AITA for telling my husband’s ex to keep her jelousy to herself?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In the midst of wedding planning—with all its laughter, tears, and unforgettable moments—the last thing you expect is an uninvited dose of jealousy. As the newlywed excitement reached its peak, one family member consistently turned what should have been joyful banter into a source of discomfort. The rehearsal dinner, meant to celebrate the union, quickly soured when Maddie, the husband’s ex with lingering unresolved feelings, made a series of off-color remarks that set everyone on edge.

The tension reached its climax when the bride, tired of the passive-aggressive comments, finally told Maddie to “keep her jealousy to herself.” While her words might have been harsh, they were born out of a deep need to protect her special day from being overshadowed by family drama. Still, the aftermath left her wondering if her reaction was truly justified, particularly when key family members later demanded an apology.

‘AITA for telling my husband’s ex to keep her jelousy to herself?’

This is 100% a throwaway so if i dont reply, assume i lost access. I(30f) am newly married to my husband, Rick(30m). So ill try to explain the backstory/relationships but i suck at typing so sorry ahead of time. Rick was raised with Maddie(30f). My MIL(50f) and Maddie's mom were best friends since they were babies.

They dated back in highschool but it didnt work out. They did however remain close friends. I probably should note that Maddie ended up marrying my older BIL 5 years ago. So on to now. Rick and i have spent the last year wedding planning and doing the all of the traditional events that comes with that.

Its been an incredibly stressfull time but being my SIL, Maddie was at almost everything. Normally this wouldnt be a problem. I like Maddie... but it seemed like every passing day she would get angrier with me. This lead all the way up to our rehersal dinner when she started making comments

She acted like she didnt know what i was talking about. I told her ive had to listen to her little remarks at the rehersal for MY wedding and i was tired of it. She shut up but my BIL and MIL kept looking at me funny for the rest of the event.

When Rick and i got back from our honeymoon, 2 days ago, my MIL had a talk with me about how that was incredibly rude and that i owe Maddie and apology. Im starting to wonder if i was actually in the wrong here. Rick says i was justified but MIL and BIL are still upset with me over it AITA??

Wedding celebrations are meant to be joyful milestones, yet when underlying family tensions emerge, they quickly become arenas for unresolved personal conflicts. In this case, the bride’s frustration stems not merely from offhand jokes but from a sustained pattern of behavior that undermines the sanctity of a day meant for celebration. Emotions can flare in situations where old wounds resurface, making it essential to define clear boundaries before these events spiral out of control.

The core issue goes deeper than a single remark; it centers on how past relationships and resentments infiltrate present commitments. When family members interject with lingering jealousy or unresolved issues, they risk overshadowing the primary focus of the celebration. Clear communication is essential in these instances, as each party must acknowledge their emotional baggage and work collaboratively to maintain a respectful, drama-free environment.

According to relationship expert Dr. John Gottman, “Conflict is inevitable, but handling it with honesty and respect is key to maintaining strong relationships.” His research, as detailed on, emphasizes that addressing issues openly—rather than letting them fester—can prevent future resentment. In the context of a wedding, this means openly discussing personal boundaries before they turn into public confrontations. Clear pre-event mediation can be a valuable tool, ensuring that everyone is on the same page regarding acceptable behavior.

Ultimately, the decision to assert boundaries—even at the risk of upsetting established relationships—reflects a commitment to personal well-being and the integrity of the event. While an apology might seem like the smoother path, compromising one’s comfort and peace of mind is rarely worth it. Setting firm boundaries not only preserves the joy of the celebration but also lays the groundwork for healthier interactions in the future. By prioritizing respect and honest communication, the bride stands as a reminder that personal dignity should never be sacrificed for the sake of appeasing outdated dynamics.

Heres what people had to say to OP:

The Reddit community has been quick to voice their support and criticism alike, adding layers of humor and candor to the discussion. Many agree with the bride’s reaction, pointing out that her wedding should be free of unnecessary drama. These sentiments range from outright endorsement of her no-nonsense stance to playful jabs at those who believe family members should temper their own insecurities. Despite the mixed reactions, a common thread remains: personal boundaries matter, even in family settings.

Kami_Sang − NTA - tell your MIL that Maddie was the rude and disrespectful person. She made your rehersal dinner about her and Rick's past relationship making you uncomfortable. Yes, you reacted but you deserved not to have your husband's ex carrying on about their past relationship at your wedding events. Maybe Maddie thought it was cute or funny but to you it was insensitive and upsetting.

Your wedding was not about Maddie or Maddie and Rick's past. You are not apologising to Maddie and frankly, if it were me I would tell MIL I'm a grown ass woman, it's not her place to tell me to apologise as if I'm a child. I can judge my actions myself and I'm comfortable with them - sometimes you gotta be an A to make a point and stop other A like Maddie in their tracks.

Vyckerz − NTA - what Maddie did was way out of line. Your mother-in-law is also way off base in supporting Maddie in this.. Also, your brother-in-law is mad at the wrong person.. He should be upset with his wife for saying that his brother should’ve been with her instead!!

Chaos_incarnate_9 − Why was the BIL not mad his WIFE was joking around about ditching him for his brother???

beached_not_broken − Your BIL enjoyed hearing about how his wife wanted to be at the alter with his younger brother?. All Sounds super creepy. “Mil what do you think she was getting at when she said comments such as ….” “Do you believe that she was saying she wished she’d married A instead of B?” Sil had her wedding.

She doesn’t get to do a do over with each brother. She had her time and her choices. What you should have answered was “the reason you and an aren’t together is because you married his brother A- you know, your husband? But we can discuss you at the alter another time…”

Tell your MIL that if SIL needs to make every relationship milestone about her and YOUR husband, then perhaps a bit of distance is great while she remembers which brother she married…

AGirlCalledPearl − NTA.  I would sit down with your husband and talk about how Maddie made you feel. Let him know that she spoiled some thing that should’ve been a special moment and you’re not going to be dealing with her for the rest of your life.

This means that he needs to run interference with his parents and brother. This means he needs to have a conversation with them about when Maddie is allowed to interact with your life and what your boundaries are as a couple

Accomplished_Two1611 − When she made the stunning comment, I would have asked if she looked tragic at her wedding.

whiteprisonbitch − Where was your brother in all this? What has he have to say about what his wife did? Tell your MIL to f**k off.

Sadpepper2015 − NTA. Hubby needs to be the one dealing with MIL, not you. If he doesn't, mommy dearest will drive a wedge between the two of you.

Bluntandfiesty − NTA. She was disrespectful. You don’t owe her anything. She was purposely trying to hurt you and ruin your joy. My question is did MIL and BIL actually hear you call Maddie out and what you actually said, or did she relay it back to them? It’s important to know that they have accurate information and not some made up story that she manipulated.

You may have to have a conversation with them about what was said and everything she did prior. As far as your MIL and BIL goes, Is anyone there going to address the elephant in the room? Maddie is currently married to your husband’s older brother…and she is still making comments about how she should have been with Rick and questioned why she and Rick broke up.

Doesn’t her husband and your MIL find that at all concerning, disrespectful or offensive to her husband? Don’t they find that odd that she’s still pining after her husband’s younger brother? You’re not wrong. No apology needed from you. She owes you and Rick an apology.

Your husband should be disgusted and demanding an apology from his family for how they’re treating you and how Maddie was treating both of you. It was directed at him too and very awkward and uncomfortable for him as well.

LetsGetsThisPartyOn − NTA. But ew! She dated one brother. Married the other brother. Is now commenting that she should be married to the first brother while remaining married to the second brother.. Talk about All in the Family

In the end, this story underscores the delicate dance between maintaining familial harmony and asserting personal dignity. The bride’s firm response to Maddie’s unwelcome behavior poses an important question: should personal milestones be compromised to placate lingering jealousy from the past?

While some view the remarks as a necessary defense of one’s emotional space, others argue for a more conciliatory approach. What would you do if you found yourself caught between family expectations and your own need for respect? Share your thoughts and experiences—let’s discuss how best to navigate these tricky interpersonal dynamics.

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *