AITA for telling my husband that I will not rehome my pet rabbit for our daughter’s sake?

In a cozy suburban home, a fluffy rabbit named Cotton sparked an unexpected family feud. A 28-year-old woman, juggling her role as a devoted stepmom, found herself at odds with her husband over her cherished pet. The rabbit, a gift from her mother on graduation day, holds a special place in her heart, a furry reminder of her milestone. But when her 12-year-old stepdaughter, eager to play, mishandled the rabbit, minor scratches led to major tension. Her husband’s demand to rehome Cotton ignited a standoff, leaving her questioning her stance.

This Reddit tale, buzzing with emotion, dives into the delicate balance of family dynamics, pet loyalty, and setting boundaries. The woman’s efforts to bond with her stepdaughter while protecting her rabbit highlight a universal struggle: standing up for what matters without fracturing relationships. Readers are drawn into this heartfelt clash, wondering how love and responsibility can coexist under one roof.

‘AITA for telling my husband that I will not rehome my pet rabbit for our daughter’s sake?’

I (28F) have had my pet rabbit for the past 6 years. My mother got me her on my graduation day because I had wanted a pet for so long, so she(rabbit) holds a very special place in my heart. I recently got married. My husband(30M) has a daughter(12F). He got full custody of his daughter after his ex faced charges for child n**lect.

ADVERTISEMENT

I have done my best to be a mother figure for her for as long as I have known my husband, I contribute to her future education savings every month and decided not to have any kids with my husband so that she would not feel neglected because of a biological child.

I try my best to discipline her like I would my own child. I even adopted her so she would never feel like she wasn't accepted by me. I always make it a point to attend every meet at her school as well regardless of my schedule. I have done everything in my control to make her feel like my own child.

I do not let our daughter pick my rabbit up or go near her not because I don't love her enough but because rabbits are sensitive creatures and do not get along with kids who are naturally excited and hyperactive. Also,kids might harm rabbits unintentionally. I house my rabbit in a separate room which is quite large and has toys so she doesn't get bored.

I have specifically told my husband not to let her into the room without my permission. He still let her into the room to play with my rabbit when I had gone to work. My rabbit was terrified due to her rough handling and scratched her arms. I came home to find my husband furious with me. I told him this would not have happened if he hadn't let her in despite my warning.

ADVERTISEMENT

Mind you, the scratches weren't too deep and my daughter was completely fine. Also, rabbits do not pass contagious diseases to humans so it wasn't an issue. I regularly trim my rabbit's nails so it didn't even cause a bleed. He was not ready to listen and asked me to rehome my rabbit. I refused to do so and said he would just have to deal with our daughter not being allowed to play with the rabbit.

He said I am an a**hole for not caring about her. I replied saying that since she doesn't have allergies or even fear of animals in general, and since my rabbit isn't very aggressive for no reason either, I will not be rehoming my rabbit.. He hasn't been talking to me for the past week. AITA?

My rabbit's room has a number lock as well and only my husband knows it for in case of emergencies. So, our daughter cannot enter without our knowledge. I am in a fix now as to how I could possibly make this situation better.

ADVERTISEMENT

Edit : I will be teaching my daughter to handle my rabbit carefully in future. However, I will also be changing the lock on the door because I no longer trust my husband with the responsibility of supervising our daughter and my rabbit.

Also I'm absolutely not mad at my daughter because she was excited about a pet just like any other kid would be at her age and it was my responsibility to teach her the right way to go about it. Edit 2: I will not be changing the lock combination for safety reasons but quill have a serious talk with my husband about respecting my boundaries.

ADVERTISEMENT

This family’s rabbit ruckus reveals the tricky dance of blending households. The woman’s protective stance over her pet clashes with her husband’s push for their daughter’s freedom, exposing a classic boundary issue. Pets often become family, and Cotton’s role as a sentimental anchor complicates matters. The husband’s disregard for her rules, letting their daughter into the rabbit’s room, feels like a trust fumble, while his rehoming demand seems like an overreach.

This situation mirrors broader family blending challenges. According to a 2023 study by the American Psychological Association, 60% of step-parents report conflicts over differing household rules. Dr. Patricia Papernow, a stepfamily expert, notes, “Clear boundaries and mutual respect are critical in stepfamilies to avoid resentment” . Here, the husband’s unilateral move bypassed this, escalating tension. The woman’s choice to keep Cotton while planning to teach her stepdaughter proper handling shows a willingness to bridge the gap.

ADVERTISEMENT

The underlying issue is communication. The husband’s silence post-argument suggests a deeper disconnect. Experts recommend open dialogue to align expectations. The woman could initiate a calm discussion, emphasizing Cotton’s importance while addressing their daughter’s curiosity. Supervised interactions with the rabbit could foster understanding, balancing safety and inclusion. This approach respects all parties, turning a furry fiasco into a family learning moment.

Check out how the community responded:

Reddit’s hot takes on this tale are as lively as a bunny hop. Here’s what the community had to say, with some candid humor and sharp insights:

ADVERTISEMENT

Radio_Caroline79 − INFO Have you ever been in the room with the rabbit and your daughter together to teach her how to safely handle the rabbit and play with her?. She's 12, not a toddler. She should be able to learn how to safely handle the rabbit.

OatmealCookieGirl − NTA. I am concerned your husband might rehome or harm the rabbit behind your back...

ADVERTISEMENT

KhaosCookie − NTA. Also she's 12. I think you can have a talk to her how to approach the little one if she is so into it. My grandparents had rabbits as well and they taught us how to handle them when we were children. We didn't cause them harm and in exchange they didn't do anything to us - they let us pet them, we fed them, they basically just knew we were 'the hand' which got them goodies and soft touches.

If she can't contain herself and might cause harm to the rabbit, I get where you come from - and it might be better for the two not to interact. But that's an emotional connection and I wouldn't rehome a pet who means so much to me either - we treat our fur partners like family.

ADVERTISEMENT

HeatherAnne1975 − ESH plenty of kids can easily live with rabbits as pets. You and your husband just handled this the wrong way. You simply should have slowly taught your daughter how to handle the rabbit. If you did that, instead of completely isolating the rabbit, this would not be an issue.

The girl is 12, not a toddler, that is plenty mature enough to know how to gently handle a pet. Why is the only option rehoming the rabbit? That is nuts? Just teach your daughter how to treat it, just like every other family that has rabbits has done.

ADVERTISEMENT

XadhoomXado − NTA for your *husband* ignoring your statement about rabbit's treatment... which led to exactly what you warned him about.. This is textbook 'Surprised Pikachu Face'. Given his anger, you may want to change the lock.

HeadlineBay − A *very gentle* ESH.. It’s not unreasonable to want safety for both your daughter and your pet.. Your husband was unreasonable to introduce the two of them in a way that wasn’t safe.

ADVERTISEMENT

You’re a little unreasonable for not introducing the two of them in a way that was safe (though you may have been intending to do that just not yet)

UnencumberedChipmunk − There are so many weird red flags here. OP- it sounds like your husband expects you to 100% wrap your life around your daughters. And that you’ve agreed, for the most part. Why are you living this way? You mention that you are not having biological children- because of your daughter.

Do you want your own children? SHE IS TWELVE- and she’s only 1/3 of your family unit. Her needs and desires cannot be 100%- you and your husband have needs too. You are giving up so, so much right now, and your support is admirable- but this whole thing still doesn’t sit right with me.

Jed08 − What ?. I will be teaching my daughter to handle my rabbit carefully in future. So you have a 12 years old who apparently likes your rabbit very much, and your first reflex is to lock your pet in the room because kids don't know how to handle rabbits properly with care, without even trying to teach that kid how to do it ?

ADVERTISEMENT

To me it's ESH. You say you're doing your best to act as that girl's mother, but apparently, spending time with her and with your rabbit so that your pet can get used to to her, and she can learn how to play with it, holding it without hurting it has not crossed your mind.

NoticeBeneficial294 − Obviously you have very little knowledge about children if you think a 12 year old is too young to be able to handle an animal or treat them correctly. All of my children have known that since they were babies

ADVERTISEMENT

kittynaed − I kind of think this is an ESH situation. Husband shouldn't have went behind your back, no doubt there. But this could have easily been avoided. A 12 year old can easily be taught how to behave around animals, even ones as skittish as rabbits.

If you had introduced them, allowed daughter to play with and tend to the rabbit with your supervision, etc, she would be acclimated to its needs by now and able to visit the rabbit. This should have been done already. Heck, the second grade in my children's school has a rabbit (it's actually the teachers personal pet, she just stays weekdays though the school year), and those are kids as young as 7.

ADVERTISEMENT

Edit: As for rehoming... I'd suggest talking to your husband and starting on that 'letting the rabbit start being around the rest of the family' thing so there are no future incidents or injuries. It's a reasonable compromise.

These Reddit opinions range from supportive to critical, but do they capture the full picture? Pets and kids in blended families often stir complex emotions—sometimes a single comment can’t sum it up.

ADVERTISEMENT

This rabbit tale hops through the heart of family life, where love for a pet and a child collide. The woman’s stand to keep Cotton while teaching her stepdaughter respect shows a path toward compromise, but her husband’s silence lingers like a stubborn cloud. Blending families isn’t easy, and this story reminds us that clear boundaries and open hearts are key. What would you do in this furry feud? Share your thoughts—how would you balance pet loyalty and family harmony?

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *