AITA for making someone pay (literally) because of a prank?

Picture this: you’re gripping the steering wheel, heart racing as you navigate a familiar route, already battling driving anxiety. Now imagine a passenger, someone you’re kindly chauffeuring, decides it’s the perfect moment for a prank that sends your stress skyrocketing. For a 24-year-old woman, this wasn’t just a hypothetical—it was her daily commute turned chaotic by a friend’s reckless antics, pushing her to draw a hard line that cost him dearly.

Helping out a friend seemed simple enough, but when K’s pranks ignored her clear warnings about her driving anxiety, the road got bumpy in more ways than one. Her decision to stop the free rides left K facing a $90 monthly cab bill and sparked debate among friends. Readers can feel the tension: how do you balance kindness with self-preservation when trust takes a hit?

‘AITA for making someone pay (literally) because of a prank?’

I need to give some context before the actual story - I (24F) have driving anxiety. I learned driving because I really needed to be able to drive so I could bring my parents who can't around once my older sister moved away. Since I get stressed pretty easily, I just stick to routes I'm familiar with and its worked out fine for me for the last 5 years.

ADVERTISEMENT

I'm a safe driver except for the fact that I just stress while driving so nobody is at risk here. I drive to work since its not otherwise accessible by public transport and recently, a mutual friend K (26M) who lives near me started working near where I work as well.

K doesn't have a car, so he asked if he could hitch a ride with me to work since the company doesn't give probation employees a transport allowance. If he didn't hitch a ride with me, he'd have to pay $5-7 to get a cab to work from the nearest train station or walk for a fairly long distance.

I was happy to help him out since its literally almost the same route I take but I did warn him not to judge me when I'm driving cos well, I get stressed out. One day when we were going to work, I'd to sort of squeeze in between two cars to move forward because there was a roadblock.

I was fine but while I was driving, he suddenly gripped his seat and said something like 'oh s**t op you're about to scratch the car on the left' and obviously I panicked and braked and when I did he laughed and said no I'm kidding you're good. I already told him that day not to do s**t like that again because it just causes me panic.

ADVERTISEMENT

But a week ago when were driving to work, he did something even worse. I normally drive with the auto hold on, which means when I take my foot off the brake the car doesn't move forward. Its nbd whether its on or off to me but K turned it off when I was driving (the button is in the centre),

and so when I took my foot off, the car inched forward and I was not amused. He did apologise but I just can't get over it personally. After that incident, I asked him to find another way to get to work cos I didn't want to drop him anymore but obviously this means he has to pay at least $5/day to get to work so it'll literally cost him about $90/month so he was super pissed that I'm taking things this far.

My boyfriend who knows K also agrees that I'm really overreacting and since K apologised I should let it slide. I'm not sure if I'm overreacting in this situation because I'm naturally a bit stressed when it comes to driving - so AITA for not dropping K anymore and costing him money?

ADVERTISEMENT

Driving with anxiety is like juggling flaming torches—adding a prankster to the mix is a recipe for disaster. This woman’s decision to stop giving K rides after his reckless antics highlights a clash between helping a friend and protecting her mental health. K’s pranks, from fake warnings to tampering with the car’s auto-hold, ignored her explicit boundaries, escalating her stress in an already high-stakes task. His apology didn’t erase the breach of trust.

A 2023 study in Transportation Research Part F found that distractions, including passenger behavior, contribute to 15% of driving-related stress incidents. K’s actions weren’t just annoying—they were unsafe, especially for someone managing anxiety. His disregard for her warnings shows a lack of empathy, putting her in a tough spot.

ADVERTISEMENT

Dr. Susan David, a psychologist and author, emphasizes, “Boundaries are a form of self-respect” . Applying David’s insight, the woman’s choice to end the carpool was a valid act of self-care, prioritizing safety over social pressure. K’s financial consequence is a direct result of his actions, not her overreaction.

For solutions, she could communicate her boundaries firmly, perhaps offering K one last chance with strict rules. Others in similar situations might consider written agreements for carpools to clarify expectations. This story underscores that respect in shared spaces, like a car, is non-negotiable—especially when safety’s on the line.

ADVERTISEMENT

Heres what people had to say to OP:

The Reddit posse rolled up with full support, tossing shade at K’s prankster ways like confetti. Here’s the raw, unfiltered take from the crowd:

Cautious_Potential35 − NTA.. Apologies are not free passes to continue doing the same s**tty thing over and over again.. K is suffering from the consequences of his own actions. He was warned and still chose to do it.. If you take him back in the car he will do it again.

ADVERTISEMENT

The only way he can learn is to face consequences. The fact that he whined to your bf shows that he thinks you should fall in line if the person he considers your handler intervenes.. Also you BF is an A for trying to persuade you.

isntellie − NTA regardless of anxiety, you don't f**k with people when they're driving. It's a safety issue. I wouldn't drive him either and I'm very comfortable driving.

ADVERTISEMENT

amytherandomest − NTA. Doesn't matter if you have driving anxiety or not. You shouldn't mess around if someone is focused on driving. End of.

SammyTheCrab99 − NTA. You asked. You gave fair warning. Now there is a consequence.. Your car, your rules.. Drive safe G

ADVERTISEMENT

SlenderHarvester − NTA. NTA. NTA. NTA! My cousin is 22 years old, a grown man and lives with my mother. He has high functioning autism, and never had proper support from his own mother growing up. For that reason, he didn't get his license until he was 19 years old,

and his driving patterns remind me of exactly what you describe:. \- Takes the same, familiar routes to places he has to go like work, store, etc.. \-Extra cautious because he is extremely anxious about driving but understands he has to drive to function.

ADVERTISEMENT

Hell he even always gets gas at the same gas station, at the same pump. He refuses to drive on the interstate. All that said, no one in my family including myself would ever, ever, EVERRR behave the apprehensible way this person did in the car with you.

It is disrespectful and more importantly, incredibly dangerous to behave that way in a car with someone who already has trouble keeping their anxiety level down while driving. He sounds like a jerk, guess he's literally going to have to pay the price for his behavior.

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] − NTA. You set a clear boundary and he crossed it. Now he gets to find a new way to work. Remember, we teach people how to treat us. Now he knows you were serious.

eatthebunnytoo − NTA , he already had two chances and has shown he can’t behave, who cares if he apologizes when he keeps doing it.

ThinkerWhoTinkers − NTA. Since K can't respect your rules when you're doing him a favor, he doesn't get free rides anymore. If your bf feels strongly about it, he can give K a lift. Did K ever offer to pay for gas when you have him a lift?

pbc85 − NTA. Fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me. K has done this twice; don’t let there be a third time.

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] − NTA. Kick this disrespectful TA to the kerb. (And interfering with your autohold verges on psychopathic behaviour, ie a total lack of empathy for your situation. It’s dangerous. Not a joke. As someone who doesn’t suffer from driving anxiety, someone would get one warning if they touched the controls when I was driving. One.)

These Redditors cheered the woman’s stand, slamming K for crossing lines and endangering safety. Some called out the boyfriend’s meddling, others saw K’s apology as hollow. But do these fiery opinions nail the issue, or are they just revving up the drama?

ADVERTISEMENT

This driving drama steers us into the heart of boundaries and respect, showing how quickly a favor can turn sour when trust is toyed with. The woman’s choice to prioritize her safety over K’s convenience sparks a bigger question about standing firm in uncomfortable situations. When does a prank go too far, and how do you handle a friend who crosses the line? Share your thoughts and experiences below—what would you do in her driver’s seat?

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *