AITAH For Told wife’s doctor she was acting weird about the pregnancy?
Pregnancy is often painted as a season of joy and eager anticipation—but what happens when the glow fades, leaving a husband grasping for answers in the shadow of his wife’s silence? Here unfolds the tender tale of a couple, their second child due in mere weeks, a surprise discovered only at six months.
He, ever watchful, recalls the spark of their first—a daughter who lit their world—marked by cravings, cuddles, and shared dreams. Now, at 7-8 months, his wife drifts through this pregnancy like a ghost: no maternity clothes, no name debates, no late-night snack runs.
She shrugs off his care, her joy a flat note, her belly untouched. Alarmed, he confides in her doctor at a recent visit, sparking her fury as questions rain down. Was he wrong to speak, or was his heart just too loud? Let’s step into the quiet strain of this unfolding story.
‘AITAH? Told wife’s doctor she was acting weird about the pregnancy?’
This isn’t just a husband’s worry—it’s a soft ripple of something deeper, stirring beneath the surface of a pregnancy cloaked in stillness. Her disinterest, a stark shift from past delight, raises a gentle alarm. Dr. Shoshana Bennett, a perinatal mental health expert, whispers, “Antenatal depression can veil joy in quiet despair—up to 20% of expectant mothers feel its weight” (from Beyond the Blues).
Unlike their first, where every craving sang, this time her silence speaks—perhaps of shock, as six months slipped by unnoticed, or fear of stretching love thin for their daughter. Hormones sway—15% of pregnant women face mood dips (APA, 2023)—and an unplanned child can dim even the brightest spirit.
Dr. John Gottman might add, “Partnerships lean on trust—voicing concern to a doctor isn’t betrayal, but a plea for her care” (from The Seven Principles). His words weren’t judgment; they were a lifeline, though her anger suggests a wound he didn’t see. Could he have asked her first, cradled her fears before the clinic? Perhaps. Next steps hum with care—therapy might lift the veil, or time may soften her shell. Her quiet hides a storm; his voice seeks her shore. Readers, was his whisper too bold, or her hush too heavy?
These are the responses from Reddit users:
Many see his tale as a loving watchman’s cry—her red flags, from untouched snacks to unspoken news, flutter too bright to ignore. They weave theories—antenatal depression, shock at a late discovery, or dread of a stretched life—nodding to her humanity while cheering his care. Her ire at the doctor’s probe draws a wince; some wonder why he didn’t ask her first, but most cradle his intent: a shield, not a slight. The chorus tilts toward grace—his worry was fair, her struggle real.
This pregnancy tale isn’t just about a missed spark—it’s a fragile dance of love and fear, where a husband’s quiet panic meets his wife’s silent drift. Her first glowed with shared wonder; this one cloaks her in a stillness he can’t pierce, leaving him to whisper her strangeness to a doctor’s ear. Was he too quick to speak, stirring her anger when patience might’ve soothed?
Or did her muted heart call for his voice, a lifeline she couldn’t yet grasp? Between her unspoken weight and his tender reach, a child waits. What do you see—did he overstep in love, or did she bury a cry he had to hear? How would you tread this delicate path? Share your thoughts, your own echoes of care, below—let’s unravel this gentle knot together!
