Am I wrong for banning my SIL from my house for suggesting my wife is a gold digger?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

A festive Fourth of July barbecue turned icy when a man’s sister-in-law hurled cutting insults at his wife, a stay-at-home mom sidelined by a hit-and-run injury. Calling her a “gold digger” and “trophy wife” for needing temporary childcare help, the sister-in-law crossed a line, prompting a swift ban from their home. The backyard, buzzing with kids’ laughter, fell quiet as loyalties were tested.

His wife, still healing, deserves respect, not ridicule, for keeping their four kids and home running. Yet his in-laws cry foul, preaching “family love” while ignoring the venom aimed at his spouse. This isn’t just about a party—it’s about loyalty, love, and standing up for what’s right.

‘Am I wrong for banning my SIL from my house for suggesting my wife is a gold digger?’

I 36M am quite successful in my career and my wife, Adelaide 35F is a SAHM to our four children: 11, 9, 6, 2. A few weeks ago, Adelaide was considerably injured in a hit and run accident. I used up all of my leave to help her with the house and children.

She was still having trouble keeping everything up and a coworker’s wife who is also a SAHM offered to watch ours while I’m at work until she recovers from her injuries. We’ve been paying her for her time and food for the kids.

We celebrated the Fourth of July early and a bunch of our friends and family came over, including my SIL Alexia 33F. Adelaide and Alexia are not close try to avoid each other but we invited her because she has two kids 10, 8 who like to play with ours.

Alexia works long hours as a nurse because her and her husband can’t afford to live off of one income and has made several snide remarks to Adelaide such as “Must be nice getting to sit around on her ass all day and not work” or “What was the point of going to college anyway?

You just wasted your time and husband’s money.” We’ve tried talking to her, telling her to shut up, etc but nothing has worked so Adelaide just tries to keep her distance I guess Alexia heard about us leaving the kids with my coworker’s wife temporarily and she said that Adelaide is nothing but a trophy wife dumping off the kids.

Adelaide heard her and gave her a dirty look so I pulled her aside and scolded her saying that Adelaide is not just a trophy wife and to stop saying that. We’re “dumping off the kids” because she can’t pick them up due to her injuries.

Alexia doubled down and said she’s being a gold digger and told her to get out of my house because she was not going to come in and talk s**t about my wife. My in laws are giving me hell about this saying that Alexia is family and family should love one another.

I don’t care if she’s family or not, Adelaide is my wife and I’m not going to let people disrespect her in her own home. She is not a gold digger, she may not have to go to work but she still has to put in work.

She isn’t the most organized person in the world but she goes above and beyond to make sure house isn’t a health hazard, the kids are well attended to, and dinner is ready or not far from being ready when I get home from work. Her work is just as important as mine so was I wrong for kicking Alexia out?

A husband’s ban of his sister-in-law for calling his injured wife a “gold digger” is a justified defense of his spouse. His wife’s role as a stay-at-home mom, managing four children despite a hit-and-run injury, demands respect, not mockery. The sister-in-law’s insults, rooted in jealousy or resentment, dismiss the unseen labor of homemaking, while her refusal to back down escalates the harm.

Family conflicts over roles are common: a 2022 Journal of Marriage and Family study found 40% of extended families face tension over perceived inequities in work-life balance. Marriage therapist Dr. John Gottman notes, “Defending a spouse against external attacks strengthens trust and unity”.

He should maintain the ban until the sister-in-law apologizes sincerely, and discuss with his in-laws how her behavior undermines family unity. His wife’s recovery and emotional well-being come first. His actions are righteous—loyalty to a spouse outweighs appeasing toxic relatives.

Heres what people had to say to OP:

Reddit cheered the husband as NTA, praising his fierce defense of his wife against the sister-in-law’s “jealous” and “vindictive” insults. They slammed her for mocking a recovering accident victim and questioned the in-laws’ hypocrisy in preaching family love while ignoring her cruelty.

Commenters, including a nurse appalled by her lack of empathy, urged him to keep the ban and protect his wife’s peace, noting her stay-at-home role is vital work.

hutselfious −

I_Feel_Called_Out − You’d think a nurse would be more empathetic towards someone who had been a victim of a hit and run. But it seems like your SIL is just attacking instead. So you not wrong in your approach of banning your SIL from your home. NAH either.

Silvermorney − Not wrong and your in laws are being disgustingly hypocritical and showing blatant favouritism. If family is family and should love one another then where the hell was that attitude when alexia was disrespecting and denigrating her own sister? You absolutely did the right thing. Well done for standing up for your wife. Good luck.

StunningOccasion6498 − You’re not wrong. Your in-laws should be having a word with your SIL, and remind her that “family should love eachother”. You sound like a good, supportive husband, and if your wife being a SAHM is what works for the two of you, and you can afford it then thats nobody else’s business. Hope your wife recovers soon!

TaytorTot417 − Your wife is also family and SIL is being rude and n**ty, what are they going to do about that?. Y'all should just talking about how much of a miserable b**ch she is and see what they say then.. I'm a nurse btw, so I hate her attitude even more.

bokatan778 − Definitely not wrong. SIL not only sounds extremely jealous, but also like a vindictive and awful person. You made the correct choice.

Osidestarfish − Just for clarity is Alexia your wife’s sister? Trying to work out the dynamics here.. Regardless you’re not wrong.. Edited for judgment

Haztlen − Not wrong at all! Why Alexia isn't held to the same standard of

alicat33133 − You are not wrong, you stuck up. For your wife. Your SIL needs should be the one that your in laws are reminding about loving one another. She’s rude and hateful.

Sidewaysouroboros − Girl is just jealous that your wife doesn’t have to work. 4 children is expensive for childcare.

This wasn’t just about a barbecue—it was about a husband shielding his wife from a sister-in-law’s venomous jabs. His swift ban, though it ruffled family feathers, stood as a testament to his love and respect for his wife’s sacrifices, especially amid her recovery.

As the in-laws grumble, it’s a reminder that loyalty starts at home, not with appeasing bullies. Ever had to defend a loved one from family shade? Share your story—how do you draw the line?

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *