AITAH for wanting to break up with my girlfriend over her skincare/anti aging addiction?

A couple in their early 30s, together three years and living together two, hit a rough patch over her escalating skincare obsession. It started innocently—he supported her Etsy success, master’s graduation, and self-care glow-up—but ballooned into multiple routines dominating daily life.

Sunscreen indoors daily, thick night creams, swimming/language classes on top of work, book writing, and a new YouTube channel. The real killer: prescription tretinoin for anti-aging, causing constant sensitivity, flaking, rashes from kisses or stubble, limiting passion to “soft only.”

‘AITAH for wanting to break up with my girlfriend over her skincare/anti aging addiction?’

The passion begins harmlessly—she builds self-support since 18 via Etsy, adds hobbies like book writing (two done, editing for self-publish), launches true crime YouTube, swims thrice weekly, takes languages:

My girlfriend and I have been together for about 3 years and have been living together since the past 2. We are both in our early 30’s. She’s gotten deep...

I am not exaggerating but this has absolutely affected our relationship and intimacy. For example she wears sunscreen every single day even when she’s indoors.

She works from home and so do I so it’s almost impossible to kiss her or touch her face with all this skincare and sunscreen on but even if I...

She’s also on this prescription strength cream known for anti aging since the past 8 months which I feel is completely unnecessary given she looks great and doesn’t have any...

Night creams/Vaseline feel gross on contact; sun phobia kills beach trips, sunny rooms:

I tried to educate myself on it apparently it’s called tretinoin and it makes you shed skin. Which looked gross on her and her skin would be so sensitive like...

Since experiencing this a couple of times she’s told me that we are only limited to soft kisses and no passion. At night she would wear thick creams and even...

This isn’t just about intimacy. She’s like pathologically scared of the sun. Usually I would draw out blinds and it would be nice and sunny outside but she makes a...

ADVERTISEMENT

We don’t even go to the beach together although any indoor place she’s ok with but honestly I just miss LIVING without having her worry about her skin all the...

He begs stopping tretinoin (thins top skin layer ongoing); talks flop—she insists it’s normal in communities; proposal hints rise as he pulls back, lease end looms:

At first this skincare passion sounded cute and I encouraged her too but now I’m just sick of it. I requested her to stop this tretinoin cream as that’s the...

ADVERTISEMENT

I even educated myself on it and though I know it helps with anti aging the topmost layer of the skin will always remain thin as long as a person...

She stubbornly insists that what she is doing is “normal” in skincare communities. Nothing I say is working. Our lease is up coming November and I’m honestly tempted to not...

I don’t honestly want to spend the rest of my life like this. I was planning on proposing to her 6 months ago and we had talks about it and...

ADVERTISEMENT

Skincare routines can boost confidence, but when they disrupt intimacy, daily joy, and shared activities, they cross into obsession—possibly tied to anxiety, body dysmorphia, or deeper mental health flags like OCD tendencies around control/perfection.

Tretinoin (retinol derivative) aids anti-aging/acne but requires adjustment—ongoing severe irritation eight months in suggests wrong strength/application; dermatologists advise slower ramp-up, buffering, or alternatives. Daily sunscreen indoors aligns with expert recs (UV through windows ages skin), but extreme sun avoidance risks vitamin D deficiency/mood impacts.

Relationship strain from one partner’s fixation highlights imbalance—his valid needs for affection/spontaneity clash with her rigid rules. Encouraging initial passion turning resentment shows communication breakdown; “normal in communities” echoes echo-chamber effect online.

ADVERTISEMENT

Path forward: Frame concern as worry for her well-being (therapy for potential underlying issues), suggest professional derm consult for routine tweak, couples counseling for compromise. If unyielding, incompatibility looms—intimacy matters long-term.

Check out how the community responded:

Responses mixed—many saw red flags in extreme behavior, urging therapy; others defended basics (sunscreen/tret) as standard while noting obsession level concerning:

Some flagged psychological roots (OCD, anxiety, dysmorphia) and suggested professional help over breakup:

ADVERTISEMENT

burntdowntoast − I’m surprised I’m the first to say it, but the skincare hyper-fixation may not be the problem. It could be a symptom of something deeper. Just curious if...

seh_23 − NTAH, I’ve seen this happen in some skincare subreddits, people truly get addicted and it turns into an unhealthy obsession. It can be comparable to an eating disorder....

I care about my skin much more than the average person but I still go to the beach I just put sunscreen on and wear a hat; that’s normal skincare...

ADVERTISEMENT

She won’t realize how extreme she has become because the online skincare community definitely encourages this behaviour so she needs a true reality check. Does she have any girlfriends who...

How she responds to a serious conversation about her mental health and the fact that you are thinking about leaving her should help you determine your next steps.

Comfortable-Yam9013 − Suncream and tret are completely normal. Being afraid to go outside is not. Something else is going on

ADVERTISEMENT

sjk928 − This sounds like something she should go to therapy for. I like skincare and get facials and use products regularly but it sounds like she is anxious about...

Is she addicted to social media about skin care? It’s easy to get targeted by all these scare tactics.

thaway12769 − Nah - I feel I have some insight as someone who is into skincare in a similar way to your gf, and has OCD. (I dont know if...

ADVERTISEMENT

I find that there is a very fine line between just being very into skincare and it becoming a new ocd compulsion for me, and its something I find I...

The rule of thumb I use is that if its affecting my functioning, disrupting my quality of life, or become distressing then its gone too far, and its time for...

For me, I wear sunscreen everyday even if I'm indoors and reapply every 2-3 hours. Some people would find that overly disruptive to their life, but I dont. But I...

ADVERTISEMENT

For example, if im out longer than I thought I was going to be, and dont have sunscreen on me to reapply, that's okay. Im not gonna freak out about...

Your gf not being willing to have drapes open or stop the tret if its really not working for her, to me sounds like it's going too far. I'm sympathetic...

I find it helpful to focus on aging well instead of trying to not age. Like my goal is to just look like a good version of my age, not...

ADVERTISEMENT

But if I want to wear makeup then I'll wear it over one layer of sunscreen and call it good enough. There's no point in keeping my skin looking good...

Dermatology insights defended core practices but flagged improper use:

WangSimaContention − I'm a dermatologist, you shouldn't have a rash on tretinoin (it means you're using it too aggresively, or you have a contact allergy).

ADVERTISEMENT

Her skin has to get used to it, either work up slowly, mix it with a moisturizer, or use the microsphere formulation. On top of that, you only use it...

She should see a dermatologist about this. That's only like 10% of what's going on here, though, most of this sounds psychological. I'm not going to give you the reddit...

ADVERTISEMENT

though if you really were close enough to her to consider marriage, try counseling and sticking it out. There's something else underneath all this.

shadow_sparke − As someone who uses tretinoin 1. You HAVE to wear sunscreen everyday, which honestly good to do regardless

and 2. It can take 2 weeks to 4 months to adjust to so if she’s continuing to feel very sensitive on it then she should probably move to weaker...

ADVERTISEMENT

There’s also alternative retinoids to tretinoin that sometimes work better for people. Tretinoin should not continuously make your skin sensitive. I’ve adjusted and my skin just feels normal now (but...

highheelcyanide − If her skin is that sensitive on tret, she needs to use it less or have a lower dose. I’ve used it and other similar actives for over...

thirdtryisthecharm − Tretinoin is typically something that people adjust to. So the shedding or breakouts should not continue indefinitely. A thinner top layer of skin doesn't mean irritation nor sensitivity.

ADVERTISEMENT

Irritation 8 months later means she needs a different product or to apply it differently. Why are the thick creams at night a problem? It's not like you're rubbing your...

Zealousideal_Heat330 − It seems like she's heard something about these products and its got stuck in her head and she can't see it might not be working for her. People...

I had at least 9 steps each evening and once done I didn't have a layer of product sat on my skin. If I used an overnight mask and you...

ADVERTISEMENT

I used a day cream, foundation and face mist all with spf that didn't cause those kinds of issues either. After a few months I started to feel like there...

That turned out to be because my skin was moisturised so much it couldn't absorb it all so I reduced what I was using and tailored it as a week...

If she is having breakouts etc and product sitting on face every day she may need to change the routine. If you want to make the relationship work try talking...

Perfecting skincare can be very trial and error and changes according to the season and as you age. Look into products containing sodium DNA which helps repair damage and protect...

Do some research into products containing spf that dont leave skin feeling sticky. See if supportive interest helps get through to her. If that doesn't work there's deeper issues regarding...

Others validated his frustration, questioned community “normalcy,” or urged no proposal:

New-Tailor3476 − It’s tough when something that starts as self-care turns into a barrier between you two. Your feelings are valid. . intimacy and connection matter just as much as...

Crazyfishman2 − I have a sticky wife too that is all about skin care. If she is sticky, I stay away.

PeriwinkleWonder − NTA -Don't propose! Can you imagine how much worse she'll get preparing for a wedding? Honestly, she's probably severely vitamin D deficient, too.

Illustrious_Egg_7408 − It's actually recommended to wear sunscreen daily, even indoors when you don't think you are going outside. Starting tretinoin in one's 30s is also not unusual.

The start of tretinoin treatment can cause skin sensitivity and flaking. The tropicals she's using at night that you don't like help with that. Beard stubble can cause a lot...

Maybe you can stay clean shaven per her preference? Really, I'm not reading any real issues with her skin care. I think there's other issues with your relationship.

Vivid-Internal8856 − I love how everybody is like, her behavior is totally normal in the skin care community. But is the skin care community normal?

Self-care turning life-disrupting obsession strains bonds—valid skincare benefits clash with intimacy loss and joy-sucking extremes here. Community leans concern over judgment—many spot potential mental health roots needing therapy, while basics like sunscreen/tret get defended as standard (if adjusted right).

Extreme sun fear/sensitivity flags deeper issues; communication/counseling urged before lease-end decisions. Ever seen a hobby morph into relationship roadblock? How’d balance return—or not? Thoughts below!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *