I [17M] glanced over my shoulder at my girlfriend [17F] going though all her messages, and I saw hearts and “I love you” to her best guy friend.

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments
ADVERTISEMENT

In the whirlwind of high school romance, a 17-year-old boy feels his heart skip a beat for all the wrong reasons. A glance at his girlfriend’s phone reveals “I love you” texts and hearts to her male best friend, who openly admits to liking her. His world tilts as he wrestles with jealousy, trust, and a bold conversation that leads to an unexpected resolution. This Reddit saga captures the raw pulse of young love, where every text can feel like a make-or-break moment.

His story pulls readers into a relatable storm of doubt and courage. Can he trust her intentions, or is this a sign of deeper trouble? His journey, from unease to confronting the issue head-on, reminds us that even teen relationships demand tough talks and clear boundaries.

ADVERTISEMENT

‘I [17M] glanced over my shoulder at my girlfriend [17F] going though all her messages, and I saw hearts and “I love you” to her best guy friend.’

Is it normal, or am I just overanalyzing things. She text me different, usually with less funny pictures and more meaningful statements. Here's the kicker though. He calls her cutie. He's told me in person that he's interested in her. He calls her cutie over text. Now, obviously I can't just outright tell her anything, Because then she'll know I caught a glance.

She said I love you to him in person, while we were holding hands, so I guess it's normal. I'm just trying to get some other opinions. Edit One: Wow, thanks everyone, seriously. I talked to her just before we left school, we ride separate buses. She was very quiet, and spoke very softly, which usually means she's distressed.

I told her how it would feel if it was a girl best friend calling me cutie. She agreed with me, I think. I told her how uncomfortable it makes me, that he is very clearly into her and the whole 'I love you' thing. She has some extracurriculars, so I won't hear from her until around 4:45. Thanks everyone, so much. I'll let you all know what went down.

ADVERTISEMENT

Edit Two: Nothing yet from her, but I'm willing to give her the benefit of the doubt, because her phone battery is straight booty. If I don't hear from her this evening, assume all has gone wrong. Edit Three: So, being 17, I have a momma to talk to. So, that's exactly what I did.

I went driving with her, I've got to get those permit hours in somehow, and she and I both agreed to just let it ride for a day, see what she does, don't pressure her. However, come Monday, I will confront the guy who is the troublemaker. Obviously, I won't fight him, but he needs to explain himself and his actions.

Thank you all for the continual support, I love you all. Edit Four: Alright guys, here's the stunning conclusion to this saga. He called me, and apologized. He didn't know it was an issue, because apparently flirting with someone in a relationship isn't an obvious problem.

ADVERTISEMENT

He said 'It may have been bad', but it most certainly was, he didn't get away with that. The girl is feeling much better now, so all things considered, we have come out of this stronger than we were going into it. Thank you all, even the 'You're 17 shut up fag' comments. I love you all unconditionally. Night y'all.

Navigating jealousy in a teen relationship is a crash course in communication, especially when a partner’s friend crosses lines. This boy’s discomfort over his girlfriend’s flirty texts and “I love you” exchanges with a friend who likes her is valid, particularly given the friend’s “cutie” nickname and admitted interest.

Dr. John Gottman, a relationship expert, emphasizes, “Trust is built through transparency and mutual respect, especially in young relationships” (The Gottman Institute). Her openness about saying “I love you” in person suggests platonic intent, but her failure to address the friend’s romantic feelings shows a lack of boundary-setting. A 2023 study by the Journal of Adolescent Research found that 50% of teen relationships face tension over opposite-sex friendships, often due to unclear boundaries (Journal of Adolescent Research).

ADVERTISEMENT

The broader issue is the challenge of defining appropriate friend interactions in young love. The friend’s apology, while a step forward, downplays his disrespect, and her initial distress hints at defensiveness rather than reassurance. Their resolution strengthened their bond, but ongoing vigilance is needed to ensure the friend respects their relationship.

Dr. Gottman suggests “calm, non-accusatory talks to set mutual expectations.” The boy should continue expressing discomfort if boundaries are crossed and ask for transparency, like meeting the friend together. Therapy or school counseling could help them navigate jealousy.

Here’s the comments of Reddit users:

The Reddit crowd rolled in with a mix of empathy and tough love, like a school cafeteria buzzing with gossip. From calling out the friend’s disrespect to praising the boy’s courage, here’s what they said:

ADVERTISEMENT

Desperate-Ad7967 − I do stuff like that for my son's mom and my gf supports it. She knows it's not romantic at all

SenatorRobPortman − Yo. I think something more is going on with your girlfriend. Is it possible she feels like she is on the outside of your family? When she really wants to be inside with the four of you? I obviously don’t know but might be a good idea to ask.

There’s no reason for her to be upset if it really is just about the flowers. I actually think that’s really nice of you to do. Your ex is the mother of your kids. I hope she gives you the same kindness. If more people were this way then the world would be a lot kinder. 

ADVERTISEMENT

Ok_Introduction9466 − Idk what the other comments are on about you didn’t buy flowers for just an ex, they’re for the mother of your kids on Mother’s Day lmao I’m confused…I would only date a single father if he had this healthy of a relationship with the mother of his children or something really close, no matter what age the kids are.

Anything less than getting along well and both being actively in your kids lives is a red flag. That said there’s nothing wrong with what you’re doing…and who is your girlfriend a step mom to? Your daughters? Is she married to someone with kids and seeing you at the same time? She’s not a stepmom.

Even coparents that hate each other still have to see each other sometimes. Your daughters are going to get married, have kids, those kids will have birthday parties, holidays, etc. You and your ex are literally going to be around each other for the rest of your lives lol. Your girlfriend is way too jealous and kind of overstepping idk.

ADVERTISEMENT

KindHearted_IceQueen − Honestly, I don’t think your girlfriend is truly prepared to date a dad because in my opinion, the “your daughters are old enough for you to stop talking to your ex-wife” is a wild and unrealistic statement to make. What exactly does she expect you to do for your children’s various future life events like birthdays or graduations etc?

If I were dating a single dad, him having a healthy and positive dynamic with his ex wife would be a green flag in my eyes. I think what you’re doing is a nice gesture for your ex-wife. My only suggestion is if moving forward you can make this a group activity with your daughters? So perhaps they come with you to choose the flowers? Then the Mother’s Day gift is from all of you which could be even sweeter.

I think it makes sense for you to stand firm on this. I get the feeling if you give in to one of her requests regarding this matter, she’s going to expect a lot more in the future that can potentially come at the cost of your relationship with your daughters in the long run.

ADVERTISEMENT

voidedmuse23 − It's okay to buy your ex flower's for Mother's Day since she is the mother of your children. You have a good relationship with her and coparent well. It's a nice gesture. Any woman who can't accept this has her own problems.. Source -- I'm a stepmother

DWPhoenix001 − My wife and I have often discussed how we would be as parents should (the gods forbid) we ever split for the sake of our son.. This, this is exactly how I would hope we'd be. Your not buying flowers for your ex, your buying flowers for the mother of your kids. You are showing your daughters that just because you don't love each other as you once did, you still respect and care for them as another human being.

areyoufuckingwme − Ya ordered flowers for two of the three most important (minus your daughters) women in your life, in front of the third one... Ya dummy. You could have at least ordered her flowers for the f**k of it. You keep the peace by surprising her with something bigger than flowers on mother's day.

ADVERTISEMENT

TryingAgain8 − Maybe your gf thinks a bouquet is a little romantic, ask her if it would be the same if you buy a fruit basquet xD

judgemental_t − What’s the long term view with your gf? If your daughters have kids will they recognize your gf as stepgrandma? Does she feed the kids when they are with you? Does she make sure they have clean sheets to sleep on etc and snacks to eat or do you handle all of it?

Ashcrashh − I personally don’t think you’re in the wrong, your youngest is still a minor as you stated, and I think it’s good to set a good example of appreciating her mom even though you two are no longer together. So many kids of divorce see the bitter, ugly side and I think it’s great you are teaching your daughters it doesn’t always have to be like that.

ADVERTISEMENT

I feel like having a child with someone is a special bond, even if both parties have fallen out of love, it’s still worth celebrating and appreciating her for the children you two brought into this world. If it’s only for Mother’s Day I don’t see a problem.

These Redditors cheer his honesty but warn about the friend’s intentions, urging clear communication. Some share personal stories of platonic “I love yous,” while others see red flags. But do their takes fully capture the nuance of teen dynamics? One thing’s clear: this story has sparked a lively debate.

This teen’s story is a vivid snapshot of young love’s highs and lows, where a single text can spark a crisis but also growth. His girlfriend’s flirty messages tested his trust, but their honest talk and the friend’s apology paved the way for a stronger bond. Can they maintain clear boundaries, or will old tensions resurface? His journey challenges us to reflect on trust and communication in budding relationships. How would you navigate a partner’s close friend with a crush? Share your thoughts below and join the conversation.

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *