AITAH for refusing to babysit my husbands kids so he can have some time off?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Picture a lively household buzzing with the chaos of three young boys, their dad juggling a new job and a groomsman’s duties. His wife, sipping coffee in her gym gear, cherishes her child-free life, having agreed years ago to be a partner, not a stand-in mom. But when a last-minute plea to babysit for a bachelor party weekend lands on her plate, the air crackles with tension.

Her refusal, rooted in a clear pre-marital boundary, leaves her husband fuming and their agreement in question. Was she wrong to hold firm, or is he dodging his role as a father? This Reddit tale, straight from her post, dives into the sticky world of stepfamily dynamics, where love, duty, and personal freedom collide, with the community ready to dish out their takes.

‘AITAH for refusing to babysit my husbands kids so he can have some time off?’

My 29f husband 34m has three kids from a prior marriage. 11m,7m,6m. They are absolutely terrors, as both of their parents have struggled to agree with parenting and rules. When I met my husband four years ago, he stated that he isn’t looking for a mom for his kids.

His kids have two parents, and he’s looking for a wife for himself. I like kids but I’ve never wanted any of my own. I was open to the idea of him having kids. Back when we dated, he had the kids on weekends. Things were fine with them. He never expected anything from me regarding the kids.

I told him I’m not interested in babysitting, and he said he’d never ask me to. He’ll just hire his niece to babysit if he needs a babysitter. Long story short, in the last year they’ve moved from weekends to fifty-fifty. Since the kids are old enough to not need their mom as much, this was always the plan.

One parent has the kids for a whole week, and other has the kids the next week. Husband lost his job and got a new job that pays less. Niece also went off to college. Husband can’t afford any of the local babysitters because they charge quite frankly a lot. The kids are terrors so babysitting does not come cheap.

Husband is also now making less money. This weekend was his friends bachelor party. Husband is a groomsman and was expected to attend. Last minute he asked me to watch the kids for the entire weekend so he can attend this event. He thought it would be no big deal, and I would definitely agree.

I was kind of miffed that he waited to last minute to ask me. I told him that I can’t because I have to go to the gym, and I have brunch plans with my mother. And honestly, I just don’t want to. Sounds like a good way to ruin an otherwise good weekend.

Also, why would I watch the kids so their dad can go get plastered and ogle strippers with his friends? No thank you. Not like it was an emergency or something. Dan was very upset because he couldn’t go. I brought up the fact that before we got married he told me he wouldn’t expect me to watch the kids ever.

He seem surprised because he thought I would’ve changed my mind. I told him I’d watch them if there was an emergency, but otherwise no. I didn’t have kids because I didn’t want the responsibility of them. I like his kids. I cook for them sometimes. And take them out to do stuff occasionally. I show up to their sports games.

But this is for me and the kids. I would say that they all really like me, because I don’t try to meddle and pretend to be their mom. I’m their dad’s wife that they like. I love Dan but I think he needs to not try to shirk his responsibility as a father. He signed up for this. Having kids means you don’t always get to do the things you want to do.. AITAH?

This babysitting standoff is a textbook clash of boundaries and assumptions. The Redditor’s refusal to watch her husband’s kids honors their agreement—she’s a wife, not a parent—while his last-minute ask betrays an expectation she’d bend. His surprise at her stance suggests he banked on her softening over time, a risky move in stepfamily dynamics.

Dr. Patricia Papernow, a stepfamily expert, notes, “Clear agreements in blended families are crucial; unspoken expectations can erode trust” (source). A 2020 study found 50% of stepparents face pressure to take on unwanted parenting roles, straining marriages (source). The husband’s financial strain and parenting challenges don’t justify springing childcare on her.

Her involvement—cooking, attending games—shows care without crossing her line. The husband needs to prioritize affordable childcare solutions, like family help, and respect her boundary. Couples therapy could align their expectations (source). This story highlights a universal truth: in blended families, clarity is the glue that holds love together.

Here’s how people reacted to the post:

Reddit’s crew stormed this stepfamily saga like pals at a game night, tossing out cheers for the Redditor’s resolve and jabs at her husband’s fumble. It’s as if they’ve huddled over pizza, dissecting the drama with wit and a touch of snark. Here’s the unfiltered buzz from the crowd, packed with support and a sprinkle of shade:

id12345678910 − NTA. He waited until the last minute so there wouldn’t be time to discuss other options that would be more expensive or inconvenient for him.

ProfessorDistinct835 − NTA. If he has the money for the Batchelor party and strippers, he has the money for a sitter.

Beautiful-Elephant34 − NTA. “He seemed surprised because he thought I would’ve changed my mind.” This right here tells me everything I need to know OP. Stick to your boundaries OP. Your husband was trying to pull a fast one on you by waiting until the last minute thinking that his urgency was also your urgency.

Medium-Fudge459 − Bhahaha this man has 13 more years of children at home. You are in for a long ride. 

Quiet-Hamster6509 − It's only going to get worse. He won't want to handle the permanent 50/50 parenting load and he'll start to say that if you love him you'll help with his kids.. This marriage won't last. Good luck.

aztex_tiger − NTA. But girl really? You really thought this conversation would NEVER happen? You should have seen this coming a mile away

Ohwowitsjessica − I think you went into this relationship with blinders on.

SimplyMadeline − Jesus Christ, those poor kids. Parents are clearly a f**king mess, and their dad marries someone who doesn't like kids. WTF was he thinking? WTF were you thinking?. What if their mom died or was incapacitated and you had to take the kids on full time? Why wouldn't you just date childless men if you want to remain childless?

Why would you marry someone with kids if you don't want kids? Why would you want to marry someone whose kids were so unimportant to them that they are willing to marry someone who doesn't like kids?. Man, the number of poor decision on display here is staggering.. You're N the A *in* this situation, but YTA for getting into this situation.

patchouliii − ... he needs to not try to shirk his responsibility as a father. He signed up for this. Having kids means you don’t always get to do the things you want to do. He has no room to be upset. This isn't an emergency. No wonder the children are a t**ror. His priorities are out of order.

languagelover17 − This might get downvoted, but I think ESH. why on earth would you get into a relationship with a man with 3 small kids when you have no interest in being any kind of parental figure? That’s not fair of him to spring this on you now, but come on, you thought that not doing parenting with kids that young would last? That’s delusional.. Poor kids.

These Redditors are all in, applauding the Redditor for sticking to her guns while roasting her husband’s last-minute ploy. Many see his assumption as a bait-and-switch, with some questioning the marriage’s longevity given the kids’ long-term presence. Others lament the kids’ chaotic upbringing, but their collective vibe backs her boundary. Do these online takes nail the stepfamily struggle, or do they miss the nuance of a four-year bond?

This stepfamily showdown serves up a sharp reminder: boundaries in love are only as strong as the respect behind them. The Redditor’s refusal to babysit wasn’t a snub but a stand for the life she chose, while her husband’s plea ignored their deal. As they navigate this rift, communication could be their lifeline. Have you ever had to defend a hard boundary in a relationship? Share your story below and let’s unpack the balance of love and duty.

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *