My (32M) wife (30F) has decided she doesn’t want children?

Venus Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Picture a cozy evening, two soulmates curled up on a couch, laughter filling their dream home. For one man, this perfect scene now carries a quiet ache. After years of building a stable, loving life with his wife, he’s begun dreaming of a child’s laughter joining theirs—only to learn she’s set against it, her resolve as firm as the walls they’ve built together.

This Reddit user’s confession spills raw uncertainty, caught between love for his wife and a budding desire for fatherhood. As their once-aligned paths diverge, he faces a heart-wrenching choice: stay with his love or chase a future that might never be. Their story pulls us into the delicate dance of dreams and dealbreakers, where love teeters on the edge of sacrifice.

‘My (32M) wife (30F) has decided she doesn’t want children?’

Me (32M) and my wife (30F) have been married for a couple of years now and together for 6 in total. She is the love of my life and I can't imagine life without her. We have talked about kids before, my wife has previously said that she doesn't know if she wants kids. And to be honest I've been that way as well.

However, in the last 6 months or so I've begun to feel like I would like to have a child in the future. Not right now but within the next 5 years perhaps. We talked about this with my wife and she told me she's pretty much convinced she never wants to have children. She gave me many reasons, some very valid, some (in my opinion) debatable but I'm not going to debate her, it's her decision.

I don't know what to do. I know I need to figure out if I can make the sacrifice of not having kids to stay with her. What I'm afraid of is that I'll resent her later for it and it'll be too late to start anew. It feels like we have everything going for us, stable life, good relationship, we're finally where we want to be. I don't want to be single. I don't want anyone else. But what if she's not enough, what if there will be a hole in me for the rest of my life?. I don't know what to do.

A marriage built on love can still wobble when dreams misalign, like a duet suddenly out of tune. This husband’s longing for a child clashes with his wife’s clear refusal, exposing a rift many couples face. Dr. Esther Perel, a renowned psychotherapist, observes, “The quality of our relationships determines the quality of our lives… but alignment on core values like family is non-negotiable” (Esther Perel). Here, the wife’s honesty is a gift, but it leaves her husband at a crossroads.

The husband’s recent shift toward wanting kids, after years of ambivalence, reflects evolving priorities—common in one’s 30s. Yet, his wife’s reasons, from valid concerns to personal choice, underscore her autonomy. This mirrors a broader trend: 20% of U.S. adults remain childfree by choice, often citing lifestyle or financial priorities (Pew Research). Neither is wrong, but their incompatibility stings.

Perel’s insight suggests open dialogue is key. The husband must weigh if love outweighs fatherhood, knowing resentment could fester. Couples therapy can clarify their values, offering tools to navigate this impasse.

Check out how the community responded:

The Reddit squad jumped in with spicy wisdom, serving empathy with a dash of tough love. Here’s the tea they spilled:

techno_queen − Do you really want children or do you want them because you’re worried you’ll regret not having them?

HoshiJones − You have to decide if she is enough for you, if the life you're building together is enough. Please picture your life with children as a single father. Think of all the sacrifices, all the sleepless nights, the endless work, the lack of 'you' time. Because that's the only fair way to think of it.

Unfortunately, in the vast majority of cases, it's the woman who gives up that much of herself for children, while the man continues to have a life apart from the kids. So it's hardly surprising that so many men want children.. Perhaps once you make that comparison, your life with the woman you love will seem more like enough.

Single_Vacation427 − You don't seem convinced about kids either. 5 years down the line is a long time and you have only come to this in the last 6 months? Have you really looked into what having kids really involves or have you only thought about the nice parts only?

I also don't think that if you go an find someone else that wants kids, they would want to wait 5 years like you are planning, because you would be 37 by then and if there are any fertility issues, it could be delayed even more. I don't know if you know that men 40+ there's an increase in autism and disability in their kids.

DVIGRVT − What I'm afraid of is that I'll resent her later for it and it'll be too late to start anew.. You need to take ownership here. If there's any resentment to be had is resentment of yourself, not her. She's being honest with you. She's respecting you, the relationship

and herself for recognizing her needs and informing you of them. If you choose to stay, that is your choice. Your decision. She's not forcing you to stay if you're need to have children is greater. To blame her for your decision to stay (if you do) is unfair. That's your decision. Own it.

thatfloridachick − It’s not that your wife has decided she doesn’t want children. You knew from the get-go that your wife did not know if she wanted kids. Yet despite this, you still married her. You have to decide how important is having kids to you.

Important enough you’re willing to divorce your wife? Which comes when no guarantees. You may meet someone else who wants kids, or you may find yourself struggling in the dating pool. Just know the grass is not always greener on the other side.

WritPositWrit − Your title makes it sound like she changed her mind and sprung it on you. But instead you say both of you have always felt uninterested, and only recently YOU changed your mind and decided you want kids, but she’s still saying “nope not interested.”

That doesn’t change your dilemma much, but I find it interesting that you are trying to blame her. She’s been honest and consistent. You changed things. If you end up divorcing so you can find someone who wants kids, please make it clear to everyone that you were the one who changed your mind. That would only be fair to her.

ChillWisdom − Honestly, it so easy for a man to feel a little twinkling urge of wanting a child when it's not his body and brain that are going to be permanent changed.

Due_Emergency4031 − Kids or no kids - is not a compromise, its a deal-breaker for one of you. You should've discussed this deeper before getting married. If she always knew she leaned more towards never having kids and you were hoping to at some point being a dad - you just swept major incompatibility under the rug.

Hippopotasaurus-Rex − I’d suggest sitting down and being real honest with yourself about why you want kids. To meet the social status quo? Because the picture perfect moments are great? Because you want to “preserve your legacy”? Because you want to care for someone else, good and bad? Do you plan to be majority caregiver, because that’s what you want? What will the logistics of it look like, and how will it impact your life?

Then, consider what your plan will be if you have a child that’s ill, or has disabilities, because it’s a REAL likelihood. Do you have the flexibility and finances to deal with that?. Then consider your lifestyle. Are you willing to end that completely in sacrifice of a child? Yeah, if you stay with your wife, you may resent her. It’s probable if you honestly want children. And it’s not fair to her.. Edit: also may want to check out r/regretfulparents

SerenaSweets333 − What makes you think you won’t change your mind back? People regret having kids even when they want them. Just something to consider. Will you regret leaving leaving her?

These Redditors aren’t shy, but do their takes hold up? Love and kids aren’t a simple equation—can online quips untangle this knot?

This couple’s tale is a bittersweet reminder that even soulmates can hit crossroads. Love alone can’t bridge every gap, but honesty might light the way. Whether they stay or part, their story nudges us to face our own dealbreakers. What would you do if your partner’s dreams diverged from yours? Drop your thoughts—let’s hash it out.

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *