My husband (M32) just told me (F30) he has feelings for our friend (F30) and those feelings are reciprocated – do I leave?

ADVERTISEMENT

In a quiet car, the hum of the engine barely masks a painful confession that shatters the evening’s calm. A woman, 30, listens as her husband, a devoted stay-at-home dad, admits to feelings for their close friend’s wife—feelings she reciprocates. The revelation, delayed and shrouded by secret messages, stings like a hidden wound, unraveling the trust woven through their marriage and two young children. Her heart races, torn between love and betrayal, as she weighs her future.

This Reddit story captures a raw clash of loyalty and temptation. Her struggle, laced with the complexities of family and honesty, draws readers into a drama where emotions collide. As she navigates this heartbreak, the narrative unfolds with expert insights, community perspectives, and a call to reflect on trust’s fragile threads in love.

ADVERTISEMENT

‘My husband (M32) just told me (F30) he has feelings for our friend (F30) and those feelings are reciprocated – do I leave?’

My husband is currently a stay-at-home dad, watching our 1yo during the day and our 4yo when he comes home from school. He met another SAH dad (M 36) who has a 1yo as well, and they’ve been hanging out all the time. I was very grateful for their relationship because my husband seemed lost as a SAH dad at first.

We ended up getting very close with the family as a family and started spending a lot of time with this guy and his wife (F 30) and kid. It’s been about 6 months since we’ve known them, and this last week I could feel something sort of shifted.

My husband and SAH dad’s wife went out together for drinks one night last week, I didn’t think anything of it, they’ve both had very hard childhoods and have bonded over that. My husband doesn’t have a lot of friends and I was honestly just excited that he had someone other than me to talk to.

ADVERTISEMENT

But today I told him I felt like he was not telling me something and he said he did have something to tell me. We went on a drive and he said that he’s developed feelings for this woman. He said they sort of talked about it on Wednesday when they went out (it’s now Sunday) and that they’ve been messaging about it throughout the week.

I asked him how it came up and he said it was just “very natural” but didn’t give me details more than that. I asked to read his messages between them from Wednesday to today and he declined. And that really rubbed me the wrong way.

He assured me nothing more had happened they’ve just established that there’s “feelings” present and that there’s no intention attached, it just was the right thing to let me know. Here’s where I stand; I am not naive and I know people develop feelings for people all the time. It would be unnatural not to, and I don’t think he’s wrong for having them.

ADVERTISEMENT

However, I don’t like that they discussed it before discussing it with me and the woman’s husband. Or that there was days between without us being told. We do not have an open relationship and we pride ourselves on our honesty with each other and this felt a little late. Also, I do not fully trust this woman.

She has confided in me a lot about the issues between her and her husband and I worry she’s using this as a way to prove a point. She also is very traumatized and likes drama (her words) so I fear she can be a bit toxic. Obviously this situation is very nuanced. My husband has expressed that he doesn’t want a life without me.

But we’ve been in similar situations before and I just feel maybe I’m not being fair to myself anymore by staying? But he is a great father and we do have two children…so that makes things extremely complicated.. Where do I go from here?

ADVERTISEMENT

This couple’s cozy family life unraveled when the husband confessed mutual feelings for a friend’s wife, discussed secretly before telling his spouse. His refusal to share messages and the delayed disclosure amplify her sense of betrayal, especially given their emphasis on honesty. Her concern about the friend’s drama-seeking nature and marital issues suggests a risky dynamic, where emotional boundaries were crossed under the guise of shared trauma.

This reflects a broader issue: emotional affairs in close-knit social circles. A 2020 study from the Institute for Family Studies found that 45% of marriages face emotional infidelity, often sparked by unmet emotional needs. Dr. Shirley Glass, a noted psychologist, wrote, “Emotional affairs begin when secrecy replaces transparency with a spouse”. Here, the husband’s private discussions and messaging breached trust, escalating a crush into a threat.

Glass’s insight highlights the need for clear boundaries. The husband’s role as a stay-at-home dad, initially isolating, may have fueled his connection with the friend’s wife, but his choice to nurture those feelings was deliberate. Couples therapy, as recommended by The Gottman Institute, could help rebuild trust through open communication.

ADVERTISEMENT

The wife might demand transparency, like sharing messages, and insist on distancing from the friend to protect their marriage. This story underscores the fragility of trust when emotional lines blur. It’s a call to prioritize partnership over fleeting connections, rebuilding through honesty and accountability.

Here’s how people reacted to the post:

Reddit’s responses crackle with urgency, reflecting a chorus of concern and advice. Many urge the wife to protect herself, citing the husband’s secrecy and refusal to share messages as red flags of deeper betrayal. Others emphasize the need to inform the friend’s husband and set firm boundaries, like cutting contact with the woman.

The community sees this as a pivotal moment, pushing her to prioritize trust and her family’s stability over a husband’s risky choices. These Reddit perspectives blend empathy with a call to action, urging clarity and self-respect in a tangled web of emotions.

ADVERTISEMENT

Richard0000069 − He should have shown you their messaging. And they sure can't continue on like it is no big deal.

Fancy-Saiyan92 − Is your husband willing to cut contact with the friend’s wife?

ChickenScratchCoffee − Definitely message the other husband and let him know what is going on.

ADVERTISEMENT

Traeyze − He assured me nothing more had happened they’ve just established that there’s “feelings” present and that there’s no intention attached, it just was the right thing to let me know. So the obvious quesiton is what he plans to do about it. Like given that tension is there the only possible sensible resolution would be for them to distance themselves.

If not they are actively, openly, deliberately playing with fire and you're the one that gets burnt. Your read on her seems fitting. This was definitely the worst way to handle it and it is definitely drama. It's disappointing how easily and readily your husband jumped into that woodchipper though and that'd be a valid ongoing concern to have.

In the end he walked a path assured to hurt you and worse, he is conscious enough of it to deny you seeing the messages and likely because he is trickle truthing you. So ask what he plans to do from here. If he insists on still speaking to her then you already know it is over.

ADVERTISEMENT

WinterFront1431 − The only way I'd stay in the marriage and I'd tell him this to. Is the messages have to be shown, she has to be blocked and never spoken to again, and also, you will be informing her husband.. Those three things or no marriage and these need to be non-negotiable.

If he won't show the message, I'd tell him to leave, but either way, I'd message her husband. ' Just been informed by my husband, and I thought you had a right to know. The evening your wife and my husband went out, they confessed feelings for each other. All the messages should be in her phone as proof'

Kylito-77 − Does great father equate to great husband? The only reason he wants to keep you in his life or stay together is due to financial reasons cos how much money does a SAHD make? If strong enough OP honestly needs to consider separation

ADVERTISEMENT

lovebeinganasshole − Oh you’re being way too kind and understanding. Of course he wants you in his life you’re f**king funding it.. So not only f**king over his wife, kids, but his supposed friend?

Quiet-Hamster6509 − The fact that he can't show you the messages means there was more in there that definitely crossed a line and he knows it. I'd be telling him that it feels like he's sneaking behind your back and the trust has diminished.

Ask him what he plans to do about their friendship, is he planning on ending it? It sounds like he's already started the emotional affair and I'd wager there was a kiss when they went out.

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] − First things first tell him to get a job.. If you divorce the last thing you want is to give him alimony. Find a way to put your child in daycare. It will be expensive but with both of you working find a way.. Make boundaries that they can't see each other anymore.

You are his wife not some stranger. Demand to see those messages and make sure he doesn't erase any. If he doesn't comply ask him to leave. Don't let this trauma of his cloud your gudgement. This is a man that you are providing for and you love!

And he still has the nerve to do this.. Nobody falls for someone without crossing a boundary.. The more you dig the more you will uncover.. He lost your trust.. Think of you and your child.

ADVERTISEMENT

Relevant_Demand7593 − I would be asking him to leave. I believe there is more to it or he would have shared their messages. At least you are the main breadwinner - you may have additional child care costs but hopefully your wage is enough to support your family without your husband.

This story lingers like a storm’s aftermath, exposing the delicate balance of trust in marriage. The wife’s pain and her husband’s confession reveal how quickly bonds can fray when honesty falters. Share your experiences—how have you navigated breaches of trust? What steps rebuilt your connection? Let’s keep the conversation alive!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *