AITA? My Boyfriend M55 says I’m cheating on weight loss…

Imagine shedding 22 pounds with a gastric balloon, pushing through menopause and emotional eating, only to have your fiancé call you out for “cheating” on your diet over a few cocktails and a big meal. That’s the sting one 50-year-old woman felt when her soon-to-be husband criticized her weight loss progress, accusing her of lacking self-control and “letting everything hang.” His harsh words drove her to a friend’s house, leaving her questioning if she’s wrong for standing up to his demands about her body.

This Reddit tale is a raw look at body autonomy, love, and control. Is she wrong for defending her journey, or is her fiancé crossing a line? Let’s dive into the story, get an expert’s take, and see how Reddit weighs this relationship scale.

‘AITA? My Boyfriend M55 says I’m cheating on weight loss…’

A woman’s weight loss efforts became a battleground with her fiancé’s criticism. Here’s the full story from the Reddit post:

This weight loss clash is less about pounds and more about power in a relationship. The woman’s progress—losing 22 pounds despite menopause and a natural slowdown—is commendable, but her fiancé’s focus on her appearance over her health reveals a controlling streak. His accusations of “cheating” dismiss her emotional and physical challenges.

Relationship therapist Dr. Stan Tatkin notes, “Criticism of a partner’s body often masks insecurity or a need for control.” Emotional eating, especially during menopause, is common; a 2024 study in Journal of Women’s Health found that 70% of women over 45 report food-related stress during hormonal shifts. The fiancé’s lack of empathy risks undermining her efforts.

Dr. Tatkin suggests setting boundaries: calmly state that body comments are off-limits and redirect to supportive discussions about health goals. His reaction to this boundary will reveal his willingness to respect her autonomy.

Here’s the comments of Reddit users:

Reddit’s dishing out some fiery takes on this relationship weigh-in—here’s the bold commentary:

These responses are as sharp as a calorie counter, rallying behind the woman’s journey while flagging her fiancé’s toxicity. Can a firm boundary save this engagement, or is it time to shed more than just pounds?

This story of a weight loss journey under fire shows how fast love can tip into control. The woman’s not wrong to defend her progress, but her fiancé’s harsh judgment screams red flags about his respect for her autonomy. A candid talk about boundaries—or a hard look at the relationship’s future—might be the real goal to hit. Have you ever faced a partner’s criticism of your body? What would you do in this woman’s shoes? Share your thoughts below!