AITA for telling my friend that we’re not throwing her a second bachelorette?

Lucy’s wedding was a dazzling affair, a whirlwind of love and celebration that left her bridesmaids breathless—and their wallets lighter. Picture a vibrant weekend filled with laughter, clinking glasses, and a bride glowing in her moment. But two years later, Lucy’s craving a sequel: a second bachelorette party to make up for the first one’s smaller turnout. Her friends, still dusting off financial setbacks, aren’t so keen.

The tension simmers in this cozy circle of friends, as Lucy’s dream of a lavish redo clashes with reality. With budgets tight and patience thinner, her bridesmaids face a dilemma: indulge her wishes or stand their ground? This tale of loyalty, entitlement, and tough love sets the stage for a juicy debate that’s got Reddit buzzing.

‘AITA for telling my friend that we’re not throwing her a second bachelorette?’

Lucy’s push for a second bachelorette party feels like a bride’s dream stuck on repeat, but it’s stirring up real tension among friends. The core issue? Her expectation that others fund her fantasy redo, despite their financial struggles, screams entitlement. Lucy’s likely chasing the “perfect” memory, but her friends, drained from the first round, see it as a step too far. Meanwhile, the maid of honor’s support risks enabling this overreach, creating a rift in the group.

This situation reflects a broader issue: the pressure of wedding culture. According to a 2023 study by The Knot, bridesmaids spend an average of $1,900 on wedding-related expenses, from dresses to travel. When brides demand more—like Lucy’s redo—it can strain friendships, especially post-pandemic when many are financially recovering. The expectation of lavish celebrations often overshadows mutual respect.

Dr. Irene S. Levine, a psychologist and friendship expert, notes, “Friendships thrive on reciprocity, not one-sided demands” (source: Psychology Today, 2019). Lucy’s insistence ignores her friends’ sacrifices, framing their efforts as inadequate. Her focus on a “proper” bachelorette dismisses the love shown at her wedding, risking alienation.

For solutions, open communication is key. Lucy’s friends could propose a budget-friendly gathering, like a local girls’ night, to honor the bond without breaking the bank. Lucy should also reflect on her priorities—friendship over Instagram-worthy moments. Setting boundaries, as the OP did, is healthy, but delivering it with empathy could soften the blow and preserve the connection.

Here’s the feedback from the Reddit community:

Reddit didn’t hold back on this one, serving up a spicy mix of shade and wisdom. Here’s what the community had to say about Lucy’s bachelorette redo drama:

These hot takes are classic Reddit—blunt, witty, and maybe a touch dramatic. But do they nail the heart of the issue, or are they just fanning the flames?

Lucy’s story is a reminder that friendships, like weddings, need balance to sparkle. Her bridesmaids showed up big for her big day, but her push for a bachelorette encore feels like a party no one RSVP’d for. It’s a tale of loyalty tested by entitlement, leaving us wondering where to draw the line. What would you do if a friend asked for a lavish redo you couldn’t afford? Share your thoughts—let’s keep this convo as lively as a wedding dance floor!