Update : AITA for telling my kids mom that her husband can’t have my kids while she’s deployed?

Venus Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In a quiet California suburb, a father’s heart raced as he faced an unexpected curveball from his ex-wife. Their carefully crafted co-parenting routine—split evenly for their two young sons—was about to be tested. She was deploying overseas for six months, a fact that stirred both concern and opportunity for him. But when she proposed her new husband step into her role to keep their 50/50 custody split, the air thickened with tension. He envisioned full-time dad duty, not sharing with a stepdad he barely trusted.

The stakes were high, not just for him but for his boys, whose stability hung in the balance. Readers, you might feel the sting of this dilemma—balancing legal rights, kids’ needs, and family dynamics. His refusal sparked a firestorm, but was he wrong to stand his ground? Let’s dive into this messy, heartfelt tale of co-parenting under pressure.

For those who want to read the previous part: Original post

‘Update : AITA for telling my kids mom that her husband can’t have my kids while she’s deployed?’

It’s been 16 days since OG post. Before I start, Not once did I say I believe stepdad to be malicious in any way. We don’t get along sure, doesn’t mean he’s a bad person. Next, I understand all the people who said I was TA was because I didn’t talk to my children about their wants. I understand their input matters in this very big decision.

Now, update! I spoke to a lawyer. As suspected, I was completely within my rights. Non-biological parent has no say in the matter. With Mom leaving I am sole guardian. No need to push anything on my end unless they try to, and even then it’s an uphill battle for them to prove I’m unfit. As you can guess, they went to a lawyer also. I never sat down with Mom to discuss how it went.

what I do know is that it didn’t go in their favor. How do I know you may ask? Well, I decided it was time to try and have a private chat with Stepdad. I was able to have a 5 minute conversation with him during my kids sporting event we both conveniently arrived early to. He basically conceded at that point and told me they would just eat the 6 months.

I told him I’d talk to my ex but he asked if I could give her some time. I get it, she just got the bad news, I obliged and left it alone. I did tell him that I wouldn’t stone wall him and that I respected his position in my kids life and that I only flexed back after I felt like they were trying to intimidate me.

We both agreed the way we met didn’t start us off on the right foot and that we should take a step back and view the other’s perspective. I told him (and her eventually) that I was still willing to give time and my intent was never to shut them out. I would like to address that I myself am a child of divorce.

My stepdad raised me and unless you knew me as a child you would have no idea. He deserves to never be reminded that we are not biologically related. He is and always will be the man I try to replicate and look up to. It was never downplaying the role of step parent. I know my children don’t have that relationship with their stepdad and it’s so fresh I don’t expect it.

He is their friend, mentor, and one day I will have to accept that he is also their dad. I saw a lot of step parents responses and if I made you feel a way, I apologize. I respect you. What do the kids want!? Unfortunately, Mom still hasn’t told them about the deployment. Why? Idk. I was able to vaguely ask the right questions to get a feel for what they want. The expectation is they stay with me but still get to see Stepdad.

I respect it, never against it. Ex and I still haven’t discussed what exactly the time split will look like but I did let her know stepdad was my go to if I needed any help, he was still welcome when events arise, and I would keep him involved. After stepdad and I spoke his entire demeanor changed. Regardless of reason, it’s much appreciated. Long story short, still in a sort of l**bo but the future is bright.

This custody tug-of-war feels like a high-stakes chess game, with kids as the most precious pieces. The father’s instinct to take full custody during his ex’s deployment clashes with her wish to preserve normalcy via her husband. Both sides have valid points, but the legal and emotional layers make it tricky. He’s driven by a parent’s primal urge to protect, while she’s grasping for stability in a disruptive time. The stepdad’s push, though, raises eyebrows—why so insistent?

Zooming out, co-parenting conflicts often mirror broader issues of trust and boundaries in blended families. A 2021 study from the American Psychological Association notes that 60% of stepfamilies face tension over parenting roles, often due to unclear expectations. Here, the stepdad’s short tenure—barely two years—fuels the father’s caution, especially since stepparents lack automatic legal rights.

Dr. Patricia Papernow, a stepfamily expert, says, “Stepparents must earn trust gradually, not demand equal footing with biological parents.” Her insight cuts to the core: the stepdad’s role, while meaningful, doesn’t override the father’s legal and emotional primacy. The father’s willingness to allow visitation shows flexibility, but his wariness is justified, given the kids’ young ages and the stepdad’s limited history.

For solutions, open communication is key. The father should facilitate some stepdad time, like weekends, if the kids want it, ensuring their emotional ties stay intact. A family mediator could help formalize agreements, avoiding future clashes. Readers, what do you think—how should they balance the kids’ needs with parental rights? Share your thoughts below!

Check out how the community responded:

The Reddit hive mind didn’t hold back, dishing out a mix of legal takes, parenting advice, and snarky side-eyes. Here’s a peek at the community’s hottest takes, served with a side of humor:

Kapoodles − That's so great to hear! And I'm glad it seems to be ending on a good note thus far! Fingers crossed that mom eases up a bit too, because the children's happiness should come first! And good on you and Stepdad both for being the bigger person.. The kids deserver all the love in the world!

yourlittlebirdie − It’s refreshing to hear people handle things like mature adults.

faaabiii − They were so aggressive before that I was expecting a lot more drama. Glad you and stepdad managed to talk 1on1. I don't trust him, but I can tell he's trying and the kids want to see him, so he can't be all that bad. Good for the kids.

gruntbuggly − I'm glad to hear you got a reasonable outcome, even though it won't all really be known until mom tells the kids about the deployment. My stepdad raised me and unless you knew me as a child you would have no idea. He deserves to never be reminded that we are not biologically related.

He is and always will be the man I try to replicate and look up to. It was never downplaying the role of step parent.. You should say exactly those words to the kid's step-dad. Never hurts to improve the amicability of co-parenting relationships.

blackmamba729 − went to the original post after i came across this. the comments are wild and reddit really shows it age there. a 9 and 11 yo, whilst old enough to voice their opinions, are not old enough to know whats best and decide how this situation plays out. a parents intuition should prevail..

It actually annoyed me that people were giving OP a hard time saying hes ignoring what his kids want. I myself come from a divorced family, i was 9 at the time, way too young to fully understand the dynamics at play. i understand it comes from a good place, and kids voices should be heard, but at that age the parent knows best, provided they are fit to be a parent and in this case, he clearly is.

dohbriste − This is so satisfying adults being adults, keeping the kids best interests in mind all the same. Good for you and stepdad! I hope the 6 months are smooth and uneventful :)

MScottMil − Everyone giving the mom and stepdad props for “communicating” needs read the part of the story where they went to a lawyer and got shut down. They didn’t mature or turn some corner. They were told they had to comply and gave up.

cinnamongirl73 − Dang! You and stepdad talked it out like well-rounded, mature adults? And you’re going to let stepdad still see the kids, and make stepdad emergency contact? Sheesh! What’s the world coming to when people decide to do what’s best for the children? (That’s being snarky, btw) This gives me hope for humanity!!!!

Victor-Grimm − This is a better case scenario than I see on here. I watch enough child custody cases on YouTube. I am talking legit court not scripted crap. Anyone where a step parent is involved the judge doesn’t even want to hear their opinion.

They basically, tell them their say is irrelevant over the birth parents unless they are adopted. It is the same for extended family. I am a retired vet as well that had troop loose kids while deployed. I bet the lawyer told your ex that she needed to let this go or you could put an order in for temporary exclusive custody as soon as she left.

That you could keep him from stepdad the whole time and then potentially be fighting to get back the 50-50 custody upon return. She could possibly been relegated to every other weekend and holidays. The service relief act doesn’t mean s**t when it comes to the best interests of the children.

ghostfromdivaspast − can someone explain to me mom's perspective and why she's so upset? i'm not sure why she even thought that OP wouldn't have the kids full time while she's deployed.

These Reddit gems spark a question: do they nail the real-world complexity of co-parenting, or are they just armchair quarterbacking? Either way, they’ve got us thinking.

This saga of custody and compromise leaves us cheering for the father’s olive branch to the stepdad, even as the ex’s silence on deployment news lingers like an awkward pause. It’s a reminder that co-parenting is less about winning and more about keeping kids’ worlds steady. The father’s journey—from legal battles to a tentative truce—shows grown-ups can, occasionally, act like grown-ups. What would you do if you were in his shoes? Drop your thoughts below—let’s keep this conversation rolling!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *