AITA for telling my SIL to get over herself and stop trying to one up us?

Jonathan Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Imagine a cozy family lunch, filled with the soft coos of newborns and the glow of proud grandparents. But beneath the surface, a subtle rivalry simmers. A young couple, still reeling from the rollercoaster of a premature birth, beams as they share their son’s first laugh. Yet, like a record scratch, the sister-in-law chimes in, turning joy into a competition. Her words sting, reopening wounds from a traumatic delivery.

This Reddit tale pulls us into the raw emotions of a 29-year-old dad defending his wife and preemie son against relentless one-upping. His outburst at his sister-in-law’s insensitive comparisons sparks family tension, leaving readers to ponder: was he too harsh, or was his frustration long overdue? With a mix of heart and heat, let’s unpack this drama and cheer for the little fighter stealing the show.

‘AITA for telling my SIL to get over herself and stop trying to one up us?’

Throwaway account. My (29M) wife (27F) and her sister (30F) got pregnant around the same time. The babies are the first of a new generation on their side of the family so everyone was excited. SIL was further along, but my wife ended up giving birth on week 32, plus she had some complications that had her hospitalized.

My nephew was born 2 weeks later at full term. Apparently SIL was resenting

This upset my wife since during her hospitalization she was often too sick to visit the NICU and she's already feeling crappy about missing skin-to-skin on those first few weeks. After we started to bring our son to family gatherings SIL started comparing the boys. Saying how much bigger and more alert her son looks like compared to ours and how he hit more milestones.

Last weekend we had lunch at my in laws'. My wife and I were excited to tell everyone that our son laughed for the first time earlier that day (he's 5.5 months old, 3.5 corrected). MIL and FIL were having a good time watching the video when SIL made another comment about how HER son did that a month ago

I don't know why that was the last straw, but I just about had it. I told SIL that she's pathetic for trying to one-up a freaking baby. That her full term son wasn't special for being more developed than a preemie. That she should get the f*** over not giving birth to the first grandbaby.

Needless to say this ruined lunch and my wife's family is pissed. I admit I was harsh with my words and tone and this was the first time I confronted her family like this. Up until now we'd each handle our own relatives. But these comments upset my wife and pissed me off. So AITA for being so harsh and not staying in

Family gatherings should be a safe haven, but the SIL’s competitive jabs turned joy into judgment. The OP’s wife, already grappling with the trauma of a premature birth and NICU separation, faced added pain from her sister’s insensitivity. The OP’s outburst, while sharp, was a protective response to a pattern of hurt.

Dr. Harvey Karp, a pediatrician and parenting expert, notes, “New parents, especially those with preemies, often carry unspoken grief over missed milestones like the ‘golden hour.’ Support, not comparison, is what they need.” The SIL’s focus on her son’s development over a preemie’s ignores basic biology—preemies follow a corrected age timeline, often hitting milestones later. Her behavior reflects a broader issue: postpartum rivalry, which a 2021 study in Frontiers in Psychology found can strain family bonds when empathy is lacking.

The OP could address this by calmly discussing the impact of SIL’s words with his wife’s support, perhaps involving the in-laws to mediate. Karp suggests framing conversations around shared goals, like celebrating both babies’ unique journeys

Here’s the feedback from the Reddit community:

Reddit brought the heat, with users rallying behind the OP and roasting the SIL’s “pathetic” behavior. From calling out her jealousy to suggesting a kids’ show about milestones, the comments are a mix of righteous anger and heartfelt support. Here’s what they said:

gymngdoll − NTA. How did your wife respond?

[Reddit User] − NTA. Your SIL is a grown woman competing with a PREEMIE. That is embarrassing behavior, and someone needed to call her out. Your wife has already been through hell and back with a traumatic early birth, NICU stays, and recovery. And instead of supporting her, this woman is out here making passive-aggressive jabs about things your wife already feels heartbroken about?

Absolutely not. And the worst part? She’s acting like her full-term baby is some kind of prodigy when, newsflash, that’s just how development works. No one is shocked that her baby hit milestones sooner—because he literally had a two-month head start. That’s not an achievement, that’s basic biology.

Your reaction was warranted because this wasn’t a one-time slip-up—this was a pattern of n**ty behavior that your wife has been dealing with for MONTHS. And instead of anyone else in the family checking her, they’ve been letting her act like a jealous brat.

And now they’re mad at you because you finally said what everyone else was thinking? Too damn bad. Maybe they should’ve spoken up sooner, and you wouldn’t have had to. You weren’t harsh. You were correct. She needs to get over herself and stop trying to compete with a baby who fought just to be here.

OhmsWay-71 − Justified A**hole here.. Sure, you could have handled it differently, but that might not have stopped the s**tty behaviour. You had justifiably had enough and said what needed to be said.

Your SIL will likely think twice before making any more comparisons out loud, which needed to happen. Who knows why she is doing it. She might be postpartum, she might just be jealous. None of that needs to concern you. You did what was right for your family and you put the bully in her place.. Bravo.

Apart-Ad-6518 − NTA I told SIL that she's *pathetic for trying to one-up a freaking baby*. That her full term son wasn't special for being more developed than a preemie. That she should get the f*** over not giving birth to the first grandbaby.. Obviously this isn't the *ideal* response. However you get a total free pass on this one.. Total. Free. Pass.

Ok_Bit1981 − You have officially stepped into Papa Bear mode. I'm so glad she was put in her place.. Now where to go from here: 1. Talk to your wife. She's probably still dealing with a lot in postpartum and you need to make sure you are both on the same page. 2. Confront her parents separately from everyone. If your wife is up for discussing this situation with them, give her the support and hold space for her to have a heart to heart with her family.

If she would rather you talk, WRITE DOWN your issues and why you blew up. Of course, apologize for how you reacted, but stand firm in your protection of your wife.. especially since her own family has not stepped in. All in all, NTA! Your SIL asked for the confrontation, and you happily obliged. I know some are gonna say

1962Michael − NTA. Frankly it doesn't matter here if your SIL or the rest of her family is pissed. How does your wife feel about it? My guess is, she is glad you said something so she didn't have to. The bonus is, what needed to be said got said,

and she can just apologize for you being

cowprintbarbie − NTA! She deserved it.. I would be proud if my husband did the same in that situation. Good for you.

SillyDJ − I'm going to say NTA. BUT I need you and your wife to do me a favor. This is going to sound silly, but look up an episode from a kids show called Bluey. It's only 8 minutes long. But it's called Baby Race. Y'all should watch that. And maybe even send it to your SIL. It made me cry, but it's basically about not comparing your kids'milestones. And it touches on it in such a sweet way. It's good for the heart. Please watch it.

BayAreaPupMom − NTA. It sounds like your baby was in critical condition as well as being a premie. Moms tend to blame themselves for anything that goes wrong with their babies even if it's beyond the mother's control. For your SIL to continuously rub salt in that wound is just evil. You sound like amazing parents and bless you for being so supportive of your wife.

Her family should have shut down this golden child behavior a long time ago. Every baby is unique and even if born at term, they still develop at differently paces but we all get there at the end. It's not a race. It's all about healthy babies, healthy kids.

What matters most is that they are loved and accepted by their family, not used as some trophy to boost the parents' ego. It sounds like you held your tongue long enough and gave your SIL enough chances to demonstrate little consideration and empathy, which never happened. I hope your SIL knows to keep her mouth shut from now on.

heartsoflions2011 − NTA. As the mom of a 30-weeker as also missed out on golden hour, wasn’t allowed nurse for 4 weeks, and had to wait 7 to take my baby home…THANK YOU for shutting her down.

Missing out on that stuff still crushes me to this day, a year later, and the trauma from the delivery/NICU is going to take years to come to terms with. Your SIL is a massive A H for using your child’s birth, etc, as ammo to try to make herself/her baby look better. I’m angry for you and I don’t even know you guys.

These Reddit takes are fiery, but do they capture the full picture, or are they just fanning the flames?

This baby milestone showdown proves that family love can get tangled in envy and pride. The OP’s sharp words may have scorched the lunch table, but they came from a place of fierce loyalty to his wife and son. Was he wrong to snap, or was the SIL’s insensitivity the real spark? One thing’s clear: empathy could soothe this rift. Have you ever had to call out family for crossing a line? Share your story below and let’s talk it out!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *