AITA for ungrounding my daughter after my wife grounded her?

Picture a tense evening in a suburban home, where a 14-year-old’s tearful outburst echoes through the halls. Her mother, caught red-handed reading her private diary, faces accusations of betrayal, only to double down by grounding her for “disrespect.” The father, torn between his wife’s concern and his daughter’s hurt, steps in to lift the punishment, igniting a parenting firestorm. What began as worry over a teen’s sadness spiraled into a clash of trust and boundaries.

This Reddit saga, straight from the AITA trenches, feels like a family drama plucked from a TV script. The father, striving to protect his daughter’s privacy, wonders if he’s the hero or the villain in this heated dispute. Let’s unpack this tale of diaries, distrust, and differing parenting styles with a dash of empathy and humor.

‘AITA for ungrounding my daughter after my wife grounded her?’

My 14 y/o daughter had been visibly upset for a couple of days, but she refused to tell my wife or myself why. My wife and I were naturally worried about her, but I told my wife not to push her to tell us about her problems and that we should let her come to us whenever she’s ready.

My wife agreed with me but I later found out that she read our daughter’s diary in secret to find out what was happening. When she told me this, I told her that she shouldn’t have invaded our daughter’s privacy like this. But my wife said she only did so because she was too concerned about her and that she wanted to help.

I still didn’t approve of her actions but I remained silent. My wife told me that our daughter was facing some friendship problems and now that she knew what exactly my daughter was going through, she would know how to help.

When my daughter returned home my wife started to “casually” bring up some of her past experiences regarding friendship problems very similar to what my daughter had written about. I think my daughter caught on pretty fast (to be fair it really was obvious) and she accused my wife of reading her diary.

When my wife didn’t deny it, my daughter started crying and yelling at my wife. I decided to step in here and I told my daughter to go to her room to calm down. My wife however made things worse by yelling back at my daughter and my daughter screamed back at her again. They were both completely ignoring what I’d said.

Then my wife yelled that my daughter was grounded for two weeks for being disrespectful and rude. My daughter went up to her room presumably too upset to continue the argument.  I told my wife that she was being unreasonable because she was wrong for invading our daughter’s privacy in the first place and our daughter’s reaction was normal.

ADVERTISEMENT

My wife remained silent so I went up to my daughter’s room and sat with her for a while.  I told her that it was wrong to yell at her mother but she had every right to get upset and because of that, she was un-grounded. She seemed to cheer up a bit at that.

When my wife found out about this she was not happy and she said that our daughter is still too young and so she had the right to know what was going on in our daughter’s life so she would know when to step in and how to teach our daughter.

ADVERTISEMENT

She thought my daughter’s attitude was terrible for yelling when my wife was just trying to help. Then she accused me of siding our daughter every time and never seeing her point of view on things.. AITA here?

Edit: Wow I didn’t expect this to blow up. Thanks for your responses, upvotes and awards! I have tried to read all the comments here although I probably have missed some out here and there (sorry). Just a small update, I bought my daughter a diary with a lock as suggested by some of you.

ADVERTISEMENT

I don’t know if she’ll write in it but hopefully she feels that she has more privacy now that the diary has a lock and she’s the only one with the key. I also talked to my wife. I told her once again to respect our daughter’s privacy and that this incident has had a negative impact on my daughter

and she will have difficulty trusting her again. My wife admitted that she shouldn’t have read my daughter’s diary. She has yet to apologise to our daughter, though.. Thanks again for all the responses and I will provide more updates.

This family flare-up, sparked by a diary invasion, exposes the delicate balance of trust in parenting. The mother’s decision to read her daughter’s diary, driven by worry, backfired when the teen’s justified anger was met with punishment. The father, countering with empathy, lifted the grounding, highlighting a rift in parenting approaches.

Dr. John Gottman, a family dynamics expert, says, “Trust is built by respecting boundaries, especially in adolescence”. The mother’s invasion, though well-intentioned, shattered her daughter’s trust, a bond that takes years to rebuild. Studies show 70% of teens value privacy as critical to their emotional growth.

ADVERTISEMENT

This scenario reflects broader issues of parental overreach versus teen autonomy. The father’s support validates his daughter’s feelings, but the parents must align. Dr. Gottman suggests family meetings to rebuild trust: the mother could apologize, and both could encourage open dialogue.

Here’s how people reacted to the post:

Reddit’s armchair judges didn’t hold back, tossing out sharp insights and witty jabs like confetti at a parenting debate.

[Reddit User] − NTA. You did good. But your daughter is never going to trust your wife again, between the gross i**asion of privacy and the irrational response to being called out on it... Ick. I'd keep an extra close eye on your wife for a while,

ADVERTISEMENT

OP, to see what else she tries to do. People don't do just one kind of privacy i**asion, especially with that kind of reasoning behind it. And if she does keep doing it, it might be better for you and your daughter to just get away.

acabxox − NTA. Your wife is completely in the wrong here; and it’s disgusting she’s trying to punish your daughter for being upset when your wife literally read her fuckin diary. Omg. I’d be fuming if I were your daughter. She didn’t deserve the grounding at all and it’s gross your wife is trying to punish her for having feelings.

nannylive − NTA, but. actually. maybe you could have told your wife that you were going to unground your daughter and given her a chance to take it back herself.. You and your wife need to get on the same page in parenting. Counseling will help.

ADVERTISEMENT

Bearmancartoons − NTA but I think there needs to be discussion about your daughter feeling she can't come to you when she is feeling obviously down. Either encourage her that you are available no matter what or offer up that she find a school counselor or therapist that she may be more freely open to talking to.

MrsMalch − NTA- your wife invaded your daughters privacy at an age where privacy is very important. She lost her trust and it will take her years to earn her daughters trust back. Your daughter was working through her problems on her own.

I bet she would have come to y’all when she was ready. But your wife rushed her and broken her trust. I feel sorry for your wife because she has lost an important part of her relationship with her daughter.. Thank you for being on your daughters side. For being someone she feel she can trust.

ADVERTISEMENT

ApartLocksmith1 − NTA, and your wife has now created a bigger problem. Your daughter was upset due to friendship issues. Now on top of that she has to deal with the fact that she can't trust her mother. Her diary, which was once a place to vent, explore her thoughts and spill her heart out, is now an object of betrayal.

Your wife has done so much damage. Screaming at your daughter, grounding her, all AFTER reading her diary, compounds her a/holeness. Her justification for reading the diary 'because daughter is young' is not acceptable.

She has overstepped and betrayed and your daughter deserves so much better. Of course you were right to cancel your daughter being grounded. The next step for you is to purchase a strong lock box for your daughter so she has a safe place away from her mother's prying eyes.

ADVERTISEMENT

Hopefully your wife's nosiness has not turned your daughter off keeping a diary in future. (I'm speaking from experience, I stopped keeping a diary after my mother and father read mine). You sound like a lovely caring dad and your daughter is lucky to have you.

tenebrous5 − NTA. Your wife has been inconsiderate about your daughter's privacy and your point of view. She has also managed to make this about herself rather than about your daughter. She's behaving very immaturely

MountainCityDweller − Normally it's good to keep a united front, but in this case NTA. Your daughter needs to have someone in her corner in respects to her right to maintain her boundaries.. Your wife invaded your daughters privacy, outed herself, and then punished your daughter for reacting to that fact.

ADVERTISEMENT

ReinaDulce − NTA. Your wife is a big A H for violating your daughters trust and this is the kind of stuff that will come up in her therapy sessions as an adult. You standing up for her really helps her feel at least that someone values her and her feelings, but this controlling manipulative attitude from you wife is toxic. Maybe get your daughter a new diary with a lock so she still has a place to vent and just get it out?

[Reddit User] − NTA.. Oh god your poor daughter. Your wife was anxious regarding your daughters unhappiness. Rather than facing her anxiety she let it control her to do irrational things such as invade your daughters privacy.

Now your wife is trying to rationalise it and deflect making it you and your daughter who are in the wrong. You and your daughter need to have a united front here in order to get through to your wife. Your wife has no power and that will also be pissing her off.

ADVERTISEMENT

What will actually tell you the type of person your wife is is whether or not she will calm down after 12 - 24 hours and have a civilised conversation about it or whether she will try and garner support from other friends and family members in an attempt to peer-pressure you. If she does that then that is just a million red flags imo.

These Reddit takes are fiery, but do they capture the full story? Is the dad a champion of trust, or is there room for compromise?

This diary drama reveals how quickly trust can unravel when boundaries are crossed. The father’s choice to unground his daughter defends her right to privacy, but the mother’s concern, though misguided, stems from love. Balancing teen autonomy with parental care is no easy feat. Have you ever faced a family trust breach? What would you do in this dad’s shoes? Drop your thoughts below and let’s keep the conversation alive!

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *