AITA for telling my mom and my sister I’ll uninvite them to my wedding if they don’t leave my fiancée alone about her appearance?

A sun-dappled park, a small gathering of loved ones, and a couple ready to tie the knot—sounds like a dreamy wedding. But for one groom-to-be, his vision of a simple ceremony is clouded by family drama. His fiancée, confident in her makeup-free look, faces criticism from his mom and sister, who insist she’ll look “washed out” in photos. Their relentless pressure pushes him to a bold ultimatum: stop, or you’re uninvited.

The groom’s protective stance sparks a family feud, leaving him wondering if he’s gone too far. With Reddit buzzing and emotions high, this tale dives into the clash between personal choice and family expectations, proving that even a low-key wedding can stir up big drama.

‘AITA for telling my mom and my sister I’ll uninvite them to my wedding if they don’t leave my fiancée alone about her appearance?’

I'm getting married next month. We are keeping it small, just immediate family and a few close friends in the park on a Friday afternoon. 16 guests total plus the officiant and the photographer. For her job my fiancée works in a lab that sterilizes medical instruments and surgical equipment. There are strict requirements to work there in terms of appearance and the dress code.

They aren't allowed to wear any makeup at all, any kind of nail polish or fake nails or any kind of perfume/cologne/body spray or other scented products. If you do show up with any of that you are sent home. My fiancée tells me since they are covered from head to toe with all their skin and hair covered no one bothers with trying to look good at work.

ADVERTISEMENT

They have to wear scrubs, a protective gown, booties over their shoes, a hair net, a face mask, glasses, a face shield and double gloves. I have been dating her for almost 2 years and living with her for a year and I have never seen her wear makeup. I honestly don't care if she doesn't because she is comfortable with how she looks. She hasn't bought or worn it in 15 years because of her job.

My mom and my sister are unhappy she isn't going to wear makeup for the wedding. They say she will look 'washed out' and 'not good' in the photos. We did hire a professional photographer for the wedding. It was our biggest expense but we want to have nice photos. He has photographed hundreds of weddings and he took our engagement photos.

In our engagement photos my girlfriend didn't wear makeup and she looks fine. It was taken in the same park at the same time of day as our wedding will be. He is aware we are keeping our appearances simple and my fiancée is not wearing makeup and he said he can make it work like he did with our engagement photos.

At first I thought my mom and my sister just wanted her to look her best in the photos even if I didn't like the looking not good dig. I showed them the engagement photos but they weren't placated. They didn't let it go. My complexion, hair and eye colour are the same as my fiancée and I said I wasn't wearing makeup either.

ADVERTISEMENT

This is where I got angry because both my sister and my mom said it doesn't matter what I do because men look fine without makeup wearas women don't so it only applies to my fiancée and not me. My fiancée said it was up to me how I handle it. I told them if they mention the subject again or say anything to my fiancée again I will univite them to the wedding.

I don't even know why they care so much. But after I said I would uninvite them they were not happy and now both of them are royally mad at me. They're saying I shouldn't mistreat or talk to family this way when they were just trying to help. Also as a man I don't understand why this issue is important.

Weddings are a celebration of love, but they often unearth family tensions. The groom’s defense of his fiancée’s makeup-free choice reflects a stand for her autonomy against his mom and sister’s intrusive critiques. Their insistence that women need makeup to look “good” reveals a clash of values, rooted in societal norms about appearance.

ADVERTISEMENT

This mirrors broader issues of gendered expectations. A 2021 study by YouGov found 58% of women feel societal pressure to wear makeup for formal events (source). The fiancée’s comfort without makeup challenges these norms, which may unsettle her future in-laws.

Dr. Rachel Rodgers, a body image expert, states, “Authenticity in appearance fosters self-confidence and defies external pressures” (source). The groom’s support aligns with this, reinforcing his fiancée’s confidence. His ultimatum, while sharp, sets a clear boundary against overreach.

ADVERTISEMENT

To move forward, the groom could calmly reiterate his fiancée’s choice and redirect focus to the wedding’s joy.

Here’s the input from the Reddit crowd:

Reddit’s got a front-row seat to this family showdown, and their takes are as lively as a wedding dance floor. Check out the crowd’s thoughts:

ADVERTISEMENT

realauthormattjanak - NTA. This is your first opportunity to teach them how to behave in regards to your marriage. Use it wisely.

Lawn_Orderly - NTA. Sounds like both you and your fiancee have picked a good partner.

ADVERTISEMENT

ninasimonerules - NTA. Good for you for standing up for your fiancée. It's her face. Nothing to do with your mum or sister. Be warned. They will always be like this with her. ETA stop attributing good intentions to this. They are not trying to help. They are trying to impose their ideals on your fiancée. It's none of their business.

g-calamia - NTA. She got the trial run with her engagement photos, and if she’s happy with those that’s all that matters. It’s her (and your) day. Not theirs.

ADVERTISEMENT

0TK421 - NTA it was none of their business to begin with but I would have entertained them mentioning ONCE that she may want to wear makeup. After that it's just harassment. I'm a woman. I don't wear makeup. I didn't wear it to my wedding. My pictures turned out hella cute.. Congrats on the wedding, and good job sticking up for your fiancée!

briannaleam - NTA. You're standing up for your (future) wife as you should. Your mom and sister are definitely AH.

ADVERTISEMENT

Lila-1212 - NTA but more importantly you are definitely a great fiancé and partner. Congrats on your upcoming marriage!

dev-246 - I said I wasn’t wearing makeup either. Amazing fiancé right here!!!! NTA I’m sorry your mom and sister are giving you a hard time. I think the best way to handle this would be to shut them down quickly whenever they bring it up, by saying things like you did above, then refuse to answer any follow up questions.

ADVERTISEMENT

Sometimes people wear makeup because they’re uncomfortable in their own skin, and although I don’t think you should accuse your family of this, I think you could say you love how confident your fiancé is.

ioanaaa_ - NTA, you should wear a full face of glamorous makeup next time you see them

ADVERTISEMENT

MissionRevolution306 - NTA. Your mother and sister have internalized misogyny and you did a great job establishing boundaries! Congratulations on your marriage!

Talk about a mic-drop moment! These Reddit hot takes cut through the noise, but do they capture the whole story? Are the mom and sister meddling too much, or is there a grain of truth in their photo concerns? The groom’s caught in a classic wedding tug-of-war.

Planning a wedding is like juggling flaming torches—tricky, but the show must go on. The groom’s threat to uninvite his mom and sister defends his fiancée’s choice, but it’s stirred up family tension. Is he right to draw a hard line, or should he smooth things over? What would you do if family pushed your partner’s boundaries? Drop your thoughts below and let’s keep the conversation rolling!

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *