They Canceled the Second Date After He Intentionally Ran Over an Animal, Now Their Friends Are Turning on Them

We all know that moment when a seemingly perfect first date takes a sudden, dark turn. For one 21-year-old on a blind date, a pleasant evening of getting to know someone quickly unraveled into a deeply uncomfortable car ride home.

They thought they were just navigating the awkward but hopeful waters of early dating, only to discover a disturbing side to their companion in the blink of an eye. The night went from promising to alarming when a small creature appeared on the road, prompting a reckless reaction that left the poster completely speechless. When friends started defending the date’s shocking behavior, this person had to wonder if their boundaries were actually the problem. Curious how it all unfolded? The full story is right below.

They Canceled the Second Date After He Intentionally Ran Over an Animal, Now Their Friends Are Turning on Them

AITAH for declining a second date with a guy after he ran over an iguana?

The stage was set for what should have been a standard, low-stakes evening of getting to know a potential new partner.

Hi! Long time lurker, first time poster, so the format might be a bit off. Made a new account since a lot of our mutual friends follow me on my...

I got set up on a blind date with Daniel (fake name) by some of our mutual friends, as we've both been in the dating scene for quite a bit....

The comfortable atmosphere shattered completely when the drive home took an unexpected and violent detour.

The date itself was pretty uneventful. We got to know each other, and he genuinely seemed like a pretty cool guy. I was seriously considering a second date with him....

In fact, I think they're one of my favorite animals. This is important. While he's driving me home, we're both chatting away when I suddenly notice an iguana on the...

There weren't many cars on the road lane where it was standing, so I assumed he'd be safe if he ran fast enough. But my date had other plans.

The chilling contrast between his casual amusement and the sudden cruelty left a heavy, suffocating silence in the car.

Without as much of a warning, he swerved into the other lane, running over the iguana, and then laughed about it. I think he said something, but I didn't quite...

ADVERTISEMENT

Once he dropped me off, I told him, "It was lovely meeting you, but I don't think there should be a second date. " Without missing a beat, he asked...

I later realized he blocked me, and now some of our friends said I shouldn't feel bad for an iguana and that I was an AH for not giving him...

The sudden shift from a charming date to an act of intentional harm offers a textbook glimpse into dark personality traits and empathy deficits. Psychologically, finding amusement in the destruction of an animal—even an invasive one—signals a concerning lack of affective empathy. This isn’t just about environmental conservation; it’s about the impulse to cause harm for sheer entertainment.

ADVERTISEMENT

Experts in forensic psychology have long noted that a callous disregard for animal life can be a strong predictor of broader interpersonal violence and a lack of emotional regulation. When Daniel swerved the car, he wasn’t performing a civic duty; he was demonstrating a desire for control and a chilling capacity for cruelty.

Furthermore, his explosive reaction to boundary-setting—resorting immediately to name-calling—reinforces this red flag. Verbal abuse in response to rejection highlights a fragile ego and a lack of respect for a partner’s autonomy. For anyone navigating the early stages of a new relationship, witnessing how a date handles power over vulnerable creatures provides invaluable insight into their true character. If you find yourself in a similar situation, firmly state your boundaries and safely exit the environment. Always prioritize your emotional and physical well-being over social politeness.

Community Opinions

Reddit came in hot and nearly unanimous, with commenters completely horrified by the date's alarming behavior and the mutual friends' baffling defense of it.

ADVERTISEMENT

proceeded to call me a sensitive b**** and then sped off. NTA, bullet dodged.

u/VxGB111
NTA.
Swerving into the opposite lane to kill an animal, then calls you names and acts reckless when called out??? No, you are not the AH here

u/maybe-an-ai
NTA
Never trust people that are wantonly cruel to animals

ADVERTISEMENT

u/Last-Campaign-3373
Why the hell are your friends defending this psychotic behavior?  I think you need new friends. NTA

u/Busy_Rhubarb6818
NTA never has the term bullet dodged rang so keenly

u/johncate73 NTA. He may have killed it because it's an invasive species, but to go out of his way to do it, and then insult you for disapproving? He's the...

ADVERTISEMENT

u/Neverstopstopping82
Your friends are also tools.
Can you also get new friends? What is wrong with people? This makes me sick to read.

u/lilguybigaxe
Based on how he treats animals, you could possibly have received the same treatment :/ You did the right thing and your friends are jerks.
NTA

u/pindvarp420 Finding joy in animal cruelty is the first symptom of psychopathy. If he can kill an innocent animal and laugh about it, who knows what he could do to...

ADVERTISEMENT

u/TechDreamcoat
To do this on a first date is pretty crazy.
I do my best to avoid running animals over, it’s not a good thing.
Bullet dodged. 

u/Druid-Flowers1
Nta, you can date/ don’t have to date , anyone , for any reason.

u/crazybicatlady86
Anyone who enjoys killing animals that much is a monster and should be avoided by everyone

ADVERTISEMENT

u/StandingGoat NTA- Your friends think you should go on a second date with a man who was comfortable with calling you a sensitive b**** on the first date? Get better...

u/spitvalv That’s crazy behavior to intentionally go out of his way to run it over and laugh about it. Especially on a first date… Did he seem like an outdoorsy...

u/Jumpingyros
Animal cruelty to an invasive species is exactly the same as animal cruelty to a native animal.
He’s a sociopath.

ADVERTISEMENT

A few readers pointed out that even if the animal was an invasive species, the sheer joy taken in the act remained an undeniable and massive red flag.

This encounter serves as a stark reminder of how quickly a mask can slip during the early stages of dating. It highlights the complex dynamics of navigating mutual friendships when a serious boundary has been crossed. Do you think the original poster was right to immediately cut ties, or did the friends have a valid point about the invasive species? And how would you handle mutual friends who relentlessly defend this kind of alarming behavior? Share your hot take below!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *