AITAH for expecting to get what I had asked for for my 30th birthday?

Jonathan Hours
Comments 0 Comments

The big 3-0 rolls around, and a guy’s hoping for a night of laughter with close friends, clinking glasses at a cozy bar. Instead, his girlfriend hands him a card, a couple of gift cards, and a book—hardly the party he’d dreamed of. Hurt by the letdown, he opens up about his disappointment, only to spark a heated argument that leaves them both reeling.

This birthday bust isn’t just about missed plans—it’s a clash of expectations in a relationship. The man feels unheard, while his girlfriend calls him ungrateful, turning a milestone moment into a battleground. Readers can’t help but lean in: was he wrong to expect her to deliver on his birthday wish, or should she have stepped up? The drama unfolds, inviting us to pick a side.

‘AITAH for expecting to get what I had asked for for my 30th birthday?’

This guy took his birthday blues to Reddit, sharing the sting of unmet expectations and the fallout with his girlfriend. Here’s his original post, diving into the heart of the conflict.

ADVERTISEMENT

It was my 30th birthday last month. Prior to this my girlfriend asked me what I wanted from her and I said I'd like a small get together of just a few close family and friends. There's a bar near us that lets you book the place out for free if you have at least 15 people as it's a small place so I mentioned possibly going there.

My birthday came and I got nothing like that. I got a card and a couple of little gifts (2 gift cards and a book) from my gf but no gathering or any sort of celebration. I was upset at this and my girlfriend asked me why I was upset and I explained it to her.

She said it would have been a hassle trying to get everyone together and would have took a lot of work to organise. I told her she knew how much it would have meant to me and that she literally asked what I wanted from her and then chose to ignore it. I said it hurts hearing her say I'm basically not worth the effort.

She said I should have done it myself then but I pointed out you don't organise your own birthday party and she is the one who asked me what I wanted from her. She said I was trying to guilt trip her but I told her I was just expressing how I felt about it. She said I was being too unfair and that I should be happy with what I got.

ADVERTISEMENT

I told her she doesn't get to tell me when I can and can't be upset and that it obviously hurts knowing your partner doesn't care enough to even try to organise what I wanted for my birthday.. She again said I was guilt tripping her and deliberately trying to make her feel bad.. AITAH for expressing my upset that she'd ignored what I'd asked from her for my birthday?

Birthdays can be a minefield in relationships, especially when expectations don’t align. This man wanted a small gathering for his 30th, a milestone he shared with his girlfriend, but her minimal effort—gift cards and a book—left him feeling undervalued. Her excuse? Organizing was too much hassle. His frustration led to a spat, with her accusing him of guilt-tripping.

The issue hinges on communication and effort. He felt ignored after she asked for his wish, while she dismissed the party as too much work. A 2023 study in Journal of Social and Personal Relationships found that mismatched expectations in romantic partnerships often lead to conflict, with clear communication being key to resolution.

ADVERTISEMENT

Dr. John Gottman, a renowned relationship expert, notes, “Successful relationships thrive on small, consistent acts of responsiveness to each other’s needs”. Here, the girlfriend’s failure to follow through or manage expectations broke that trust. The man’s heated response, though, may have escalated things unnecessarily.

Moving forward, they could benefit from a calm discussion about love languages and planning shared responsibilities. She might consider small gestures to show care, while he could clarify future expectations.

ADVERTISEMENT

Here’s the input from the Reddit crowd:

Reddit waded into this birthday drama with opinions as varied as party snacks. Here’s a roundup of their takes, sprinkled with humor—because even relationship spats need a chuckle.

shenme_ − ESH: She is an AH for agreeing to plan the gathering and then just not doing it without telling you. You’re an AH for saying “you don’t organise your own birthday party”. Maybe that’s true when you’re a child, but adults organise their own birthday parties all the time. Who would organise it if you were single? Definitely seems like you were guilt tripping her, instead of communicating how you felt.

ADVERTISEMENT

nuggets256 − ETA: NTA with the context that she agreed to the original request. INFO what was her response when you originally asked for her to organize the gathering?

GreekAmericanDom − ESH. Telling someone what you want for a gift does not entitle you to that gift and as a 30 year old, you don't get to be b**t hurt over not getting the gift you want. Why? Because you are an adult who can make the gift happen for himself.. You want 15 of your friends to have an evening at a bar? ORGANIZE IT.

ADVERTISEMENT

Getting mad at a partner for not doing a fairly big ask, is not fair to them, especially when it is something you should for yourself. Your 30. Organize your own birthday party. Don't outsource it..

I'm not letting your GF off the hook either. I think her offense is much smaller, but when you asked for what you did, she should have managed your expectations. Honestly, the best response would have been along the lines of 'that's not the sort of gift I had in mind, but I can help you organize it.'

ADVERTISEMENT

NoPersonality9280 − NTA. Why ask if you're going to ignore it?! And since when is inviting friends to an easily booked venue such a hassle?

IndividualAd9213 − It would never cross my mind to ask someone to organize a 30th birthday bash for me. So I must admit that I was surprised by the size and the scope of this ask. I disagree with OP. Lots of people who I know have organized their own birthday parties, especially the so called important ones ending in zeros. They usually recruit someone to help them;

ADVERTISEMENT

but other than surprise parties, these don't usually get outsourced to GFs or other loved ones. Assuming that such a request is acceptable, if not appropriate, I'd have to find fault with the gf's failure to manage expectations and her near dismissive response to OP's explaining why he was feeling the way he was.

On the other hand, I do agree that the gf has a point about guilt tripping when OP writes 'that it obviously hurts knowing your partner doesn't care enough to even try to organise what I wanted for my birthday*' Come on, that's some mom-level guilting going on there. I land on ESH because there seems to have been lots of implicit expectations and non communication going on here. You two need to spruce up your communication skills.

ADVERTISEMENT

_espen − It's always funny watching someone asking if they're the AH, as if they were actually open for different answers and then passive-aggressively argueing eith everyone not agreeing with his side of things.

I'm going with ESH. Yes, adults do organize their own parties, even when they're in a relationship. it's kind of common. also the gf should've communicated more clearly. But i do think we have a case of unreliable narrator, just judging by his comments and the absolute need to be right.

ADVERTISEMENT

dontlikebeige − ESH.  I would have voted not, but all your responses to anyone who gives your gf any leeway are angry, snarky, total lashouts.  So you are just really pi**ed and unable to even entertain the idea that you are not the perfect and vilely mistreated angel. What happened might be a lack of emotional investment on her part.

Also likely, since you have apparently been good together for two years, is that there is a mismatch of love language and perhaps a social anxiety issue. Planning parties is nearly impossible for some people.  And some people are unable to say no, they can't do things.  Is your gf like that?

Expectations and adjustments to make you work together better could happen if you would sit and talk, maybe with a therapist to guide the discussion.  But if all you bring to the discussion is your outrage, you will never solve it. 

anglflw − You do, actually, organize your own birthday party when you're an adult.. But still, ESH.

ADVERTISEMENT

EmergencyPaint6457 − I’m not a big birthday guy, but this seems really low effort for a milestone birthday.

ReasonableAd3605 − NTA. A gift card and a card is a b**lshit gift in you're in a relationship. Sorry that's not personal. That's what a relative who doesn't know you gets you at Christmas.  She asked and you answered.

ADVERTISEMENT

If she couldn't/wouldn't do it she could have said that instead of doing nothing and acting like you should be grateful for her functionally driving to CVS and grabbing a couple of impersonal cards. The only thing I agreed with her on is you were guilty tripping her and trying to make her feel bad, because she is guilty and she should feel bad. 

These Reddit gems are spicy, but do they nail the truth? Is the guy justified in his hurt, or should he have thrown his own party?

ADVERTISEMENT

This 30th birthday saga is a classic tale of love, letdowns, and clashing expectations. The man’s hurt over his girlfriend’s low-effort gifts collides with her defensiveness, leaving their relationship on shaky ground. Reddit’s split—some cheering his honesty, others calling for better communication—mirrors the messy reality of partnerships. How would you navigate a birthday bust like this? Drop your stories and weigh in on this couple’s drama!

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *