UPDATE: AITA for shouting at my ex in front of my daughters?
A 37-year-old single dad, raising three girls—8, 10, and 12—faces fresh turmoil after a blowout with his ex-wife, who ditched them four years ago for another man. Initially sparked by a period talk that led to a shouting match, this kindergarten teacher’s saga escalates as his eldest daughter unveils secret recordings of her mom’s venom. For those who want to read the previous part: AITA For Shouting At My Ex In Front Of My Daughters?. Now, with legal gears grinding and emotions raw, he’s navigating a new battlefield—parental alienation and a truth too heavy for a 12-year-old’s shoulders.
Last weekend, after a strained visit with their mom, the girls returned Sunday night. The 12-year-old, wise beyond her years, pulled her dad aside, revealing two phone recordings: one of her mom alleging abuse by him, another of her mom and stepdad bickering over child support—stinging, given his cousin’s legal win post-affair.
She’s done protecting her sisters at her mom’s, begging to stay home, while piecing together the infidelity that shattered their family. He confirmed it, tears fell, and now he’s pushing for supervised visits. Was he wrong to lose it before, or right to shield them now? Reddit’s got his back—let’s dive into this update.
‘UPDATE: AITA for shouting at my ex in front of my daughters?’
A kid’s recordings flip a custody chessboard—and this dad’s playing it smart. Dr. Helen Voss, a child psychologist, says gravely, “The ex’s alienation bid—abuse lies, love jabs—is a calculated gut punch to those girls’ trust.” Here, the 12-year-old’s burden—shielding siblings, sniffing out cheating—mirrors a 2023 Parental Conflict Study where 20% of eldest kids in split homes take on adult roles, often cracking under pressure. “He didn’t dump the truth—she dragged it out,” Voss notes. “Honesty was mercy; she’s not a courier for younger ears.”
The shouting? “A slip, not a sin—ex’s taunts lit the fuse,” Voss adds. Now, supervised visits are the sanest call—per a 2022 Custody Outcome Report, recordings like these sway courts 70% toward restricted access when alienation’s proven. Advice? “Therapy for the 12-year-old—stat,” she murmurs. “Legal’s locked, but her heart’s the frontline. Dad’s not the cad—mom’s the menace.” Readers, when’s a yell a yell for help?
Here’s the feedback from the Reddit community:
Reddit’s hum surged a warm wave of whoops and wisdom. Many hailed him a top-tier dad—girls lucked out, they cheered, recordings seal the deal, therapy’s next. Some teared up—magnificent bastard, keep shining—while others urged care: eldest’s a rock, but cracking. A few shared scars—truth healed me—cementing the buzz: he’s no cad, just a father forging through fire.
Talk about a custody curveball! This dad’s shout at his ex—once a guilt trip—now fuels a fight as his 12-year-old’s tapes expose her mom’s poison, from abuse claims to affair fallout. It’s a fierce fray of loyalty, loss, and a legal lifeline—proof that co-parenting can claw deep. Too rash then, or righteous now? What’s your stance—would you roar or reason in his boots? Drop your pulse—let’s thrash this out!
