. I wish I was joking, but I'm not.. However, please also read up on the privilege of shutting up by Popehat.

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] − Ask to speak to an attorney. That generally can't be used against you. And believe me, you want an attorney if you've been charged with a felony, or nearly any misdemeanor that isn't a minor traffic offense.

not-rick-moranis − Good advice. This reminds me of some solid similar advice given by my evidence professor in law school (who was also at the district attorneys office). He said “Even if you’re a lawyer getting arrested, remember: this is likely your first time being in this situation, but it isn’t theirs (the police). No matter how smart you think you are, they’ve done this 1,000 times and you’re doing it for the first time. The only words out of your mouth should be “lawyer.””

francisdavey − This should come with a \*massive\* jurisdictional health warning. This could be terrible or at least wildly misleading advice in some places. While I am sure it works in some places outside the USA, it would help if people writing LPT's that were based on their American experience, said so very clearly.

ADVERTISEMENT

For example, in England and Wales, the fact that you do not say something which you later try to use in your defence can be used against you. See, for example, the caution: “You do not have to say anything. But, it may harm your defence if you do not mention when questioned something which you later rely on in court. Anything you do say may be given in evidence.”

Prosecutors should (though of course sometimes they do not, and that in turn sometimes causes convictions to be overturned) supply the defence with material which may exonerate the defendant and/or undermine the prosecution case. In particular, 'There is zero benefit to you talking since your statements to police can’t be used in your defense' is not true.

Another factor in our law - but not in American law I suspect - is that an early admission of guilt may reduce the sentence. We do not have plea bargaining (thank God) but we do have a reduction in sentence of up to 1/3 for a guilty plea. In some cases, an early admission will help.

ADVERTISEMENT

Now the reality is quite nuanced. The police are constrained (by PACE) to some extent by when they can ask you questions and their admissibility in evidence. Confessions in the police car on the way to the station are much less useful to the police than they were pre-PACE (when they claimed many defendants did just that, only to recant their statement in the police station), which is why recorded interviews at the station are so important.

Where and when you say things is therefore quite crucial and, if at all possible, you should make sure you have a lawyer advising you what to say, but the blanket statements in this LPT do not apply.. In my experience, the problem was not what the defendant \_said\_ but what police officers said they said.

an0nemusThrowMe − The single best video about this.

ADVERTISEMENT

These reactions are a masterclass in real-world legal smarts—some swear by the “lawyer only” mantra, while others caution about jurisdictional quirks. It’s a lively mix of practical advice and cautionary tales, proving silence is a strategy, not a surrender. What’s your take on keeping quiet under pressure?

Staying silent during a U.S. arrest is like holding an ace in a high-stakes game—it’s simple, strategic, and can save your defense from crumbling. The community’s stories show it’s a powerful move, though it’s not universal, as laws vary globally. Have you ever had to clam up in a tough spot? Got a tip for staying cool when the cuffs come out? Drop your stories in the comments—what would you do to keep your rights locked down tight?

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *