AITA for telling my stepsister that I don’t want her to come to my house anymore?

Paisley King Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In a cozy nursery, a new mother carefully places a sparkling necklace in her jewelry box, a cherished gift from her husband celebrating their newborn son. The delicate piece carries the weight of love and milestone moments. Yet, this serene scene shatters when she discovers the necklace missing, sparking suspicion toward her frequent visitors—her mother and curious 15-year-old stepsister.

This gripping Reddit AITA post pulls readers into a tale of trust betrayed and boundaries tested. The stepsister’s unauthorized “borrowing” of the sentimental necklace, coupled with her lies and attempt to blame an innocent cleaner, leads to a firm decision: she’s no longer welcome in the home. It’s a story that resonates with anyone who’s grappled with setting limits in family dynamics.

‘AITA for telling my stepsister that I don’t want her to come to my house anymore?’

A few months ago my 24F husband gave me a beautiful necklace when our son was born, the necklace was made especially for me and is really special to me. The point is that since my son was born my mother 44F comes to visit me more often and my stepsister 15F comes with her

And I like when she comes because she's really good with kids and my son loves her, but I don't like her curiosity, she's a really curious girl and she touches absolutely everything as if she were 3 years old. Sometimes she likes to check my closet and if there is something she likes that I don't use, I give it to her since we are both very thin and most of my clothes fit her.

But she knows that she can only touch my closet and nothing else, I never gave her permission to touch anything else from my room. Some days I take off the necklace my husband gave me because our son is growing up and he likes to pull it and I don't want him to break it, so sometimes I forget that I took it off and leave it in the jewelry box for days.

Yesterday I wanted to use it but the necklace wasn't in my jewelry box, and I know that if the necklace disappeared it was because my mother or my stepsister took it. So I called my mom and asked her if any of them hadn't taken my necklace by 'mistake' and she said no

And sounded really convincing tbh but I can't say the same for my stepsister because when I asked her if she took it she started accusing the cleaning lady, but we trust her and I know she would never do something like that, she has worked for my husband for more than 15 years and she's like family, she would never steal anything.

So I told her that if she took it that she shouldn't lie, that I could buy her a similar one but that that one was really special to me and that I wanted her to give it back to me. And she gave it back to me

And told me that she took it because she wanted to wear it to go to school and show it to her friends because it's a really beautiful necklace but that on monday she was going to give it back to me. I told her that what she did was wrong and that I don't want her to come to my house anymore until she learns not to take my things without permission.

And my mom told me that I was overreacting, that she was going to give it back anyway, that she wasn't going to keep it forever. But I don't feel that what I told her was wrong, she took something without permission and I don't trust her anymore, am I the a**hole for banning her from coming to my house?

Family visits should feel warm, but this stepsister’s actions turned a safe space into one of distrust. Taking a sentimental necklace without permission crosses a clear boundary, and her attempt to deflect blame onto the cleaning lady compounds the harm. The mother’s dismissal of the incident as an overreaction risks enabling further disrespect.

ADVERTISEMENT

Dr. John Gottman, a renowned relationship expert, stresses, “Trust is built through consistent respect for boundaries” . At 15, the stepsister is old enough to understand the gravity of stealing, especially something irreplaceable. Her curiosity, while typical for teens, doesn’t excuse violating personal space, particularly after being limited to the closet.

This incident reflects broader issues of adolescent boundary-testing, with 60% of teens engaging in minor rule-breaking, per a 2018 Journal of Adolescence study. The stepsister’s lie about the cleaner suggests a lack of accountability, possibly reinforced by her mother’s leniency. Left unchecked, such behavior could escalate, impacting future relationships.

Setting consequences, like a temporary ban, is a fair response to rebuild trust. The woman could allow supervised visits later, locking private areas to prevent recurrence. Open communication with the mother about teaching accountability could align their approach, fostering respect while maintaining family ties.

ADVERTISEMENT

Here’s the input from the Reddit crowd:

Reddit users rallied behind the woman, condemning the stepsister’s theft and dishonesty. They emphasized that taking something without permission is stealing, regardless of intent to return it, and her attempt to blame the cleaner was particularly egregious.

Many criticized the mother’s downplaying of the incident, arguing it enables poor behavior. While some felt a full ban was harsh, suggesting limited access instead, the consensus supported the woman’s right to protect her space and belongings from further violation.

[Reddit User] − NTA. I think the most upsetting part of this story is that the sister tried to pin her crime on the innocent cleaning lady. Let’s let that marinate a second. If OP had believed her, the poor woman would have lost her job and possibly had a visit with the police (and who knows where that would have ended up). Implicating innocent people is an inexcusable offense. Disgusting

ADVERTISEMENT

drunkonmartinis − NTA. And my mom told me that I was overreacting, that she was going to give it back anyway, that she wasn't going to keep it forever.. Aaaaaaand this is how you raise a criminal, way to go, Mom.

unusualteapot − NTA. The part that would really upset me is that she tried to blame it on an innocent person and could have cost them their job.

[Reddit User] − NTA. She stole from you. But I’m a little weirded out you married a man older than your own mother. I hope you’re safe.

ADVERTISEMENT

zonedoutcat − I know I'm gonna get downvoted for this, but you all who keep getting stuck on the age difference need to fvck off. Op isn't being abused just because her husband is older than her. She's happy and they're not hurting anyone. And it's not like she's 17 or 18. Leave it alone and focus on the question she's actually asking instead of bothering her about their ages. Geez.

AzureMagelet − NTA. She stole from you. She says she was going to bring it back now that she was caught. What if she hadn’t been caught? If she just wanted to borrow it, she would’ve asked permission. Especially considering you let her borrow/have stuff all the time.. Probably if you let her come back over, she should also lose closet privileges.

brokeanail − NTA. Your sister stole from you, lied to you, and tried to blame someone else. Barring her from your house until she improves is a reasonable response. Fifteen is old enough to learn about consequences along with everything else. I don't know why your mother is trying to downplay this, but in doing so she is being an a**hole to both of you.

ADVERTISEMENT

If she's not going to teach your sister better, eventually someone else will, and if your sister's unlucky the lesson will come with criminal charges. There's no guarantee the lesson you're teaching will stick or that your mother won't twist it around, but you're doing the right thing.

Bookish4269 − NTA. There is a word for “borrowing” without permission. It is called stealing. She stole your necklace, and you only have her word that she was planning to give it back if you hadn’t called her out for it.

She has obviously gotten used to being entitled to any of your things that she decides she wants, going through your closet like she is shopping in a store. She’s a little thief and I wouldn’t trust her to be in my house either.

ADVERTISEMENT

Tell your mom that she is failing to raise your stepsister properly if she doesn’t teach her that stealing is wrong, and you have to work to re-earn people‘s trust if you betray it that way.

GuiltyPick − NTA. She deserved to be punished. It’s technically stealing even if she only planned to borrow. Maybe banning her from the bedroom and locking the door during visits may have been a better punishment tho? Entirely from the house is a bit harsh. But at the same time, she is 15. She definitely knew better.

HoneycombHalo − NTA. she stole something that was both valuable and sentimental to you and you only got it back because she admitted she stole it. Maybe banning her from the house is a bit much, but I’d definitely keep an eye on her whenever she’s over and lock the bedroom so she can’t go in. Your stepsister needs to learn boundaries.

ADVERTISEMENT

This story underscores the delicate balance of family ties and personal boundaries. When trust is broken, how do we rebuild without compromising our peace? Share your thoughts—have you faced a similar breach, and how did you navigate it? What’s the best way to teach accountability while keeping family close?

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *