AITA for telling my cousin to leave after she saw my plastic straw stockpile and accused me of “destroying the environment”?

Jonathan Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In a quiet suburban kitchen, a young woman sips her drink through a plastic straw, her hands trembling slightly from a neuromuscular condition that makes every sip a small victory. For her, these straws aren’t just convenience—they’re a lifeline. But when her eco-warrior cousin stumbles upon a cupboard stuffed with plastic straws, a heated clash erupts, leaving family ties strained and feelings raw.

This Reddit tale dives into the messy intersection of disability needs and environmental passion, where good intentions collide with lived realities. Readers are left wondering: was she wrong to send her cousin packing, or was this a stand for her own survival? The story pulls us into a world where personal necessity meets societal ideals, sparking a debate that’s as heartfelt as it is thorny.

‘AITA for telling my cousin to leave after she saw my plastic straw stockpile and accused me of “destroying the environment”?’

The original Reddit post lays bare a deeply personal struggle wrapped in a family spat. Here’s the story in the poster’s own words:

I (20f) have neuromuscular disabilities. I cannot drink things without a straw/lid. I need a lid so I don't spill, a straw because I cannot lift drinks to my mouth and have difficulty getting liquid to the back of my mouth to swallow. Straws alleviate this problem.

Plastic straws are necessary because biodegradable/paper ones break apart easily, silicone is not flexible enough, metal straws get hot/cold too easily and are inflexible - which hurts my mouth and makes it impossible to swallow. My city is currently laying out plans to ban plastic straws, and it has already been implemented in some areas.

I am currently stockpiling. My cousin came around to drop something off a few days ago, and found my stockpile when she opened a cupboard. She immediately goes on about how 'plastic straws are convenient, but you're destroying the environment', 'Just get reusable straws' etc. She's super passionate about the environment, if you can't tell.

I tell her to leave, and she drove off really upset. My mum comes home later, and I tell her what happened. Mum is upset that I told her to leave, because my aunt apparently got angry at my mum for me being rude, and that I probably should have explained to her why I need straws instead.

That the majority of people who support straw bans don't realise that single use straws are usually the only way that people with certain disabilities can get hydration safely. I needed to educate her, according to mum.
This clash over plastic straws isn’t just a family argument—it’s a microcosm of a broader tension between environmental activism and disability rights. The young woman’s need for plastic straws highlights a critical oversight in well-meaning environmental policies.

ADVERTISEMENT

Dr. Alice Wong, a prominent disability rights advocate, notes in a 2018 Teen Vogue article, “The straw ban is a perfect example of how policies can unintentionally harm disabled people when their voices aren’t included” (Source). Wong’s point underscores the woman’s dilemma: plastic straws are uniquely suited to her needs, unlike alternatives that disintegrate or cause discomfort. Her cousin’s outburst, though rooted in environmental concern, ignores this reality, reflecting a broader societal blind spot.

The environmental impact of straws is often overstated. A 2019 study from the Ocean Conservancy found that straws make up less than 1% of ocean plastic, with fishing gear dominating at over 70% (Source). This suggests the cousin’s focus might be misplaced, prioritizing symbolic gestures over systemic issues.

ADVERTISEMENT

For the woman, explaining her disability in the heat of the moment may feel like an unfair burden. Yet, a brief explanation could bridge the gap, turning confrontation into understanding. Experts suggest open dialogue: “Share your needs calmly, but firmly,” advises disability educator Mia Mingus. This approach could help the cousin see beyond her eco-zeal to the human stakes involved.

These are the responses from Reddit users:

Reddit’s hive mind didn’t hold back, dishing out opinions with the spice of a family reunion gone wrong. Here are some of the top takes:

ADVERTISEMENT

JustheBean − NTA the ableism in the “green movement” is maddening and their initiatives are often performative. The straw situation for example: performative. They make up a tiny percentage of plastic pollution and are an important accessibility measure.

If the movement wants to impact plastic in the ocean they should be a thorn in the side of corporate fishing (contribute upwards of 70% of plastic in the ocean) not disabled people.. Edit: because I’m being misinterpreted. I never said the cousin is ableist, I said the movement is.

Edit 2: the 70% refers specifically to plastics on the ocean floor, particularly ridges. It is also accurate with regards to macroplastics. My apologies for stating it as a generalization, I had no idea this post would blow up.

[Reddit User] − NTA. Being disabled is generally not environmentally-friendly, and healthy people who have a choice about what products they prefer to use really need to realize that it's not a choice for everyone. Although straw bans are well-intended, any law or ordinance that doesn't take people with disabilities into account is incredibly flawed.

ADVERTISEMENT

kmoore − ESH, but a soft one towards you. Straw bans are stupid, bad for many people with disabilities and as far as I can tell practically meaningless from an environmental standpoint (and imo saps energy from actually effective policies).

If this was some stranger coming up to you at a restaurant and giving you s**t, telling them to just go away is right. But in this case, where you’re interacting with a family member you presumably see somewhat often, I think you should give a brief explanation before kicking them out.

A “I have a health condition that is best dealt with plastic straws” I think is a way to show that you hear your cousin’s concerns. But there are specific important reasons for you to do this (which you did take the time to explain to internet strangers, since it does make you look much better).

ADVERTISEMENT

If she keeps badgering you about it or is digging into exactly how bad your health condition is, then yeah, ask her to leave. You’re not obligated to do so in some deep sense, and the general AITA consensus is that it ends there.

But I think giving a simple explanation for your behavior first before upping the drama is something we should strive to do with people we care about, even the annoyingly zealous environmentalists in our life. If they still insist on ignoring your reasons, then yeah, kick them out.. I could be misreading and if you did say something along these lines, I’d revise it to NTA.

Timely_Froyo1384 − NTA. Ask her if she walks everywhere? If not then thank you for your input!

ADVERTISEMENT

ifsnakescouldspeak − INFO: Does your cousin know why you need the straws?

aubaub − Slight YTA here. Why didn’t you explain it? Don’t you think the whole thing could have been avoided if your cousin knew why you were upset? You know she’s “super passionate about the environment” , why didn’t you take this opportunity to inform her that some people need the things she is passionate against?

pntlesdevilsadvocate − ESH. Your cousin is not a random person standing on a soap box. Your cousin presumably knows about your condition, but has somehow never made a connection to how your situation is different. Dont treat your family like they aren't worth the time of an explanation.

ADVERTISEMENT

You dont need to explain yourself to everyone you meet, but it is the duty of close family to correct any lapse of understanding. The brunt of most misunderstandings in society will always fall most heavily on those affected by it.

You may be tired of explaining this to people, had a bad day, or just dont like your opinionated cousin, but you are the first line of defense against this opinion gaining traction. Hopefully there will always be someone else who will explain how someone is being dumb, but I think it is important for someone who is affected by a situation to be willing and able to instruct those closest to them.

ageender92 − NTA. Environmental activism is unfortunately not taking into account disabled voices, as is unfortunately a common problem with most forms of activism that isn't centered on disabled folks. Your cousin is parroting a lot of what they consume around this and thinks they have the high ground here while completely ignoring your disability and needs.

ADVERTISEMENT

I know it's frustrating to have to argue your right to exist and exist well, OP. I hope at least if you do decide to and have the energy to explain your situation to your cousin that they listen to what you have to say and incorporate your experience into their activism in a favorable way.

christy95 − I dont know why people are voting NTA unless your cousin knows why you need those specific straws. I'll go with NAH. I woild probably comment the same as your cousin even though I'm not super passionate about the environment as you claim your cousin to be, and then again it is understandable that you will get upset over this.

Dszquphsbnt − She's straw manning you. NTA.

ADVERTISEMENT

These Reddit hot takes range from fiery support to gentle nudges for more communication. But do they capture the full weight of balancing personal needs with family dynamics?

This story leaves us at a crossroads: one woman’s fight for accessibility versus another’s crusade for the planet. It’s a reminder that good intentions don’t always align with everyone’s reality. The woman’s sharp reaction was human, but could a quick explanation have cooled the tempers? What would you do if you were caught between defending your needs and keeping the peace? Share your thoughts—have you ever faced a similar clash where your necessities were misunderstood?

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *