AITA for telling my students the real reason why they take so many standardized tests?

Venus Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In a bustling 8th-grade classroom, a teacher’s honesty stirs up trouble. When students demand to know why they face endless standardized tests, their 31-year-old teacher reveals the truth—state policies and teacher evaluations—contradicting a coworker’s claim that teachers chose the tests. The coworker, a second-year teacher, loses control of her class after students call out her lie, and now demands an apology.

Picture the fallout: a staffroom rift over truth and trust. This Reddit AITA post dives into educational transparency and workplace tension, leaving readers to weigh in: was the teacher wrong for being honest, or did the coworker’s lie spark her own downfall?

‘AITA for telling my students the real reason why they take so many standardized tests?’

I (31F) teach 8th grade, and they get assessed. A lot. A WHOLE lot. It seems every month there’s a test they have to take, which causes us teachers to alter our plans and timelines to fit them in. I announced another test starting next week, and one of my students asked “why the hell do we take so many tests?”

ADVERTISEMENT

I told him to watch his language but stood there for a few second, and I asked them if they really wanted to know. My class of 33 said “YES!” and immediately started complaining amongst themselves. So, I told them. Mostly, it’s a state policy requirement and their evaluation counts on teacher evaluations (value added) and the state wants to monitor their growth as much as possible.

Well, I found out today that a coworker of mine had been telling the kids it’s because we teachers have decided to do it because we thought it was best (which is a lie, like, literally no teacher agrees with all these tests despite what you might hear from politicians and the media).

The kids had started asking her why she was lying because my class told her class the real reason. And apparently, this caused her to lose control of her class yesterday. People are telling me to apologize because I revealed information that hurt another teacher. But my team (we are teams of 4 for the core subjects) think that’s ridiculous and it’s her own fault for lying in the first place.

This coworker will not speak to me until I apologize, but I feel I didn’t do anything wrong. She apparently was lying to them because she didn’t think we were supposed to tell the kids the reason but I didn’t see a problem. If they have to take all of these tests then I feel they should at least know why.. So AITA? Should I apologize to this teacher?

ADVERTISEMENT

Honesty in education can be a double-edged sword, especially when colleagues aren’t aligned. The 8th-grade teacher, facing her students’ frustration over frequent tests, shared the real reason—state mandates and evaluation metrics—only to unravel a coworker’s lie that teachers opted for the tests. The coworker’s loss of classroom control and demand for an apology highlight a clash: transparency with students versus workplace harmony.

This reflects a broader challenge in education: balancing student trust with professional cohesion. The coworker’s lie, likely meant to shield students, backfired by eroding her credibility. Dr. Linda Darling-Hammond, an education policy expert, notes, “Students, especially in middle school, value honesty; misleading them risks losing their respect.” The teacher’s truth aligned with this, but it exposed her coworker’s misstep, escalating tensions.

A staff meeting to align on transparency policies could prevent future conflicts, while the coworker might benefit from mentorship on classroom management and honesty. The teacher could offer a diplomatic apology for the unintended fallout, not the truth itself.

ADVERTISEMENT

Here’s the feedback from the Reddit community:

Reddit’s serving up sharp takes, from teacher solidarity to student respect. Here’s what users think about this classroom controversy:

RollingKatamari - NTA these kids aren't stupid, they can literally find out online. This teacher is completely disrespecting her students and underestimating them by blatantly lying to them.

ADVERTISEMENT

saran1111 - No mate, never apologise for exposing someone else's lie. NTA.

salukiqueen - NTA Fellow teacher here and I agree that she brought this on herself. Lying to your kids is never a good idea and what was she hoping to gain out of her lie specifically? Because all it does is say she doesn’t know good practice (all those assessments are not helpful, I agree with you).

ADVERTISEMENT

So why lie? It sucks she got caught in a lie but that’s not on you. I don’t know if she’d be receptive to it, but if you think she would be maybe she needs guidance on 1) classroom management because it’s not great that she lost control of her classroom and 2) building relationships with her kids. It’s hard as a new teacher and I say this as a second year teacher myself.

chucker23n - NTA. Sooner or later, some of the kids will read up on the subject and find out the truth anyway.. Don’t lie to kids. Simplify for age-appropriateness, but don’t lie.

ADVERTISEMENT

Rolling_Beardo - NTA , it’s common knowledge why these tests exist the other teacher is a fool for lying about something that is so easily proven false.. Edit: I put the wrong vote

PurpleWomat - It's her fault for lying in the first place but, for the sake of workplace harmony, I might be inclined to give her a qualified apology regardless. E.g., 'I'm sorry that I put you in a difficult position, that wasn't my intention.' And perhaps have a staff meeting where you all agree not to lie to the kids, because kids *will* gossip.. NTA

ADVERTISEMENT

mzinformd - NTA. That other teacher lied and is upset with you because instead of just asking, “hey my students want to know why we’re testing so much, can I tell them?” She made up a stupid lie and got caught. I work with kids in schools for the past 22 years. If there is ONE thing I know, you can’t lie to them because they’ll never trust you again if they find out. She made a bad choice and that’s on her.

Dont-trust-it - NTA. Kids deserve the respect of an honest answer to a question, i believe if they are old enough to ask a question they are old enough to receive an age appropriate answer. Other teacher is TA and is only suffering because she got caught in her own lie, thats not on you. You have no need to apologise.

ADVERTISEMENT

ladybird2223 - Teacher here. I told my 4th and 5th graders that our state test was required by the state, it doesn't impact their grades/report card, but gives the state info in how our school is doing compared to other schools. All I asked was that they just try their best.

Honestly this made them far less stressed out about them. If my elementary kids don't want BS there is no way in hell 8th graders want and accept it. The teacher made her own bed and as a beginning teacher she will learn quickly that junior high students are not babies.

ADVERTISEMENT

artemis1860 - NTA. 1. The answer you gave was easy to find in a google search. 2. If she didn’t know if the kids were or weren’t supposed to know (being a fairly new teacher, she should have asked around.. 3. Before lying she should have made sure other teachers were on the same page. 4. It’s always dumb to lie to students, quite frankly they’re never as dumb as some seem to think. They’ll figure it out.

These opinions hit hard, but do they capture the full balance of honesty and harmony?

ADVERTISEMENT

This teacher’s tale is a lesson in truth’s ripple effects. Was she right to tell her students the real reason for tests, or should she have protected her coworker? Would you spill the beans to students, or keep the peace with a fib? Share your thoughts below!

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *