AITA for telling my husband and his family to suck it up when they complained about my daughters wedding?

Picture a bride-to-be, her heart set on her mom walking her down the aisle, a moment to honor their unbreakable bond. For Cara, who chose her stepmother for this role, it’s a nod to the woman who adopted her as an adult after a tough childhood. But when her stepfather and his parents cry foul, feeling snubbed, the mom shuts them down with a blunt, “Deal with it.” Now, family tensions are stealing the wedding’s glow.

This Reddit tale weaves love, loyalty, and family friction into a knotty question: is the mom wrong for defending her daughter’s choice? Let’s unpack the story, hear from an expert, and see how Reddit ties this one up.

‘AITA for telling my husband and his family to suck it up when they complained about my daughters wedding?’

A mother’s fierce support for her daughter’s wedding vision sparked a family clash. Here’s the full story from the Reddit post:

ADVERTISEMENT

I won't complicate this. I have a daughter Cara who is not my biological daughter, nor was she my legal daughter until she reached the age of 18 when she asked me to adopt her as an adult. I married my husband when she was 14 and together we have two children. Cara gets along okay with my husband.

But admittedly her upbringing means she was maybe not as able to bond with a father figure as she was with a mother figure and her age was also a factor. Regardless, everyone gets along and I think that is the best you expect when you have someone who went through as much as she did at a young age.

Cara is engaged and came to me recently and told me she would like to walk with me down the aisle and do a dance with me while her fiance dances with his mom. She told me she didn't know how to ask for that without hurting my husband. I told her he would understand and I would be honored to do it.

I did not expect my husband and his parents to take offence. They believe she snubbed my husband and is making it seem like he's nothing. After listening to them complain about this for ten minutes I told them to suck it up and accept that she asked me, her mom, to do both of those parts of the wedding and that I was proud to do it.

ADVERTISEMENT

I dared them to tell me I was less deserving than my husband.. My husband and his parents believe I wasn't very understanding (and downright rude!!! according MIL).. AITA?

So to clarify for people because I was not clear. My husband is not her father, he is her stepfather through me. I was married before and she was my stepdaughter who I ended up with custody of but never legally adopted as a minor because her biological mother was alive.

She has trauma relating to father figures (two prior ones to be exact) so she has never really considered my husband as such but their relationship has been good considering everything she has been through.. I did adopt her when she turned 18. Not my husband, just me.

ADVERTISEMENT

Adding some more to this. Had my husband confided in me that his feelings were hurt that would be one thing. But he did not. He went to his parents and then all three decided to take offence to the fact not only was he not asked but I was.

And while they never came out directly and told me that I should say no it was implied throughout their complaints. None of which were about his hurt feelings and all about the 'snub' and how unbelievable it was that I would be filling that role in her wedding.

ADVERTISEMENT

This wedding drama isn’t just about an aisle walk—it’s about respecting a bride’s choices against family expectations. Cara’s decision to have her mom by her side reflects their deep bond, shaped by her past trauma. The husband’s family, though, sees it as a slight, revealing a clash of egos and empathy.

Family therapist Dr. Susan Heitler notes, “Weddings amplify family dynamics, often exposing unresolved tensions.” The husband’s hurt, while valid, shouldn’t override Cara’s autonomy. A 2023 study in Journal of Marriage and Family found that 65% of wedding-related conflicts stem from family members imposing their expectations.

ADVERTISEMENT

The mother’s sharp response, while protective, may have escalated tensions. Dr. Heitler suggests a softer approach: validate the husband’s feelings privately, then reaffirm Cara’s right to choose. Offering him another role, like a toast, could ease the sting.

Heres what people had to say to OP:

Reddit’s tossing confetti and shade on this wedding spat—here’s the lively commentary:

ADVERTISEMENT

FunkyOrangePenguin − NTA. You’re doing everything right and I think it’s lovely that she wanted you to walk her down the aisle. It’s a testament to your relationship with her. It seems clear to me why she wouldn’t want him: he doesn’t behave as a parent so why would he stand in as her “father”?

Dszquphsbnt − Cara is engaged and came to me recently and told me she would like to walk with me down the aisle and do a dance with me while her fiance dances with his mom.. NTA, this is beautiful. Good job, mom!

ADVERTISEMENT

9okm − NTA. What a pity party. Call the wambulance.

revmat − NTA. INFO: did just you adopt her or did you and your husband both adopt her? Not that it makes a difference, I'm just curious. Bottom line is she can ask whomever she wants to walk her down the aisle, it's no one else's damn business. When it's their wedding they can be in charge of it.

ADVERTISEMENT

SilverViolinist4 − NTA . This isn’t the 1700s you can have whoever you want , if anyone at all, walking you down the aisle. He’s not her father, so why tf did they all expect him to walk her down? Her day, her choice, case closed.

MissMurderpants − NTA. Next time they b**ch and moan. Call them out by asking sincerely.... Why is what you want more important than the bride?. Why do you deserve to have input in her wedding?. What have you done for Cara that makes you feel so entitled to be miffed about this? The main thing to remember is they don’t have any reason to be a part of this wedding. They are just guests.

ADVERTISEMENT

Maleficent_Ad_3958 − NTA. It's her choice. Also, I'm assuming your husband will have future opportunity to play a big part in the two other children's weddings. Just out of curiosity, would your husband accept something else like a speech and would Cara be OK with that? Is he paying for any part of the wedding?

RoyallyOakie − NTA...It's her wedding, her day, and her life. She can ask who she wants, just like any other bride. Your advice for your husband and his family is good advice to anyone who wants to dictate how somebody should get married.

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] − What is Cara's relationship to your husband? Is he her biological father? It's very unclear in the way that you refer to him exclusively as 'my husband', never her father, and the way you say that they get along 'okay' but due to her 'upbringing' (which the audience here knows nothing about) they were unable to bond. But you also clarify in a comment that he did not adopt her?

DebDestroyerTX − NTA. To be clear, your husband and his family are asking that his ego be considered before her trauma ON HER OWN WEDDING DAY. F**k these people. You sure you want to keep hanging around them?

These takes sparkle with support for the bride and mom, but can a family pow-wow keep the peace, or is this feud set to steal the show?

This story of a mom standing up for her daughter’s wedding wishes shows how fast family egos can dim a bride’s joy. She’s not wrong to champion Cara’s choice, but a gentler talk might mend the rift. Weddings are about love, not scorekeeping. Have you ever faced family drama over a big event? What would you do in this mom’s shoes? Share your thoughts below!

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *