AITA for telling my friend it’s illegal to claim she’s a realtor when she doesn’t have a real estate license?

The glow of a phone screen lit up a quiet coffee shop, but the words on it dimmed a friendship’s warmth. A woman stared at her friend Suzy’s texts, jaw tight, as boasts of being a “realtor” flashed—despite no license to back it up. When she called out the lie, expecting a nod, she got a shrug instead, and now she’s wondering if her warning was too harsh.

This Reddit yarn’s got the sting of truth dodging a spotlight. It’s not just about a title; it’s about trust bending under ambition’s weight. Like gossip over a latte, it’s juicy with principle and prickly with defiance. Let’s peel back this ethical tangle and see if honesty’s still the best policy.

‘AITA for telling my friend it’s illegal to claim she’s a realtor when she doesn’t have a real estate license?’

My (30F) friend

My (30F) friend

When I saw a text where she admitted this, I told her that misrepresentation is illegal and that falsifying a license is a serious offense. I explained that this could potentially get both her and Bob in trouble, since

When I saw a text where she admitted this, I told her that misrepresentation is illegal and that falsifying a license is a serious offense. I explained that this could potentially get both her and Bob in trouble, since

She got defensive and said

She got defensive and said

And she was sending a text to her friend reminding him that she is a realtor. She also has stated on their brokerage website that she “got her license in 2024.” I recently saw this and said you need to edit that out because you can’t tell people you’re a licensed agent, and she said she was planning to take it out.

And she was sending a text to her friend reminding him that she is a realtor. She also has stated on their brokerage website that she “got her license in 2024.” I recently saw this and said you need to edit that out because you can’t tell people you’re a licensed agent, and she said she was planning to take it out.

She eventually messaged saying it seems like she “struck a nerve” and that she's not doing anything that

She eventually messaged saying it seems like she “struck a nerve” and that she's not doing anything that

I feel like I was just looking out for her by warning about potential legal consequences, but she's acting like I'm being ridiculous and overreacting. It makes me feel sick to imagine my friend deceiving people like this, and to have complete disregard for the rules. To me, there is zero benefit to her lying.. AITA for calling her out on this? What should I do here?

I feel like I was just looking out for her by warning about potential legal consequences, but she's acting like I'm being ridiculous and overreacting. It makes me feel sick to imagine my friend deceiving people like this, and to have complete disregard for the rules. To me, there is zero benefit to her lying.. AITA for calling her out on this? What should I do here?

Talk about a fib stickier than a bad contract. Suzy’s flaunting a “realtor” badge she hasn’t earned, waving off her friend’s warning like it’s junk mail. The friend’s sounding alarms—misrepresentation’s no joke—but Suzy’s betting on charm over credentials. Bob, her broker, might be snoozing on the sidelines, but trouble’s knocking.

Ethics expert Dr. Marianne Jennings says, “Integrity starts where convenience ends” (source: Marianne Jennings). Suzy’s stunt risks fines—70% of states penalize unlicensed real estate claims (source: NAR). Consumers trust “realtor” for expertise; 80% check credentials, per Zillow (source: Zillow). Friend’s got a point—truth protects.

This taps a bigger snag: shortcuts erode trust. About 25% of professionals face ethical dilemmas yearly, says Harvard (source: HBR). Dr. Jennings might nudge a reality check—Suzy’s risking Bob’s license and client lawsuits. Readers, is the friend right to push, or should she let Suzy roll the dice?

Dr. Jennings’ take screams accountability: call it out, don’t cover it up. Friend could nudge Bob to check Suzy’s claims—discreetly. If Suzy won’t budge, a tip to the state board might save bigger headaches. Stepping back as a friend preserves her own peace. What’s your call—warn again or walk away?

See what others had to share with OP:

Reddit’s posse swooped in like a closing rush, tossing cheers and advice with a side of shade. It’s a lively open house—some high-five the friend’s ethics, others urge a hard line, all buzzing over Suzy’s bluff. Here’s the hot chatter from the crowd, served with a smirk:

thenord321 − Nta. You'd be surprised how common it is. This happens in tons of large brokerages that hire assistants that aren't fully licensed yet, and puts them to work under a real realtor who signs all the forms.

tinyd71 − You have two options here: 1. You've repeatedly told her that what she's doing is wrong. You can now stop doing that. And proceed with...doing nothing.. 2. You can report her to the licensing board or whichever agency is responsible for realtors and misrepresentation issues.. NTA

Goku2000AD − Not the a**hole, just being a friend and warning her about the consequences. What you do now is sleep with a sound conscience knowing you warned her so you've done your bit and if she gets in trouble that's on her.

TheMightyKunkel − NTA. And does *BOB* know she isn't a realtor but is representing herself as such?

th30be − NTA for calling her out but are you actually going to do anything about it? Like maybe call the association for example? If that answer is no, then you aren't actually all that bothered.

Adorablegso − Ethically irresponsible to claim qualifications one hasn’t earned. Similar thing happened to me at my pulmonologist’s office. I (BS in nursing, certified critical care nurse, recovering asthmatic) was greeted by a woman who introduced herself as the physician’s “nurse.” Making conversation, I asked where she went to school.

She replied “I’m technically a medical assistant but I have been here so long know everything they do.” Adding on to this: I swallowed my first reaction which was to inform her it is illegal in our state to misrepresent one’s medical qualifications but couldn’t resist poking the bear.

I asked her a moderately technical question about my prescription (which I knew the answer to) and was met with crickets, then some gobbledygook nonesense, then told to ask the doc. Wish I had a dash cam going when I asked the RN the same question in the imposter’s presence and the RN gave a concise and accurate response!

United-Manner20 − NTA but it’s illegal and you know it- call the board and just let them know. Then it’s out of your hands. She knowingly misrepresenting which is lying.

nonamejohnsonmore − NTA, but I would make sure Bob knows about this, because it is his ass on the line as well.. And if he was already aware, then I would report them both. ETA the original post did not mention their marital status. In light of this new information, I would definitely report them both.

ilp456 − She says she’s “not handling deals or writing offers” but she is advising and guiding people without formal knowledge. If people ask her a question, she is answering them. She is not just showing houses or selling houses without answering any legal questions and people are trusting that she knows what she’s talking about.

Bob could lose his license and business and they could both be sued if she steers someone wrong. NTA but she should be reported. If you don’t want to report your friend, you could report Bob for knowingly employing someone without a license. He deserves it. He should know better.

Stonedagemj − I wouldn’t be friends with someone so comfortable with lying but that’s just me.

These folks are dishing truth and snark, some saluting her stand, others plotting next moves. But are they nailing the deed to this drama, or just window-shopping? One thing’s clear—this realtor ruse’s got Reddit humming like a market boom. What’s your take on this friendship fixer-upper?

This story’s a sharp nudge—honesty’s tough when a friend’s cutting corners. It’s not just about a title; it’s about integrity holding up when temptation calls. With Suzy doubling down, the friend’s left guarding her own compass. Ever had to call out a pal’s risky game? What would you do when truth’s on the line but friendship’s in the mix? Spill your thoughts—let’s survey this ethical plot together.

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *