[UPDATE] I [19F] am being excluded from our gaming group. I decide to find a new group. Boyfriend [20M] is the one upset?

Picture a quiet summer evening, the hum of a gaming PC filling a cozy bedroom as a 19-year-old woman clicks through online forums, her face lit with cautious hope. She’s been pushed out of her gaming group, sidelined by a toxic player and, shockingly, unsupported by her boyfriend. Her story of exclusion struck a chord with many, sparking heated discussions online. For those who want to read the previous part: (I [19F] am being excluded from our gaming group. I decide to find a new group. Boyfriend [20M] is the one upset?). Now, she’s back with an update—new groups, an apology, and a fresh perspective.

This tale isn’t just about gaming; it’s about resilience, communication, and rebuilding trust. After joining a new crew and confronting her boyfriend’s missteps, she’s navigating a delicate balance between independence and love. Her journey invites readers to reflect: How do you rebuild after betrayal? And when does an apology truly mend a fracture?

‘[UPDATE] I [19F] am being excluded from our gaming group. I decide to find a new group. Boyfriend [20M] is the one upset?’

Thank you everyone for all the advice! And thank you to those that also offered to play with me. I wasn't expecting my post to get so many replies. Unfortunately, I had some unrelated family business, so I couldn't respond to you all. However, I have read everything and have taken all your words into consideration.

Some people have also asked me questions about how we can play so often, how long I've been with my boyfriend, etc., so I'll just give a brief background (skip to the next line if you don’t want to read it). First off, most of us are college students [18/20], either working part time or staying at home with our parents.

As of right now, most of us are on summer break. We only have two older members in the group, which are R [25/M] and another guy [23/M]. The rest of us are or fall under 20. R is actually married and his wife makes good bank, so he has a ton of free time. Second, about my boyfriend. Surprisingly we met through the gaming group, as he was the one who advertised it, which was how I found and joined the group.

That was about 2 years ago, and about a couple of months after we met, we just clicked and started dating. My boyfriend has known R for about 3 years, so they're close friends. However, R did not join the group until 6 months ago, as my boyfriend invited him because he thought it'd be fun to have him there too.

I did not know much of R, other than that he was my boyfriend's friend, until he joined the group. So, after I posted my original post, I signed up for 2 different groups. The first one was an all-women’s group [16-20F]. They responded to me pretty quickly. They were very nice and polite, but explained that they only play once/twice a week. Unfortunately, that didn't cut it for me.

The second group responded to me the next day, and I learned that they were more active but that they're also an all-men’s group [17-19M]. However, they were open to having me there. At first, I felt pretty sketched, but the oldest and most popular guy [19/M] there took me aside and explained to me that he does not tolerate any type of harassment and that he will definitely kick out any of the other guys if they were bothering me.

Hearing that made me feel more comfortable and I played some games with them. I had so much fun! All the guys were really nice and friendly. No s**ual remarks, no more screaming of profanity against women, etc.. It was nice being in a group of people who were happy to play with me. After I finished my games and left, my boyfriend called and asked if we could talk.

When he came over, before I could even ask or speak myself, he told me he was really sorry and that he screwed up big time, and he understands how wrong he was. He said he didn't want me to go to a new group because he feared that I would leave him too for some new guy.

Then he told me that he didn't realize how hurt I was from being excluded from the group because I had never complained or voiced against it, which was true. I never complained about the exclusions, or even R’s behavior before, because I knew it would just cause more conflict. I also didn't want my boyfriend to stop playing with his friends because of me.

I explained this to him, and he said he was sorry for not defending and comforting me like he should have been in the first place. To my surprise, he then showed me his text messages between him and R that happened a few months ago. Apparently, way before my exclusion, R had a few conversations with my boyfriend, telling him how much of a pain it was to play with me there.

He wanted my boyfriend to kick me out. However, my boyfriend refused and told R that was not happening. Then, around the time when I decided to stop hanging out around R, that's when R sent a group text to everyone in the group explaining how he doesn't want to play with the group again, and he hopes everyone understands.

Everyone, and to my shock, even my best friend, all agreed with him. Only my boyfriend protested, but R was really stubborn and he had the whole group to support him, so my boyfriend gave up. After showing me those texts, he told me next that he kicked R from their group earlier today.

R was not allowed to play with them anymore, but my boyfriend said he'd still be willing my play with R one on one, but only like once a month. Surprisingly, R agreed, and that was that. My boyfriend said he understood if I didn't want to be with him anymore, but said that he truly does love me. Honestly, even after all that has happened, I'm not mad at my boyfriend.

This is both of ours first relationship, and we’re still learning. He's always been kind to me and I’ve never had a problem with him before this situation occurred. I feel happy that he realized his mistakes and did apologize without me asking. This is the first time he's ever come across a situation where he has no choice but to choose a side, so I don't blame him for trying to do anything to keep the group together.

He told me he would also like me to come back to our old group, but he said it's completely fine if I stay with my new group. He knows it was wrong of him to ask me not to join a new group. I told him I don't think I'll ever come back to the old group and that I will definitely be sticking with my new group from now on.

However, I will always make time for him and put him first. He accepted it without any protest, and we went back to our usual fun activities. I feel bad that my boyfriend may have lost a close friend since I never asked him to do any of that for me. Regardless, I am happy, and lately my boyfriend and I have been spending more time together now that R isn't around as much.

I have also continued playing with my new group and it's been awesome. If you've made it this far, thanks for reading this long update! Sorry for the ramble and mistakes, my mind is all over the place right now and I wanted to explain as much as I could. Thank you guys once again!.

Group dynamics can turn a fun hobby into a social tightrope. This young woman’s exclusion from her gaming group, driven by R’s toxic behavior, exposed cracks in her relationship and her circle. Her boyfriend’s initial failure to defend her, followed by his fear-driven reaction to her joining a new group, points to a common relationship hurdle: balancing individual needs with partnership.

Social exclusion isn’t trivial. A 2022 study from the Journal of Social Psychology found that being ostracized can lower self-esteem and increase anxiety (tandfonline.com). Her silence about R’s misogyny, to avoid conflict, mirrors a broader issue—many young women suppress discomfort to keep the peace in male-dominated spaces like gaming.

Dr. Harriet Lerner, a psychologist and author, emphasizes, “Apologies require accountability and change, not just words” ( psychologytoday ). Her boyfriend’s apology and decision to remove R show growth, but his choice to maintain limited contact with R raises questions about boundaries. This situation highlights the need for clear communication in relationships, especially in young love.

She’s made a smart move by sticking with her new, respectful group. To strengthen her relationship, she could set explicit boundaries about R’s influence and continue voicing her needs.

Here’s what the community had to contribute:

Reddit’s reactions are as lively as a boss battle! From cheers for her new group to side-eyes at her boyfriend’s lingering tie to R, the community weighed in with gusto:

[Reddit User] − I told him I don't think I'll ever come back to the old group and that I will definitely be sticking with my new group from now on. I think this is a good choice, OP. And, aside from your boyfriend's initial reaction, you both handled this pretty well. Good luck with your new group and with your boyfriend :)

TheBatmanToMyBruce − I don't like R. All he ever does is degrade and talk about are women who are 'back-stabbing bitches who you can never trust'. It's sad, but some people are just like tha--. R is actually married and his wife makes good bank, so he has a ton of free time. Wait what. Does she stab him in the back with *money*?

GrundleFace − Glad it worked out. I'm confused by the 'R texted the group' bit though. R wasn't going to play with the group, the group agreed, then your boyfriend kicked him out.. What did I read wrong?

[Reddit User] − OP, I hope you are reconsidering your relationship with your 'best friend,' who had you kicked from the group.

bugsdoingthings − R was not allowed to play with them anymore, but my boyfriend said he'd still be willing my play with R one on one, but only like once a month. I raised my eyebrow a little bit at this. If your BF can continue to maintain boundaries with R, that's great. But I think he might also benefit from reading up on geek social fallacies (just Google 'geek social fallacies' and you should get some good results). Good luck to both of you.

CoffeeMug_of_Victory − I think you handled this situation fairly well and I think both you and your boyfriend learned a lot from it. Sticking with the new group is a fantastic idea, and they sound like a lovely bunch! Though I think I big take-away from this is learning when to tell someone that something is happening or that whatever is happening is making *you* feel uncomfortable.

When I was your age, I rarely spoke up when I should have because I didn't want to cause conflict; but sometimes not saying anything makes the situation worse. My own two cents on this, I don't think it's appropriate for your boyfriend to still be playing with someone who was so aggressive especially to you. A whole other issue, but your boyfriend is responsible for himself and his choices. If R does become an issue again in the future, let boyfriend know. You got this :)

whereisvicsage2 − I don't think it's appropriate for your BF to still hangout with R. R was wildly rude towards you and had the whole group turn on you, including your BF before he came to his senses. R is 25 years old and should know by now his behavior is awful. I wouldn't be surprised if R was still looking to cause trouble between you and your BF just out of weird revenge.

Racecarrrd − You know, your boyfriend did s**ew up, but he did seem to make amends and handle it well afterwards so that does say something about his character. Hopefully this can be a lesson on communication and boundaries for the future. I'm also glad you found a new group and that you fit well with them. It looks like everything worked out!

KingofAces − I just wanted so say kudos to you for standing by your decision to stop talking to R. Even after to pressure from your BF. I've definitely been in your shoes and the pressure to apologize to types like R from the friend circle are insane.

Sadly it seems all to common in nerider circles. I still think it's s**tty that he''s willing to hang out with R. The dude has clearly talked a lot of s**t about you in front of and behind your back. It sucks he doesn't see any problem with spending time with someone like that.

[Reddit User] − Ok so the ending is kinda happy but there is some stuff buried here that should be making you uneasy. Your boyfriend says that he was upset at you doing something on your own because he was worried you'd leave him. This is a huge flag to be aware of.

These takes are spicy, but do they miss the nuances of her evolving relationship?

This gamer’s update is a testament to standing firm and seeking spaces where you’re valued. Her boyfriend’s apology and actions show promise, but the shadow of R lingers, sparking debate. Should she trust his growth, or is his tie to R a red flag? What would you do after an apology that feels sincere but incomplete? Share your thoughts below and let’s unpack this together!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

One Comment