WIBTA for not apologizing to the people who live next to my airbnb?

When it comes to being a good neighbor, especially as a landlord or Airbnb host, the lines of responsibility can get blurry. One host faced backlash after a BBQ at their rental unit accidentally started a fire, putting nearby residents in danger. The neighbors expected an apology, but the host didn’t feel responsible.

This sparked a heated debate online — should hosts apologize for their guests’ actions? In an age where Airbnb rentals are becoming increasingly common, the question of owner accountability in residential neighborhoods has never been more relevant. Let’s dive into what happened and how people reacted.

‘WIBTA for not apologizing to the people who live next to my airbnb?’

From a legal, ethical, and community-centered standpoint, Airbnb hosts have a clear duty of care—not only toward their guests but also toward the permanent residents living nearby. According to property law and tenant safety experts, short-term rental owners are expected to mitigate foreseeable risks, such as fires, noise complaints, and unauthorized activities, especially when their business model operates in residential neighborhoods.

Failing to apologize after a near-emergency can appear negligent and dismissive, even if no one was hurt. It erodes trust and heightens tensions with neighbors, which can ultimately lead to calls for local ordinances to restrict short-term rentals altogether.

Moreover, risk management professionals strongly recommend hosts take proactive steps: providing essential fire safety equipment, establishing clear house rules (including BBQ limitations), and communicating openly with neighbors to address any concerns before they escalate.

Replacing the neighbor’s used fire extinguisher, offering a sincere apology, and reaffirming a commitment to safe hosting practices would not only be morally sound but also strategically wise for long-term business sustainability. Maintaining good relationships with neighbors isn’t just a nice gesture—it’s smart risk management.

Here’s how people reacted to the post:

Reddit users unanimously declared the OP as YTA. The overwhelming sentiment was that owning property means taking responsibility. Even if the host wasn’t present, the fire happened under their roof — and the neighbors quite literally helped save it from further damage.

Others voiced frustration about Airbnb in general, particularly in residential areas. Several pointed out that short-term rentals can strain neighborhood relationships, drive up housing costs, and often bring irresponsible or disruptive guests into otherwise quiet communities. The host’s attitude, especially their unwillingness to acknowledge the incident, only amplified the resentment.

While the fire was ultimately contained and no one was injured, the emotional toll and potential danger were very real. As an Airbnb host, taking responsibility — at least enough to apologize and offer gratitude — isn’t just courteous, it’s part of being a conscientious member of a community. What do you think? Should short-term rental owners be held accountable for the behavior and mistakes of their guests? Would a simple apology have been enough? Let us know in the comments below.