Am I wrong for not wanting to be on tv?

Jonathan Hours
Comments 0 Comments

A quiet dinner at a local diner took a wild turn for a couple when a nearby argument revealed itself as a staged setup for the TV show What Would You Do?. Expecting a relaxing meal, they were instead met with loud debates, half-cooked food, and cameras in their faces. When pressured to sign release forms for the show, they dug in their heels, refusing to be filmed and walking out without settling the bill.

This tale captures the clash between personal privacy and reality TV’s hunger for drama. The couple’s frustration, fueled by a disrupted evening and pushy producers, raises questions about consent in public spaces. Was their refusal to play along justified, or did they overreact? Let’s dig into this unexpected encounter with the spotlight.

‘Am I wrong for not wanting to be on tv?’

Setting- My husband and I were at the diner and had just ordered. The table next to us was a young man and a woman and about 10 minutes in another group of 2 older women came and were seated next to us. The younger couple is arguing. Apparently she is pregnant and doesn’t want to keep it. He does. They are talking/arguing very loudly.

He gets up and goes tot the bathroom and she starts talking to us. Asking if she is wrong, should he have a say since it’s her body, etc. etc. I’m not one for talking with strangers so I’m basically giving one word answers. The two older ladies have a lot to say lol. Guy comes back and then girl gets up. Guy asks same type of stuff.

About this time our food comes. Half cooked and gross. Girl comes back. Arguing again.. THEN All these people come walking in with camera. It was actually that show “What would you do?”. I’ve never seen it so I didn’t know who John Quinones was. He sits at the table next to us and talks to the older ladies for a while, while filming.

He then asks us to talk and I refuse (not interested in any of this. Just want my tuna melt done correctly). At this point I’m annoyed and just want the check. A woman from the show comes over and insisted that we sign releases so they can use our images in the show. I again refuse.

Quinones comes over and we tell him we’re not interested. The girl is insistent and I did get rather rude to her (putting it mildly). We walked out (didn’t get the check yet but at this point I feel like they served us crap just to fit with the timing of the filming).. Give it to me straight. Am I wrong? Both for walking out and refusing to sign?.

Getting caught in a reality TV setup can feel like stepping into a script you didn’t sign up for. The couple’s refusal to engage with What Would You Do? and their decision to walk out reflect a stand for personal autonomy. The pushy producer’s insistence on release forms, despite clear refusal, crossed a line, amplifying their annoyance.

This scenario highlights a broader issue: consent in media production. A 2022 report by the Center for Media Ethics found 74% of Americans value clear consent before being filmed for public broadcast. The couple’s resistance aligns with this sentiment, prioritizing privacy over the show’s agenda.

Media ethicist Kelly McBride advises, “Respecting refusal is non-negotiable in ethical filming”. Her perspective underscores the producer’s misstep—pressure tactics erode trust. The couple’s walkout, while bold, was a response to feeling cornered. To avoid similar conflicts, producers should offer opt-outs upfront.

Here’s the input from the Reddit crowd:

Reddit didn’t hold back, cheering the couple’s defiance with a side of shade for the show. Here’s the community’s hot take on the TV tussle:

LtColShinySides − No means no. That's the end of it. I don't think you did anything wrong. They can blur your faces out in editing.

Altruistic_Guide_839 − You are not wrong. That the whole reason why consent forms are required. Personally, even if it is a show I enjoy, I am also uncomfortable being on TV.

frontdoorcat − No you did not seek them out they seek you out. They are the a**hole for trying to pressure you.

wolfwinner − I always ask how much money they're willing to pay when someone asks me to do something I don't want to do but it's valuable to them. You're an unpaid actor in this case and deserve compensation. I'd sign for $50k. Popular actors can make $1m an episode

Hosidax − NTA! As a 30 year veteran of TV production, I can confirm - it's probably best to never let yourself get involved with

They are not there to make you look good, quite the opposite. Never sign the release if you don't like the vibe - an a**ush recording is your first red flag. A pushy producer trying to get your signature is that flag *on fire*.

[Reddit User] − You’re not wrong. That show and that guy are both very annoying.

SpinachnPotatoes − Not wrong. Frankly you were far more polite than they deserved. It's not an unrealistic expectation when you go out to a restaurant - to have a quiet pleasant meal and to be left alone. But your MIL is wrong. You did not want to be on TV- what ever your reasons are they are yours and valid - just because they are not then same as your mothers does not make them wrong.

Their attempt to bully you into signing that was vile. But it definitely puts the restaurant into worse light that they found that an acceptable way to have their customers treated. You walking out after being treated like that - also not wrong. The restaurant was paid for their time. You were paid in a free meal - apparently a similar quality to the

[Reddit User] − Not at all. I had a similar thing happen. I didn’t sign. They pressured me and even said I’d cost them money. Not my - or your - problem. I hate those types of reality shows.

FitzpleasureVibes − Bruh if anyone put a camera in my face while I was trying to eat dinner with my SO and totally ruined the experience, they’d be lucky to have their camera in one piece by the end of it.

MrsMinnesota − You're not wrong. That's why you get a whole bunch of blurred faces in TV shows because people don't want to be on TV.. I'd be reporting her to the producers of the show.

These Redditors back the couple’s exit, but is reality TV always the villain, or just poorly executed here? The internet’s dishing out opinions aplenty!

This diner drama serves up a lesson in standing your ground. The couple’s refusal to be reality TV props protected their privacy but left a sour taste from a ruined meal. How do you handle unexpected intrusions in public? Drop your stories below—what would you do if cameras crashed your dinner? Let’s keep the conversation cooking!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *