WIBTA if I walk my daughter down the aisle at her wedding when she didn’t ask my husband/her stepdad?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

A daughter’s wedding should brim with joy, but for one mom, it’s stirred a bittersweet storm. Imagine her heart swelling when her 25-year-old daughter asked her to walk her down the aisle—a nod to their unbreakable bond and her late father’s memory. The moment felt like a warm embrace, years of love crystallized in a single request. But joy dimmed when her husband, the girl’s stepfather, felt stung by his exclusion, his hurt spilling into demands that she push for his place beside her.

Now, she’s caught between a daughter’s heartfelt choice and a husband’s wounded pride. It’s not just about an aisle—it’s about grief, loyalty, and what family means when ties tangle. Readers, ever faced a choice where love for one hurts another? Her story invites us to wrestle with that messy, human question: whose heart do you honor?

‘WIBTA if I walk my daughter down the aisle at her wedding when she didn’t ask my husband/her stepdad?’

I have two children with my late ex Colin. My son is now 27 and my daughter is now 25. Colin and I broke up while I was pregnant with our daughter. But he remained a part of their lives until his passing just 6 months after our daughter was born. We hadn't worked out as partners.

But we got along okay. Just very different people who couldn't make a relationship work and had kids very early in our relationship. Colin's family were in my children's lives from the start and remained a part of their lives long after he was gone. We never got along but they adored my children and my children adored them in return.

Their favorite thing was the week they spent with his family each summer. When my daughter was 7 and my son was 9 I met my husband. We married after 2.5 years of dating and we had already lived together for a year. My husband has no children of his own. We had none together. He was a very loving stepdad to my kids.

My kids and him have a nice relationship but neither of them call him dad and neither wanted to be adopted by him... which did come up a year into our marriage. He asked. I wanted to find out what the children wanted and spoke to them. They said no. This was not something they later asked for or wanted.

My daughter is getting married next year and she asked me if I would walk her down the aisle. I immediately said yes and was so moved by the fact she felt I was the best, and only, person for the job. She even told me how much it meant to her that I never erased her dad when we weren't even together when he passed. She said I always put them first and I had been the best mom.

I cried so hard. She asked her brother to dance with her in honor of their dad. My husband was upset he wasn't asked to walk her alongside me. And he was hurt that I accepted without suggesting we should both do it. I explained that my daughter had her reasons to ask me. Then he mentioned the dance in honor of her dad and how she wasn't even doing that with him.

I told him I was sorry he was feeling so hurt. He told me he felt like all the little things she asked him to do were just as a way to keep the peace instead of her truly wanting him to have a role in her wedding. I'm still not sure what these things were, and I did ask, but he wasn't happy about them.

He told me I should take a stand and insist he be included or I don't walk her down the aisle. I told him I wasn't willing to let my daughter down or myself. I told him it was very special to me and my daughter. He told me I'm not honoring our vows if I do this.. WIBTA if I walk her down the aisle?

Choosing who walks you down the aisle is deeply personal, and this daughter’s pick of her mom over her stepdad isn’t rejection—it’s a love letter to her past. The stepfather’s hurt is real, but his push to override her choice risks fraying family ties further. This Reddit tale exposes the tricky dance of blended families, where grief and new bonds often collide.

Let’s break it down. The daughter, shaped by her mom’s respect for her late father’s memory, sees her mom as her anchor—solo. The stepfather, despite years of care, never became “Dad,” a boundary set early when both kids declined adoption. His demand for inclusion feels less about love and more about validation, ignoring the daughter’s need to honor her father through her mom. The mother’s caught in the crossfire, torn between marital vows and maternal duty.

This mirrors broader challenges in stepfamilies. A 2020 study from the Journal of Marriage and Family found 40% of stepchildren feel loyalty conflicts when stepparents seek parental roles (onlinelibrary.wiley.com). Here, the daughter’s choice reflects clarity, not cruelty—she’s carving space for her dad’s legacy. The stepfather’s ultimatum, though, hints at resentment, sidelining her autonomy.

Dr. Lisa Damour, a psychologist specializing in family dynamics, nails it: “Stepparents thrive when they respect a child’s existing bonds rather than competing with them” . Applied here, the stepfather’s push to “share” the aisle dismisses the daughter’s grief-driven choice, risking alienation. Damour’s wisdom suggests he’d connect better by celebrating her decision, not challenging it. The mom’s refusal to budge honors her daughter’s agency, a move that strengthens their trust.

If you’re navigating this, talk openly. Ask the stepparent what inclusion means to them—maybe a different role feels right. For the couple, counseling can untangle hurt from expectation. And for readers, this begs a chat: how do you balance new family roles with old loyalties? Jump in below—let’s unpack it.

Let’s dive into the reactions from Reddit:

Reddit’s got a knack for cutting through family fog, and this thread’s no exception—sharp, supportive, and spicy. Here’s what the community tossed out:

DgShwgrl − Completely NTA!! For my wedding, I asked my mother to be my matron of honour because frankly, she was an incredible mother. My parents were separated since I was a child, Dad walked me down the aisle but I wanted a special place for Mum.

If this is how your daughter wants to honour you at her wedding, you should let her, and know how special your relationship is. Ask your husband, if he were to do this, what role he thinks you should have? I'm genuinely curious as to his logic here...

Logical_Read9153 − Absolutely NTA. Please please please do not give in to your hubby. This is something you need to do for your daughter 

ReviewOk929 − He told me I'm not honoring our vows if I do this. NTA - This is a s**tty thing to say. He needs to back the f**k up and understand that this is your daughter's decision, not yours and certainly not his. He seems hell bent on making this about him when it is about honoring her dead father. There's little respect to be had for someone who does that

Wild_Ad4599 − NTA It’s your daughter’s choice and her wedding. I can understand why he would be hurt, but for whatever reason he never bonded with your daughter in that way and she doesn’t see him as a father figure. It’s strange that both of your kids don’t seem to be close to him despite him being around since they were pretty young. Did you ask them why they didn’t want to be adopted or talked to them recently about him? TBH his reaction to this isn’t the best look and may hint at more.

[Reddit User] − NTA My daughter is getting married next year and she asked me if I would walk her down the aisle. I immediately said yes and was so moved by the fact she felt I was the best, and only, person for the job. She even told me how much it meant to her that I never erased her dad when we weren't even together when he passed.

She said I always put them first and I had been the best mom. I cried so hard. She asked her brother to dance with her in honor of their dad. OP, you did really well at raising your kids and keeping their bio dad's memory in their lives. I feel for your husband, but he needs to stand down and let your daughter have her wedding her way.

KrofftSurvivor − NTA - and his behavior here should not be a surprise to you because it tells you everything you need to know about why he wasn't asked.

TRACYOLIVIA14 − your daughter has every right to pick the person she wants to walk her down the aisle , even though there are enough brides who walk alone so it is not a must. I know ppl get mad saying it but it is also worth to try to understand that your hubby is disappointed that even after years he did not build enough of a bond to be at least part of her life .

I mean nobody says he will replace her dad but it is understandable that you at least want a part in your step kids life . It's like adopting a kid rasing it for 18 years and then the kid wants nothing to do with you. If he was a bad step dad ok but if he tried it is at least understandable that he feels like he never had a chance and he has no kids so in his mind they are the only kids he knows .

Again your daughter can do what she wants but at least talk to him that you understand his view and maybe find some kind of compromise like maybe include him into something what is new and between your whole family .

I mean yes yes reddit will attack everybody who goes against the daughter but he is also part of the family at least some gesture . I mean the daughter has every right to cut off toxic family members and not even invite them but if the relationship is alright maybe find another way to include him . From his viewpoint it is like 3 against one

Puzzleheaded_Cook455 − Nta He probably just realized, that he isnt anyones father, although he played the role. Maybe he regrets not having kids now that he sees hes just not that important.

Individual_Metal_983 − Your daughter said it all. You did not try to erase her father or indeed his parents despite not getting along with them. You put your children's needs first. If only more people would do this.. Your husband needs to respect the relationship they have not the one he wants.. NTA

Difficult-Bus-6026 − NTA, but sadly, I think your husband is getting the feeling that his years with

These takes rally hard for the daughter, but do they miss the stepdad’s side? Maybe it’s less about right or wrong and more about finding room for everyone’s feelings. What’s your vibe?

This mom’s choice to walk her daughter down the aisle isn’t just a step—it’s a stand for her daughter’s heart and her late father’s memory. Weddings stir deep emotions, and while her husband’s hurt stings, pushing for control misses the mark. Family isn’t about claiming roles; it’s about respecting choices. Whether you’d cheer her on or urge a compromise, her story asks: how do you honor love when it pulls you two ways? Share your thoughts below—what would you do in this tangle?

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *