Woman Kisses Her Ex’s Roommate Two Weeks After Splitting, Blames ‘Double Permission’

We all know that moment when a relationship is clearly over, but the lingering social ties make moving on a total minefield. For one 21-year-old woman, a supposedly clean break from her boyfriend of three years quickly spiraled into a chaotic friend group drama.

She thought a mutual expiration date meant a drama-free exit, but a lingering spark with her ex’s roommate ignited a spectacularly messy situation. Armed with the bizarre excuse of romantic authorization, she found herself at the center of a very awkward love square.

Want the juicy details? Dive into the original story below!

Woman Kisses Her Ex's Roommate Two Weeks After Splitting, Blames 'Double Permission'

AITA for kissing my ex’s roommate 2 weeks after we broke up?

I, a 21-year-old female, ended a 3-year relationship with my boyfriend, Josh (21M), two weeks ago.

I dumped him, but we agreed we had an expiration date as I am moving away next year, which he knew for months before.

Josh lives with three other guys, and one is Pauly.

Well, when Josh and I were starting to fight about six months ago, we went on a trip with Pauly and his then-girlfriend, Isabella.

They were also having issues, and there were vibes between me and Pauly.

We didn't cheat or anything, but we made eyes.

Now, two weeks after the break up, Pauly starts texting me.

He and Isabella split a month ago.

ADVERTISEMENT

Pauly said he had something to tell me.

So, we went to a park during the day, had fun chatting, and ended up at my place.

Sometimes, the most baffling rationalizations are exactly what we want to hear in a moment of reckless temptation.

ADVERTISEMENT

He asked if he could kiss me, and I said I felt weird since he was Josh's roommate.

He said that's what he wanted to tell me, that he got permission from Josh to "romantically engage me." I said that was weird, but we ended up kissing (that's...

Pauly went back home and told Josh what happened.

ADVERTISEMENT

Josh then told all of our friends, and I am getting judged a lot.

My friends said indulging this was not OK, and that two weeks was way too soon.

I brought up that Pauly had permission, but the damage was done.

ADVERTISEMENT

Josh was upset, but Pauly refused to apologize.

He told Josh that he had asked him not once but twice.

He started to say he had "double permission." Josh and he yelled at each other, with Josh saying that kissing and telling was "crazy behavior," and Pauly kept saying, "Sure,...

ADVERTISEMENT

After, Josh called me and said I "showed no regard for him." I asked if he really did give permission.

He replied, "Whatever I told Pauly doesn't change anything."

Finally, Pauly's ex, Isabella, got wind and sent me flowers with a congratulations card.

ADVERTISEMENT

I took this as she was insulted because I violated girl code by kissing Pauly, though we weren't close; we just had gone on that one trip together.

It obviously made me feel horrible.

And generally, I feel pretty bad, but this would've been shut down completely if Josh never gave permission.

ADVERTISEMENT

AITA?

The psychological forces at play here go far beyond a simple post-breakup rebound. This dynamic is a classic example of boundary testing mixed with social triangulation. Relationship psychology suggests that when a long-term couple splits, the surrounding social network often experiences a destabilizing ripple effect. Pauly’s insistence on obtaining permission is a transparent attempt to absolve himself of guilt, turning his former roommate into an unwitting accomplice.

Meanwhile, the original poster leans entirely on this perceived authorization to bypass her own moral compass. Experts in navigating toxic friend groups often note that in our early twenties, the line between loyalty and ego is incredibly blurred. The ex-boyfriend’s passive-aggressive compliance highlights a severe lack of direct communication.

ADVERTISEMENT

A practical step for everyone involved would be to enforce a strict period of no-contact, allowing the dust to settle before navigating any new romantic entanglements within the same circle. Clarity and space are often the best remedies for impulsive decisions.

Navigating the aftermath of a long-term relationship is rarely simple, especially when mutual friends and roommates are involved. This situation leaves us wondering where the line between personal freedom and social respect truly lies. Do you think the “double permission” makes this acceptable, or was kissing the roommate a step too far regardless? And how should the ex-boyfriend have handled his true feelings? Share your thoughts below!

Community Opinions

Most sided firmly against the original poster and the roommate, though a vocal few pointed out that everyone involved played a part in this chaotic mess.

ADVERTISEMENT

u/One-Organization970
Being straight and in your early 20's sounds exhausting, lol.

u/Sure-Appearance-2769 ESH This post helped remind me why I don’t miss being in my early 20s lol, everyone is such an idiot at that age. Your ex sucks for giving...

u/fivehots
Haha you’re just trash. Young age isn’t an excuse. YTA

ADVERTISEMENT

u/earlgreypoirot like yes… it was two weeks after you ended a three year relationship with his roommate 😭😭 but also feels gross to me the way this Pauly guy was...

u/tgobin94
Another incestuous friend group. Yeah you suck, yeah the AH and so is his roommate

u/BigWeinerDemeanor
YTA get out that damn house.
Jesus Christ.
Pauly seems s*** and this is so messy and classless.
WTF were you thinking.
Permission doesn’t make it right.

ADVERTISEMENT

u/Legitimate-Agency282 This is just messy. Regardless of "permission", you should have thr critical thinking ability to know kissing your ex's roommate 2 weeks after a break up is messy and...

u/Extension-Nebula-235
The amount of times "permission" was used in this post made me vomit.

ADVERTISEMENT

u/Silent_INTJ
Absolutely not. Your all free to do whatever. They are just salty people.

u/Good_Ad8057
Yes.
You’re creating drama for yourself.
Very stupid.
Also the fact that he calls himself Pauly just screams douche bag

u/Obi_Yaj_ Blaming Josh for giving permission is wild. You have no free will?? “Well, he has permission so I have no choice here.” Wild. Yeah, you suck. I’d say Josh...

ADVERTISEMENT

u/potentatewags
You and Paul are both absolutely the ah's here.
Your ex may as well go f your best friend.
Would that make you feel ok? Probably not.

u/horseduckman NTA and they are. Pauly asked a crazy question. Josh gave a crazy answer. Rinse. Repeat. Two boys driven by ego and toxic masculinity. You got caught in the...

u/Kidd__ TLDR: NTA but not free of guilt either. It’s a moral grey zone. Getting intimate with your ex’s friend so soon after a breakup really paints a bad picture....

ADVERTISEMENT

And a few reminded everyone that youth and immaturity were the real culprits behind these spectacularly poor decisions.

Navigating the treacherous waters of post-breakup friendships is never simple, especially when roommates and unspoken rules are involved. While some argue that technical permission clears the slate, others believe that common sense and basic respect should override any bizarre verbal contracts.

Do you think she was justified by the so-called double permission, or did she cross an unforgivable line by kissing his roommate? And how would you handle the fallout if your friend group turned into a messy love triangle?

ADVERTISEMENT

Share your hot take below!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *