AITAH for threatening divorce is my husband gets sealed in the Mormon temple with his family?

Imagine a family dinner where the mashed potatoes are passed, the kids are giggling, and then—bam—your mother-in-law drops a bombshell about sealing your husband and kids to her in the afterlife. That’s the surreal scene one 29-year-old mom stumbled into, caught between a Mormon temple and a hard place. Her mother-in-law’s newfound faith has turned a casual meal into a battleground, with eternity—and her marriage—on the line. She’s staring down a ceremony that excludes her, and her husband’s shrugging it off like it’s no big deal.

The sting isn’t about belief—she’s not religious, and neither is her husband, Jake. It’s the gut punch of being sidelined while her mother-in-law stakes a celestial claim on her family. Picture her, fork paused mid-air, as Jake brushes it off as “just a ceremony,” leaving her to wonder if their four-year marriage means less than his mom’s heavenly RSVP. Now, she’s threatening divorce, and everyone’s calling her dramatic—but is she?

‘AITAH for threatening divorce is my husband gets sealed in the Mormon temple with his family?’

Talk about a plot twist—your mother-in-law wants your family in her afterlife VIP list, but you’re not invited. It’s a wild ride, even for a non-believer. The redditor’s stuck in a tug-of-war between Jake’s loyalty to his mom and the vows he made to her. It’s less about Mormon theology and more about respect—or the lack of it.

Let’s break it down. The sealing idea stems from a real Mormon practice, but as Dr. Jana Riess, a religion scholar, notes, “It’s about eternal family unity, not exclusion” (source: The Next Mormons, public interviews). Yet, here, it’s a weapon—intentional or not. The mother-in-law’s excluding her while including her sisters-in-law’s husbands smacks of personal beef, not doctrine. Jake’s enabling it? That’s the real kicker. Marriage counselor John Gottman says trust erodes when partners don’t “turn toward” each other (gottman.com)—and Jake’s turning toward his mom instead.

This isn’t rare—studies show 30% of couples cite in-law issues as a major strain (Psychology Today). The “it’s not real” excuse misses the point: it’s real to her feelings. Advice? Jake needs to set boundaries with mom—stat. Couples therapy (try resources like BetterHelp.com) could rebuild trust. Readers, what’s the line when family meddling goes too far?

See what others had to share with OP:

The Reddit squad weighed in with gusto—here’s the dish, served with a wink: “These spicy takes from the online peanut gallery are equal parts wild and wise.”

They’re loud and proud, but do they nail the vibe—or just fan the flames?

Where does this leave our redditor? Teetering on divorce over a ceremony she doesn’t even believe in, all because it’s a neon sign of disrespect. It’s a quirky mess—eternity’s at stake for some, but for her, it’s about the here and now. Should she fight for her marriage or her dignity? What would you do if your spouse picked their mom’s cosmic guest list over you? Spill your thoughts—let’s hash it out.