Woman Feels ‘Ripped Off’ After $100 Mother’s Day Brunch Serves Stale Rolls and Disposable Cups

We all know that moment when a long-awaited celebration feels more like a costly mistake than a special treat. For one mother, a highly anticipated 3:00 p.m. reservation at a scenic stone castle restaurant quickly devolved from a dreamy full-service dinner into a frustratingly expensive buffet experience. What was meant to be a sophisticated meal turned into a race against the clock as the staff began breaking down the stations shortly after her arrival. Want the juicy details on this holiday disaster?

Woman Feels 'Ripped Off' After $100 Mother’s Day Brunch Serves Stale Rolls and Disposable Cups

Would I be the jerk if I wrote a negative review about a Mother’s Day brunch?

The stage is set with high expectations, as the family relies on a decade-old memory of elegance and a lack of online updates.

So my son made a reservation at a restaurant I’d been to once years ago. I remembered having really good food in a really cool setting—a beautiful old stone castle,...

I checked out the website but didn’t see anything about a Mother’s Day brunch, and he made reservations for 3:00. He too hadn’t seen anything on the website about a...

When we arrived on time for our reservation, they asked for payment upfront of $100 per person and then added on a ten percent kitchen surcharge in addition to tax,...

This was a complete surprise—not only that it was a brunch, but also that it was so pricey.

I am a pretty picky eater, and I’m not a fan of buffets in general, but I agreed because we basically had very few decent options at 3:00 on Mother’s...

As the meal progresses, the gap between the premium price tag and the actual quality of the food begins to widen.

The little bit I ate was good, even though I got the last dregs of the prime rib and they even gave me the end crust, which I found to...

However, the horseradish sauce was delicious and the small edible slice of meat was actually enough for me since I eat very little.

I also had a scoop of plain unremarkable mashed potatoes and a salad with blue cheese dressing which was very tasty, but there were no croutons, which I would have...

ADVERTISEMENT

Unfortunately, my roll was stale and the various desserts I tried were mediocre.

They started cleaning up and closing down the restaurant not long after we got there, at about 5:00, I suppose.

They also had king crab legs, pork ribs, meatloaf, and lamb, lobster pasta, and lots of breakfast stuff, but they were out of pancake batter.

ADVERTISEMENT

The onion soup wasn’t good at all, according to the others.

They offered ramen, and the small sushi bar offered only two types of sushi and shared half the table with the ho-hum desserts.

All in all, it was quite small and very compact—just your basic low-budget "Everyday Sunday" buffet.

ADVERTISEMENT

We all agreed it was about a 6 on a scale of 10. Everyone said the desserts were mediocre, and the mimosas were made with the cheapest champagne while the...

For the price, it was a disappointment for all of us.

The frustration peaks as the author compares the current lackluster service to past experiences where the same price felt like a bargain.

ADVERTISEMENT

We’ve been to the Huntington Gardens Mother’s Day buffet on several occasions and it is $100 per person now, but it’s worth it with lavish displays on rows and rows...

It’s about 10 times bigger and more extravagant than what we experienced yesterday.

The mimosas are served by the elegant and proper wait staff.

ADVERTISEMENT

Plus, one has access to the gorgeous gardens, all for a paltry $100 per person—paltry in comparison to yesterday‘s disappointing experience which left me feeling ripped off.

So would I be the jerk if I put a negative review about the restaurant, basically saying what I’ve said here?

Community Opinions

The community was deeply divided, with many industry veterans defending the restaurant's holiday chaos while others were appalled by the $100 price tag for plastic cups.

ADVERTISEMENT

u/VantaFables
u paid $100 for stale rolls and disposable cups, yeah

u/Legion1117 You describe a high-end buffet with prime rib, sushi, lamb, lobster pasta and then turn around and call it "a basic low budget" buffet. TBH, this sounds like you're...

u/javlafan2 First rule of holiday restaurant visits--DON'T. The staff do not really want to work on a holiday, it is always overcrowded and over priced. STAY HOME do your celebrating...

ADVERTISEMENT

u/Randill746
"King crab legs, lobster pasta and lamb" " your everyday sunday buffet" huh?

u/Vivid_Percentage5560
How do you not call the restaurant ahead of time? I wouldn’t write a review but speak to the GM instead.

u/Ok_Effort9915 Brunch at 3pm? I don’t eat breakfast or lunch at that time. Also, OP — YTJ You didn’t even pay for your free meal but still need to complain...

ADVERTISEMENT

u/masterchef2309 As someone who has worked in the restaurant industry for 2 decades, yes, you would be a jerk. You could have said something then, but everyone in your group...

u/ceruveal_brooks I’m a little confused…this was brunch but the reservation was at 3:00 and you got there around 5:00? Either way, you had a poor experience and overpaid, there’s nothing...

u/MaximumBandi No you wouldn't be the jerk for leaving an honest review. Just keep it fair and factual.mention the unexpected pricing, buffet set up, and service timing, without overly emotional...

ADVERTISEMENT

u/Jmfroggie YTJ. Because NO ONE thought to call the restaurant for answers to your questions so you came at the END of brunch, expecting dinner at 3pm, then got mad...

u/CadillacMatt6216 Things that are on you, not the restaurant: \* That it was a buffet. That's your fault. \* The price. You knew it and you paid it. Honestly I'd...

u/Icy_Calligrapher7088 Yes, ytj, don’t go to a buffet and complain about it being a buffet. No one forced you to eat there. Your review of a buffet, as someone who...

ADVERTISEMENT

u/Time_Tutor_3042 I'm very torn on this one, as is not the buffets fault you're a picky eater so didn't try much for your $100 Then again your bread rolls were...

u/nopulsehere Mother’s Day is the busiest and the worst day to go out to eat. Most restaurants go from being empty to fully packed in the span of 15-30 minutes....

u/FloydianSlip212 I completely understand wanting to take mom out and make it a special day for her. But I'm always surprised anytime someone who has ever been to a restaurant...

ADVERTISEMENT

While some felt the author was being overly critical of a late-afternoon buffet, others couldn't get past the 'stale rolls' and 'disposable cups' at such a high price point.

This situation highlights the delicate balance between consumer expectations and the logistical nightmares of holiday dining. On one hand, the restaurant failed to provide the ‘castle-like’ elegance promised by its setting; on the other, the family’s late arrival and lack of prior research contributed to the friction.

ADVERTISEMENT

Was the restaurant’s service truly subpar for the price, or did the author’s picky nature and late timing sour the experience? And how would you handle being asked for $100 upfront for a surprise buffet? Share your hot take below! Drop your thoughts in the comments. Read more restaurant stories here.

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *