WIBTA if I go on vacation with my grandparents when my stepsister wants to come too?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Imagine a summer breeze carrying the promise of a dream vacation, only for it to stir up a family feud. For one 16-year-old, a trip with her maternal grandparents—a cherished link to her late mother—has sparked tension at home. Her stepsister Emma, craving the same warmth, wasn’t invited, and now the girl’s caught in a whirlwind of guilt and loyalty. Her dad and stepmom’s pressure to stand up for Emma feels like a storm cloud over her sunny plans, pulling readers into a heartfelt clash of family ties.

This story paints a vivid picture of blended family life, where love and boundaries tangle like vines. The girl’s longing to honor her grandparents’ invitation battles the sting of Emma’s exclusion, making every choice feel like a tightrope walk. Readers will connect with her struggle, wondering how to balance personal joy with family expectations in a home buzzing with unspoken tensions.

‘WIBTA if I go on vacation with my grandparents when my stepsister wants to come too?’

This involves me (16f) and my stepsister Emma (16f). My dad married Emma's mom when we were 4. My mom died when I was 6 months old, Emma's dad died when she was 1 year old. My mom's family was big and never left my life. Emma's dad was not the best and his family were never really that involved in hers.

When my parents got married conflict happened between them and my mom's family, because they didn't embrace Emma as another grandchild. This resulted in my dad saying I could no longer see them and them taking him to court and my grandparents being awarded grandparents visitation with me.

This includes one overnight a month and six added hours of time with me, it also included time over Christmas. And two weeks in the summer. My time with my grandparents has always been a source of conflict and my dad always makes me feel like wanting time with them is wrong. Emma and her mom aren't much better.

They have told me before that by wanting to keep my relationship with my extended family, I am being unfair to her.. The whole thing has made for a very tense relationship between us all. My grandparents planned a pretty cool vacation for me and the rest of the family this summer, because we lost out on a lot of time when cases were high,

and my grandpa is vulnerable so it was important to protect him. Emma found out about it via my dad, who had to be alerted they were taking me out of state. She said she wanted to go. My parents told me to ask and I did. My grandparents said no which I expected. I told my dad. Emma is upset.

I know part of her upset is she never gets treated like that. None of her bio grandparents are in the picture (her mom's parents are very distant) and my dad's parents while involved, don't really have much to spoil anyone with.

But she sees me get more and I know it bothers her. But I understand my mom's family not including her and I still want to go. But at home I am being made to feel like I should be standing up for Emma and refusing to go if they won't take her as well.. WIBTA if I go?

Navigating a blended family can feel like tiptoeing through a minefield, and this teen’s vacation saga proves it. The conflict pits her bond with her grandparents against her stepsister’s desire for inclusion, revealing the tricky dance of loyalty and boundaries. “Blended families thrive when roles and expectations are clear,” says Dr. Patricia Papernow, a stepfamily expert. Her research highlights that forcing connections, like expecting grandparents to embrace a stepchild, often backfires.

ADVERTISEMENT

The OP’s grandparents, still grieving their daughter, fought for visitation rights to stay close to their granddaughter. Their decision to exclude Emma likely protects this sacred bond, not a slight against her. Emma’s hurt is real—she sees the OP’s special treatment and feels left out—but a 2020 study shows 42% of stepchildren grapple with divided loyalties, often intensified by parental pressure.

Dr. Papernow advises, “Stepparents should support kids’ ties to their biological family without demanding inclusion.” The OP’s dad and stepmom’s guilt trips unfairly burden her with adult conflicts. They could help Emma by fostering her own relationships, perhaps with her distant maternal grandparents, rather than leaning on OP to fix her pain.

ADVERTISEMENT

For the OP, joining the vacation honors her emotional needs and her grandparents’ rights. She can show empathy by talking openly with Emma, acknowledging her feelings while holding her ground. Family counseling could untangle these knots, as Papernow suggests, building trust through honest dialogue. This approach keeps the peace without forcing the OP to sacrifice her connection to her mother’s family.

Here’s the comments of Reddit users:

Reddit’s finest didn’t shy away from this family drama, serving up a platter of support with a side of sass. Here’s the unfiltered scoop from the crowd:

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] − NTA. None of the background conflict should be your problem, and the adults in your life are the AHs for not shielding you from it better. It sounds like grandparents might resent stepmother (and therefore Emma) as a 'replacement' for their daughter, but further speculation would require more facts (that aren't relevant).. It's not your job to mediate conflict between your parents and grandparents.

newbeginingshey − NTA and this is so unfair to you. It is very wrong to make a child feel guilty for wanting to spend time with their family, and in this case, the surviving relatives of your deceased mother. You have a right to know your mother’s family and they do not need to include the new family of their former son-in-law as an access fee to see you.

ADVERTISEMENT

HumbleOrganization71 − Look. You can’t force relationships with people. That’s an unfair expectation. Maybe t here’s more to this story about your dad and step mom wanting Emma to be recognized right away instead of giving your mom’s family time to acclimate, I don’t know.. But.

I will say this they lost their daughter shortly after becoming grandparents to you and that had to be absolutely devastating. So them wanting to spend time with you and have you for vacation is not unreasonable whatsoever.

And the fact that 12+ years ago your dad wanted your MATERNAL grandparents to accept a child that has no relation to you and they were not comfortable with that was not a good enough reason for your dad to stomp on their boundaries and keep you from them.

ADVERTISEMENT

Losing a child is horrendous, no matter how old they are. Then having you kept from them over a petty matter is absurd. I would have sued for grand parents rights too. You are their grandchild. Not Emma. I feel for Emma not having a great extended family, but when your dad made the choice to marry her mom and become her stepdad,

that didn’t automatically give her a right to YOUR extended family. That’s a huge difference. Go on vacation, please, guilt-free. You have not nor continue to do anything wrong by having a relationship with your mother’s family.. NTA. ETA: thank you for the awards! My first ever!

Julia070000 − Nta go enjoy time with your mother's family it's so important to you your all the adults in your life suck and the should not be surprised when you move out ASAP

ADVERTISEMENT

ClothesQueasy2828 − NTA. Emma is not a member of your mother's family. While I understand why she wants to go, you should not cancel your trip in solidarity. Your grandparents get to decide who's invited, and Emma was not. On a broader scale, it's important for both you and your mother's family to keep the links to each other. If Emma has to be invited to everything, that may damage your relationship with them.

Rohini_rambles − NTA. They are your family and love you. your dad is to blame for Emma feeling left out because he doesn't like the fact that his first in-laws are active in your life. You AREN'T being unfair to anyone by spending time with your family.

It sounds like Emma could have been embraced if she was nicer to you, and your parents kinder to them. Your grandparents surely would have seen her as OP's sister, if not another grandchild if your father and Emma's mom had been interested in that setup.

ADVERTISEMENT

Go enjoy your vacation OP. Your dad is being unfair to you by not supporting you in bonding with your mom's family. It sucks for Emma that she doesn't have grandparents who love her, but she has to learn to manage that emotionally.

[Reddit User] − Nta. Everyone else is though. Next time its brought up ask them how is it unfair of you to Emma to continue your relationship but not unfair of all of them to ask you to dismiss the only connection to your mom? Just. Because emmas dad’s family aren’t around doesn’t mean they can punish you for your mom’s family being there.

Bubbly_Satisfaction2 − NTA. But your father and stepmom sure are... Is the maternal side of your family well-off (a.k.a. 'have money')? If so, this may be the motivation behind your dad and stepmother wanting Emma to be considered a part of their family. Plus, they want them to babysit and take Emma off of their hands, so they can have the occasional 'child-free' time.

ADVERTISEMENT

mltrout715 − I am confused. Why would your mom's parents be expected to be part of the life of your dad's stepdaughter? That makes zero sense.

sixyrs − Go enjoy that vacation, NTA

Redditors backed the OP’s right to her grandparents’ love, throwing shade at the adults for turning her into the family referee. Some sympathized with Emma’s envy but insisted it’s not OP’s burden; others called Dad’s guilt trips a low blow. Are these spicy takes spot-on, or just fanning the flames?

ADVERTISEMENT

This story of summer plans and family friction reminds us how tangled love can get in blended households. The OP’s choice to join her grandparents honors her roots, but Emma’s hurt lingers like an uninvited guest. It’s a messy, human tale of balancing loyalty with personal needs. She’s choosing her path, and that’s her right. How would you navigate this family tug-of-war? Drop your thoughts below and let’s keep the convo going!

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *