AITA for telling my wife she could quit her job if she wanted to?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In a quiet suburban home, the soft glow of a desk lamp illuminates a woman’s tear-streaked face as she pours her heart into a notebook, scribbling stories between shifts as a healthcare provider. Let’s call her Emma, whose husband, Tom, watches helplessly as her job drains her spirit. Emma once dreamed of being a writer, but stability won over passion. Now, her nightly tears signal a breaking point, and Tom’s suggestion that she quit her job to pursue her dreams sparks a fiery clash.

This isn’t just about a career change—it’s about love, sacrifice, and the weight of expectations. Tom wants Emma to find joy, but her fear of dependency and familial disappointment looms large. Reddit’s armchair therapists jumped in, offering a mix of empathy and advice. Let’s dive into this heartfelt drama, where good intentions meet raw emotions.

‘AITA for telling my wife she could quit her job if she wanted to?’

So my wife is a healthcare provider. Lately she's been disillusioned with her job (emotionally draining and just not her passion) and she's been regretting her career choice. She's spent the last couple days crying after work, saying that she gave up on her dreams too easily (she originally wanted to get a creative writing masters and become a working writer,

but turned her back on that path due to its lack of stability). She still writes, but only in a spare hour here and there and when work doesn't drain her. It's so hard for me to see her cry like this. I told her if she wanted she could quit her job and pursue the masters she wants, pursue a new career.

She snapped at me and said that she refuses to be my dependent and that I don't value her contributions to the household. I definitely do, I just want her to be happy and we'd be perfectly fine on just my salary. She says I'd lose respect for her if she quit and she'd let her family down after they paid so much for her schooling.. AITA for suggesting she quit her job to find her passion?

Tom’s well-meaning suggestion to Emma hit a nerve, revealing the complex dance of support and independence in marriage. Dr. Esther Perel, a renowned psychotherapist, notes, “Partners often struggle when one’s dreams clash with shared responsibilities, especially under emotional strain” (Esther Perel). Emma’s burnout in healthcare, compounded by her regret over abandoning writing, fuels her distress, while Tom’s offer to support her financially feels like a dismissal of her contributions.

This situation reflects a broader issue: career dissatisfaction among healthcare workers. A 2024 study from the American Medical Association found that 44% of healthcare providers experience burnout, with many regretting their career paths (AMA). Emma’s fear of dependency is valid; relying on Tom’s income could shift their dynamic, especially if she feels it diminishes her role.

Dr. Perel advises couples to co-create a “shared vision” for big decisions. Tom could propose a phased approach—like Emma working part-time while taking writing courses—to ease financial fears while nurturing her passion. Programs like online MFAs or writing workshops could offer flexibility (Poets & Writers). Tom should practice active listening, validating Emma’s fears without pushing solutions. For example, acknowledging her pride in contributing financially can rebuild trust.

A practical step could be exploring hybrid solutions, like part-time healthcare work or freelance writing to test the waters. Tom and Emma need a calm, structured talk to map out logistics, ensuring Emma feels supported without losing her sense of self. It’s about partnership, not rescue missions.

Let’s dive into the reactions from Reddit:

The Reddit crew rolled up with a mix of heart and humor, dissecting Tom and Emma’s clash like seasoned relationship coaches. Here’s the raw scoop from the crowd:

ADVERTISEMENT

WebbieVanderquack − NAH. I think you meant well, but possibly if she's in a lot of turmoil about what to do and you said 'we'd be perfectly fine on just my salary' that might have sounded to her like 'the work that's been so emotionally draining for you is actually totally unnecessary.'

Making a living as a writer is *hard*, so she probably would be dependant on you financially, and that's a difficult position for someone to be in when they're used to earning a decent living.. She shouldn't have snapped, but she was upset.

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] − NAH. in that moment she just needed a shoulder to cry on, not advice. and what she said about being dependent and you losing respect for her are her very real fears and reasons for why she stays in her job. it would be better to talk about the reality of allowing her to quit her job to pursue her dream at a non-emotionally charged moment when things are calm and both of you can have a discussion about logistics.

Droluk1 − NAH, she is upset that she isn't able to do something she is passionate about and you're being completely supportive of her. I think you both just need to sit down and have a talk about this. Tell her she wouldn't be your dependent but rather a partner who is pursuing her dreams and how you want that for her.

ADVERTISEMENT

ohshitakemushrooms − NTA. But I feel like you both need to have a conversation about this when she’s not upset, crying and frustrated. Clearly she has some perceptions about what it would mean to stop earning and be completely financially dependent on you.

It makes her insecure and that is frankly understandable. I think you need to reassure and reaffirm your support for her in a gentle, non-confrontational way, and let her know that you’ll unconditionally support her trying to pursue her passions, rather than toil away at a job that eats away her mental health.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ok_Smell_8260 − NAH. You meant well, but providing solutions felt to her like telling her she'd failed. I think you need to try some active listening, similar to a coaching conversation (but not pushing it if she's not in the mood to talk about it). For example:. * where would she like to be. * what are the options for helping her get there. * what support would she like from you. * what does she want to do next

psych0303 − The pandemic has left a lot of us with compassion fatigue. Maybe suggesting a vacation or a day to relax at a spa etc would be helpful. I took 4 days because I’m flat out tired. The pandemic is “over”(which it’s not and yet the things that helped are ending) and yet there’s still high volumes of need.

It’s a lot to process on top of a job that is demanding already. I cannot stand when I’m gaslit over having normal human feelings during a pandemic and everything else happening in the world. Listening, reminding her of why she loves her job, how much you love and support her and offering things that are restful.

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] − NTA. You're just trying to help.

philadelphialawyer87 − NAH. But sounds more like Relationship Advice to me.

Cultural_Industry429 − NTA. Maybe she could go part time. That way she’ll still be contributing to the household but will free up some time to look at other options.

ADVERTISEMENT

Warriormuffinhed − NAH. But I think encouraging her to write again could be a very good middle point here. She's clearly upset and feeling o**rwhelmed and torn. Quitting her stable and lucrative job and going back to school as a creative writer is really likely not a realistic solution, which is why she probably snapped at you.

Sometimes when people make unrealistic suggestions to your conundrums, it makes you feel unheard and that the person is just throwing out placations. Which I know in my case can make me super frustrated as it ends up feeling like an entirely unhelpful conversation to a logic-based thinker (I am also in healthcare).

But maybe sit down and plan out with her what other chores or time sinks can be readjusted or offloaded to give her the time and space to take an writing course and indulge in her passion? It is possible to have it all to a certain extent at times. But it takes a lot of work, support, and planning to make it happen.

ADVERTISEMENT

These Redditors served up a buffet of perspectives, from cheering Tom’s support to urging better timing for his advice. But do their takes capture the full picture, or are they just stirring the emotional pot?

Tom and Emma’s story is a poignant reminder that love means navigating dreams and fears together, not fixing them with quick solutions. Emma’s burnout and Tom’s support highlight the delicate balance of independence and partnership. A heart-to-heart could chart a path forward, blending practicality with passion. Have you ever faced a career crossroads that strained a relationship? What would you do in Tom’s place to support a partner’s dreams? Share your thoughts below and let’s keep the conversation flowing!

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *