AITA for telling my sister that I don’t want to hear her complaining about being pregnant?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In a cozy suburban home, the air hums with the chaos of toddler tantrums and the weight of unspoken frustrations. A young woman, juggling her demanding job as a paramedic, finds herself tethered to her sister’s bedside, helping manage a whirlwind of young nephews and a high-risk pregnancy. The tension is palpable—every cry from the kids feels like a siren in her already sleepless nights. Readers can’t help but wonder: how much can one person give before they snap under the pressure of family duty?

This story unfolds a raw, relatable family drama, where love for innocent nephews clashes with exhaustion and unfiltered honesty. The original poster (OP) faces a storm of emotions, torn between loyalty and her own breaking point. Readers are drawn into the messy reality of caregiving, questioning where the line lies between support and self-preservation in a family stretched thin.

 

‘AITA for telling my sister that I don’t want to hear her complaining about being pregnant?’

I have three nephews. They were born in January 2020, November 2020 and February 2022. My sister is pregnant again and due in December. The succession of pregnancies so close together has taken its toll and my sister is on bedrest. Besides using the washroom and going to medical appointments my sister doesn't leave her bed.

She is under the care of specialists. Me, my parents and my BIL's parents have been doing what we can to assist in looking after her and my nephews. The succession of pregnancies meant my sister had to leave her job. My BIL works but his job can't be done remotely and with my sister on bedrest and three kids under age three at home they need help.

They can't afford daycare for my two oldest nephews and my youngest nephew is still too young yet. But their lives are in complete chaos and relying on us to keep things afloat. Me, my parents and his parents chip in where we can. Even my grandparents and his grandparents have helped a little despite their ages.

But the bulk of it is being done by me and my and his parents. I am happy to help if only to make things better for my nephews. I want to be a good aunt. They are just kids and this mess isn't their fault. I have even refrained from commenting until now because of how exhausted and floundering my sister and BIL are.

They don't need me to tell them how much of a mess this is. I said something to my sister only because I was tired of hearing her complain about her pregnancy and bedrest. I'm sure it's not a picnic to be dealing with a high risk pregnancy but this situation is of her and my BIL's making.

Me, my parents and his parents all have full time jobs and we are rotating to ensure my sister and my nephews are cared for. I'm a paramedic and I have nightmares of getting called to their address because she and the baby are in distress. It's a real possibility given how fragile her pregnancy is.

My sister and BIL are university educated and where we live they can access contraception and birth control at no cost. Doctors have repeatedly warned them about getting pregnant so soon after my sister gave birth. There is no excuse for the mess they have created.

ADVERTISEMENT

I love my nephews more than anything but my sister and BIL have completely destroyed their lives for the foreseeable future. When I told my sister I don't need to hear her complaining because she got herself into this situation she got really angry.

My BIL chided me the next day for what I said as well. It may seem harsh but I am already exhausted from my job and giving up my days off to help them. I do it for my nephews and I never commented throughout all the pregnancies before now. They are both angry at me though.

ADVERTISEMENT

This family’s saga feels like a pressure cooker, with the OP caught in the steam of her sister’s choices. The sister’s rapid pregnancies, despite medical warnings, have created a domino effect, pulling everyone into a vortex of caregiving. The OP’s frustration is understandable—she’s not just an aunt but a lifeline, balancing a high-stakes job with family demands. Her sharp words to her sister reflect a breaking point, not malice, highlighting a classic case of caregiver burnout.

This situation mirrors a broader issue: the strain of family expectations in reproductive choices. According to a 2021 study by the Guttmacher Institute, access to contraception significantly reduces unplanned pregnancies, yet personal choices can override even free resources (guttmacher.org). The OP’s sister and brother-in-law, educated and with access to birth control, made choices that ripple outward, burdening their support network.

ADVERTISEMENT

Dr. Jane Adams, a family therapist, notes, “When family members are drafted into caregiving without consent, resentment can build, eroding relationships” (psychologytoday.com). Her insight applies directly: the OP’s outburst stems from being conscripted into a role she didn’t choose. The sister’s complaints, while valid, amplify the strain on those already stretched thin.

For solutions, open communication is key. The OP could set boundaries, perhaps offering specific help (e.g., one day a week) while encouraging her sister to explore government assistance programs, like childcare subsidies. A family meeting could clarify expectations, ensuring gratitude is expressed and burdens are shared more equitably.

ADVERTISEMENT

Here’s the input from the Reddit crowd:

The Reddit crowd didn’t hold back, serving up a mix of empathy and tough love. Here’s a peek at their hot takes, straight from the AITA thread:

runningaway67907 − NTA but i think it might be time for you to step back from helping them so much because this isn't healthy for you and your relationship with them, what are they planning to do once the baby arrives, will you still be expected to help, can they look into governments assistance .

StAlvis − NTA My sister and BIL are university educated and where we live they can access contraception and birth control at no cost.. They **chose** to destroy their lives with children they're unable or unwilling to care for.. *Let it burn*.

ADVERTISEMENT

Alternative-Click-15 − NTA everyone is stressing themselves out because they couldn't bother to use some form of contraceptive. voicing your frustrations doesn't make you the bad guy.

tigerCELL − NTA. You're allowed to snap, you've been pushed past your breaking point by your own empathy and selflessness. If it were me, I'd eat bon bons and take a nap, no one else's kid is my problem. You've sacrificed a lot for your nephews and sister, she should quit whining and get her big girl bra out of her purse.

Your BIL couldn't even manage his penis snot for 2 years straight, that's your sister's problem, not yours. This won't stop, by the way, in 2023 she'll be pregnant again. It's some sick fetish for a lot of males. You may need to wash your hands of this to preserve your mental health.

ADVERTISEMENT

Suchafatfatcat − NTA. Their lack of proper planning does not obligate you to be a Mary Poppins stand-in. To conceive a fourth child when they cannot afford childcare for the ones they already have, is stupid and selfish.

Mysconduct − NTA. You, your parents, and BIL parents have gone above and beyond to help your sister and BIL. Caregiver burnout is a real thing and it sounds like you all need a break. As the doctors have said your sister and BIL need to start being responsible adults and use some sort of contraception.

It is not responsible to be having children that closely in succession, especially if you can't care for them yourself. While your sister has every right to express her frustration about being stuck in bed all day, everyday, she doesn't have the right to tell you that you can't express your own frustration.

ADVERTISEMENT

I really hope that she and your BIL are doing things to express their gratitude for all that you and parents are doing to help them and not taking your caregiving for granted as they are not entitled to it.

[Reddit User] − NTA - but it's the truth, they got themselves in that situation. Maybe they need to do it all themselves.

boniemonie − NTA. You are at breaking point. And through no fault of your own. Your sister is too (hormones don’t help), but as you justifiably point out: she had a say in this: you didn’t. I would try to have a quiet talk with them, let them know that you care deeply, but complaints from them are not what is needed now.

ADVERTISEMENT

If you don’t think it will go down as you think, perhaps text them. Add a time table of your last couple of weeks to show how much it has impacted. And it will though the pregnancy and probably beyond. Stress you are happy to do it, especially for those adored nephews,

but keep negative thoughts to themselves as you and the family are doing your level best. I would also organise to have an few days in a row off: reconnect with friends and go and do some fun things. You are a great aunt, your sister is super lucky to have you! Best wishes!

BaoBunny44 − Oh god. My aunt is like this. She has a ton of mental health issues and would just not stop getting pregnant. She was told after the 3rd her uterus was going to detach and she got pregnant 2 more times. And she's the type to shove off her small kids onto everyone at family functions and disappear

ADVERTISEMENT

If you ever said no or tried to give the kids back she'd throw a fit. It ruined so many events because I'd be stuck with a screaming infant for hours. She was talking to someone about wanting more children and I just noped out of there. Her life,the kids lives, and her family's lives are chaos and she just does not care. It's infuriating.. NTA, OP it's time to take a break and step back from helping.

romantic_elegy − NTA. It sounds like your sister's family planning included contributions of time and labor from the whole family. That's a perfectly fine scenario IF it's agreed on beforehand but it's clearly not the case here. They're in a tough situation but it's unreasonable for her to just assume that everyone in her life wants to help raise her kids.

If I were you I would send a text/email explaining that you can't handle contributing that much to her family and either offer a smaller, clearly defined amount of support or withdraw completely. I'm guessing your relationship is going to suffer for a while either way.

ADVERTISEMENT

These Reddit opinions pack a punch, but do they capture the full weight of family loyalty versus personal limits? It’s a messy debate, and the community’s divided stance shows just how tricky this situation is.

This story leaves us tangled in the messy threads of family obligation and personal breaking points. The OP’s love for her nephews shines, but her exhaustion raises a universal question: how do you balance helping loved ones with protecting your own sanity? Readers, what would you do if you were in the OP’s shoes, juggling a demanding job and a family in chaos? Share your thoughts and experiences—let’s spark a conversation about where to draw the line.

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *