She Broke Up With Her Boyfriend After He Came Out As Asexual, Now Their Friends Are Calling Her Cold

We all know that sudden, sinking feeling when a long-term relationship shifts under our feet. For one twenty-one-year-old woman, this reality hit hard when her partner of five years made a deeply personal revelation. While she wanted to support his self-discovery, the news meant their physical future together would look vastly different.

Caught between her deep history with him and her vision for her youth, she began to distance herself, dreading the emotionally heavy conversation she knew they had to have. When the truth finally came out, it left both of them heartbroken and their friend group completely divided. Can a long-term relationship survive when core physical needs suddenly diverge, or is walking away the only healthy option? Curious how it all unfolded? The full story is right below.

She Broke Up With Her Boyfriend After He Came Out As Asexual, Now Their Friends Are Calling Her Cold

AITW for breaking up with my boyfriend after he came out as asexual because I don’t want to waste my twenties?

Establishing a strong foundation early in life makes sudden shifts feel even more seismic. When a relationship spans your entire late teens, any change to the status quo can feel like the ground is crumbling beneath you.

I (F21) have been with my boyfriend (M23) for almost five years.

A few months ago, he came out as asexual.

He told me he’d spent years trying to convince himself he liked sex because he thought it was expected, but he finally accepted that he just isn’t interested in it.

I told him I supported him, but privately I was freaking out.

I’m only 21.

I don’t want to spend the next decade wondering what it’s like to be with someone who actually wants me.

I don’t want to have to ask for intimacy knowing he’s only doing it out of obligation, and honestly, I don’t want to be in a relationship where sex is...

Avoiding conflict often breeds a slow, painful distance before the storm actually hits. Pulling away silently might feel like self-preservation, but it usually just prolongs the inevitable heartbreak for both partners.

ADVERTISEMENT

The thing is, I never actually told him any of that.

Instead, I started pulling away.

I stopped initiating dates, spent more time out with friends, and found myself checking out other guys.

ADVERTISEMENT

I even caught myself thinking, "I’m too young to settle for this."

Last week, he asked me if something was wrong.

I finally admitted that I didn’t think I could stay in a relationship with someone who’s asexual because I didn’t want to spend my twenties feeling sexually frustrated.

ADVERTISEMENT

He looked absolutely crushed.

He asked if our entire relationship was only worth as much as our sex life.

I said, "Well… kind of."

ADVERTISEMENT

"It’s a pretty big part of a relationship."

He started crying and said he’d spent months terrified I’d leave after he told me, and that I’d just confirmed his biggest fear.

I ended things anyway.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ending a relationship for personal compatibility can invite harsh judgment from those on the outside. When mutual friends only see the sudden breakup, they often miss the quiet struggle that led up to the final decision.

blockquote>

Now, our mutual friends are saying I made his coming out all about me and that I basically told him he’s unlovable unless he can provide sex.

ADVERTISEMENT

I don’t think that’s what I meant, but I can see why it sounded that way.

I still think I made the right decision, but I also know the way I handled it was pretty cold.

Community Opinions

Reddit overwhelmingly backed the original poster, arguing that sexual compatibility is a foundational pillar of any healthy romantic partnership.

ADVERTISEMENT

u/Accomplished_Sock435
Any reason is a valid reason to break up with the someone and a lack of sexual compatibility totally makes sense for a break up

u/EnerGeTiX618 You definitely made the right decision. If your mutual friends believe it's OK to be in a sexless relationship, then they can date him. It is a very big...

u/ClevelandWomble YNW Your ex was finally honest about his sexuality. That was your first opportunity the re-evaluate your relationship in light of that new information. Staying with him would have...

ADVERTISEMENT

u/WinterQueenMab
You shouldn't waste your 20s,30s,40s, 50s, 60s, 70s, or any other decade.
If it doesn't work now, it's not going to work later either

u/theladyorchid YNW Honestly I’m shocked he was “crushed.” If he’d been online at all he could’ve predicted it. It’s something other people talk about. Don’t be concerned about his future...

u/RollingKatamari Would any of these flying monkeys coming at you accept a non sexual relationship when it comes to them??? I get that your ex is sad....but that's the reality...

ADVERTISEMENT

u/Quirky_Masterpiece55
Not wrong- you really don’t have to justify breaking up with someone.

u/banbanu14 I can see why he’s sad and why he was afraid. His romantic love doesn’t come with sexual feelings and because of that, it’s hard for him to understand...

u/driftindemi After reading the title my answer was: No. After reading the story my answer was: Absolutely No and OP needs new friends. Best of luck finding a new boyfriend,...

ADVERTISEMENT

u/YoshiandAims ... Your friends are... posturing. Also very lacking in perspective and life experience. Compatibility... is what matters. Not love. Love doesn't conquer all. This isn't a movie. Love is...

u/MissesNegativity
You made the right decision. Run for the hills!

u/Aggressive-Cicada349 You’re not wrong. You can breakup for any reason. Sexual incompatibility is a big one for most people. And two people cohabitating like what he wants makes you roommates...

ADVERTISEMENT

u/scgt86 YNW The relationship doesn't have to be based on sex to have value but for you a relationship needs intimacy and it doesn't for him. You guys became incompatible....

u/Cammyw01
This needs to be said for everyone everywhere
YOU CAN BREAK UP WITH PEOPLE FOR ANY REASON YOU WANT! you are not obligated to date someone

ADVERTISEMENT

u/FrolickingGhosts
This is a fundamental incompatibility that would only have bred resentment.
You did the right thing.

However, some commentators pointed out that her passive-aggressive withdrawal prior to the breakup unnecessarily amplified her ex's heartbreak.

Ending a long-term relationship over physical incompatibility is rarely easy, especially when both partners still care for one another. It requires balancing personal fulfillment with empathy for a partner’s authentic self.

ADVERTISEMENT

Do you think she was justified in prioritizing her own needs in her twenties, or should she have communicated her fears sooner instead of pulling away? How would you have handled this delicate situation?

Share your hot take below!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *