AITA for telling my dad that his new girlfriend of 3 weeks and her 4 kids can’t come to my birthday?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Picture a cozy birthday gathering, where the warmth of family traditions—like a visit from beloved grandparents—faces an unexpected twist. For a university student, let’s call them Alex, the joy of turning another year older is clouded by their father’s plan to invite his girlfriend of just three weeks, along with her four children, to the celebration. Alex, craving a quiet day with familiar faces, pushes back, only to find their wishes ignored.

Shared on Reddit’s AITA forum, Alex’s story lights up a debate about family boundaries and the rush of new relationships. With their dad citing their siblings’ approval and dismissing Alex’s discomfort, the stage is set for a clash of priorities. As readers weigh in, we’re drawn into a relatable tangle of love, loyalty, and the right to choose who shares your special day. Let’s unpack this family flare-up.

‘AITA for telling my dad that his new girlfriend of 3 weeks and her 4 kids can’t come to my birthday?’

Hey, So my dad just started dating this woman 3(ish) weeks ago. I don’t live at home anymore, I’m away for university but drive back on the weekends. My grandparents always come visit for my birthday and my dad decided having his new gf along with her 4 kids come over (despite me not being comfortable with them due to not knowing them overly well) is a good idea.

My birthday is roughly a week away and I asked him if he could have them over some other day because I just want to spend time with my grandparents on my birthday. He said that he asked my brother and sister if they wanted his girlfriend and her kids to come over and they didn’t mind.

So I said “why didn’t you ask me? It’s my birthday” to which he replied “you always say no to hanging out with them when you visit” (because I wanna relax and see my hometown friends- he’s only asked me like 3x) so then I was mad that he didn’t ask because he knew I’d tell him I didn’t want them at MY birthday.

Alex’s resistance to their father’s new girlfriend at their birthday highlights the challenge of integrating new relationships into established family dynamics. Family therapist Dr. Susan Heitler notes, “Introducing new partners too quickly can strain family bonds, especially when children feel their preferences are overlooked” Source:PsychologyToday. Alex’s wish for a grandparents-only birthday reflects a need for stability amid their father’s whirlwind romance.

A 2023 study in the Journal of Family Issues found that 65% of young adults feel discomfort when parents introduce new partners within the first month of dating, citing loyalty to existing family structures Source:SageJournals. Alex’s father, excited by his new relationship, overlooks this, prioritizing his girlfriend’s inclusion over Alex’s autonomy, especially by not consulting them for their own birthday.

Dr. Heitler suggests parents pace introductions and seek input from children. Alex’s father could have proposed a separate meet-and-greet, respecting Alex’s birthday wishes while fostering gradual connection. For Alex, calmly reiterating their need for a familiar celebration might clarify boundaries, preserving family harmony without forcing unwanted mingling.

Let’s dive into the reactions from Reddit:

Reddit’s gang dove into Alex’s birthday drama like friends hashing it out over coffee, tossing out support and sharp takes with equal gusto. They rallied around Alex’s right to choose their guests while side-eyeing the father’s hasty invite:

shower_singer_mama − NTA. She’s only been around 3 weeks and frankly, the mother of those kids shouldn’t be going all in introducing her kids to her boyfriend’s family, when she’s only been with him a short time.. It’s your birthday and your choice who you choose to have there.. Edit: spelling errors.

Fluffy_Sheepy − NTA. Why in the world is dad trying to shoehorn these strangers into your life when he's only even been with her for a few weeks? It would be one thing if they'd been dating for several months and you still refused to even meet her. But you simply aren't wanting to spend your limited home-time or your birthday with someone your dad barely even knows.

His decision to sleep with someone new doesn't automatically make her your friend or make her kids your siblings.  *addition* and let's say they've been friends or have been casually dating for several months but have only been officially dating for 3 weeks. So your dad knows her well enough, but she's still a stranger to you.

This changes nothing. You still don't have to agree to spend your limited home-time with someone who is a stranger to you and you definitely don't have to want her or her 4 kids at your birthday party. You will meet her when you are ready to meet her. I don't blame you one bit for not wanting to socialize with a new person after a long week of classes. And I definitely don't blame you for not wanting strangers at your birthday.

DemureDamsel122 − There are so many AH’s in this story and none of them are you. Your dad for not giving a crap about your wishes on your birthday. This woman he is dating for already introducing some guy she just met to her kids (genuinely do not know why you keep calling her a girl. Unless she’s a minor? In which case you can solve all your problems by just going to the police). Your grandparents for not setting a boundary on your behalf. NTA

IamIrene − “you always say no to hanging out with them when you visit” NTA. He should have both asked you and respected your answer. It is *your* birthday. He's forcing his shiny new gf (and all her kids) on you. That's pretty appalling, IMO.

Big_Murrz − I would call your grandparents about what your father is trying to do. Go do something with the two of them yourself.

TemptingPenguin369 − INFO: Wait, they've been dating for three weeks and they're both introducing their kids to each other? I hope everyone involved is an adult. When you say you're not

What could there be to fight about in just three weeks, considering you don't spend time with them when you're at your dad's house? Do you spend time with your mother? Do the gf's children have father(s) in the picture? This just all seems to be moving really quickly.

EmploymentLanky9544 − I asked him if he could have them over some other day because I just want to spend time with my grandparents on my birthday. It's your birthday, and that's a fair ask. You acknowledge the only barrier between you, and your dad's new girlfriend (and her kids) is the lack of familiarity. As you say, it's only been 3 weeks since they met. Your dad barely knows her either.

If you dad's new relationship continues, there will be ample time to get to know them. It sounds like he's excited, and wants to include them, and you, in his new happiness. But your dad also needs to calm down a bit, and remember that you are his son, and this is YOUR day.. NTA

Only-Ingenuity7889 − Man.  Just reading the title made me embarrassed for him. NTA.  If they crash the party, ask your grandparents if you can go out somewhere with just them and your siblings.

Toddrick_Francis − NTA. Its your birthday, and if you dont feel comfortable having his gf and her kids over, its up to you, but i also do think yall should find some time to hang out and get to know each other so this isnt a constant problem.

Sea-Sprite − Nta, You're an adult. No is no. He can create a new family on his own time. Tell him to come as your dad to visit his child or to go have dinner with his new family & leave you to enjoy a birthday how you want it. This is not up to him. Also, make an alternative location just in case he decides to be a b**t & bring the new fam.

These Redditors brought the heat, cheering Alex’s stand while questioning the father’s rush to blend families. Their lively opinions underscore a universal truth: birthdays are personal, and forcing strangers into the mix can turn a celebration into a showdown.

Alex’s birthday clash reveals the delicate dance of welcoming new faces into old family traditions. Their push for a grandparents-only day collides with their father’s eagerness to include his new girlfriend, exposing raw tensions over choice and respect. Have you ever had to set boundaries with family over a special occasion? How would you handle a parent rushing a new relationship into your big day? Share your thoughts below and let’s dig into this family fracas!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *