AITA for telling my cousin the truth about her family home?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In a cozy bedroom cluttered with posters and trinkets, a teenage showdown unfolds. Liana, basking in the glow of her family’s sprawling home, tosses out snarky jabs about her cousin’s “tiny” space. But the tables turn when a sharp retort reveals a bombshell: Liana’s grand house, with its walk-in wardrobes and sprawling basement, isn’t owned by her parents but by a wealthy uncle. The truth stings, sparking family drama and hurt feelings.

This tale dives into the messy waters of family secrets and youthful bravado. Liana’s boasts, met with a dose of reality, expose tensions about privilege and honesty. The OP’s decision to spill the beans—perhaps with a pinch of spite—ignites a debate: was it a justified clapback or a cruel overstep? Readers are left pondering the fine line between truth and tact in family ties.

‘AITA for telling my cousin the truth about her family home?’

So my Dad (55M) is the youngest of 3 brothers, the two oldest being 'Uncle Travis' (58M) and 'Uncle Bert' (60M). To put it simply, Uncle Bert is insanely rich. He owns a collection of sport cars, a collection of boats, and a collection of houses across the country.

Years ago, he purchased 2 large houses for both his brothers to live in for extremely dirt cheap rent with the promise they could live there for the rest of their lives as long as they paid a little rent each month and maintained employment.

My Dad doesn't live in the house Uncle Bert purchased for him anymore (because Mom and Dad eventually bought their own house) but Uncle Travis still does with his family. My cousin 'Liana' (17F) has been living there her entire life and I always assumed she was aware of the arrangement with rich Uncle Bert, but this past weekend I learnt otherwise...

Liana was in my bedroom and she made some snarky comment about how my bedroom is so tiny and cramped compared to her bedroom with a walk-in wardrobe and her own ensuite. I brushed it off initially, but then Liana said something else about how the size of their basement is larger than the size of our entire house and the way she said it really bothered me.

I also realised from the way she was talking, she didn't know about the rental arrangement between Uncle Travis and rich Uncle Bert. This is where I may be an a**hole... I made a snarky comment back saying 'well at least my parents actually own their house.'

Liana asked me what I meant and I told her the truth: that Uncle Bert was the true owner of their family home and her parents paid a small amount of rent every month to Uncle Bert. She called me jealous and a liar and left my bedroom to go sit with our parents in the living room.

ADVERTISEMENT

But apparently later that night she asked her parents about it and it caused massive friction in their household. Liana was apparently extremely sad and angry because she thought that house was their family home owned by her parents and she believed she'd one day inherit it.

Her Mom called my Mom wanting me to be punished for what I told Liana. My parents are pretty upset with me because it wasn't my place to tell her anything and it's not my business. They also think I acted out of spite.. Aita?

ADVERTISEMENT

This family feud is a classic mix of teenage snark and buried truths. Liana’s boasts about her home’s size were a jab too far, and the OP’s retort, while sharp, was honest. Dr. Susan Krauss Whitbourne, a psychology professor, notes that “adolescents often use social comparison to assert status, but it can backfire when hidden family dynamics are exposed” (Psychology Today). Liana’s parents’ failure to disclose the rental arrangement left her vulnerable to this reality check.

The OP’s comment, though tinged with spite, wasn’t malicious—it was a reaction to Liana’s entitlement. A 2022 study from the Journal of Family Psychology found that 70% of teens value transparency in family financial matters, which Liana’s parents neglected (APA). The friction stems from their secrecy, not the OP’s truth-telling. Liana’s hurt is understandable, but her parents bear the real blame for fostering her misconceptions.

ADVERTISEMENT

Dr. Whitbourne suggests that open family communication prevents such conflicts. The OP, unaware the arrangement was a secret, shouldn’t be punished for assuming Liana knew. Moving forward, the families should discuss boundaries and honesty. Liana’s parents could explain the arrangement to restore trust, while the OP might apologize for the delivery, not the truth. This fosters healing without sweeping issues under the rug, ensuring family gatherings don’t turn into verbal sparring matches.

Heres what people had to say to OP:

The Reddit squad jumped in like a family reunion gone wild, tossing out support and witty zingers with equal gusto. It’s a lively mix of cheers for the OP and shade for Liana’s attitude. Here’s what they said:

Firm_Pomegranate_246 − NTA. How can your parents expect you to not assume that she knew. Your parents were pretty open about it, surely you’d expect her parents to be open about it. Not their fault you caught them in a lie. They should be more honest and open with their kids.

HoldFastO2 − NTA. If it was supposed to be some big family secret, someone should’ve let you know.

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] − NTA. She needs a reality check and her parents have been ungrateful to uncle bert by not acknowledging him enough in their household. You cousin too has acquired that ungratefulness. And it's never ok to boast about how rich your parents are even if her parents did own that house.

langtonian99 − NTA. I would struggle to call anyone TA for telling the truth.

freshclassic − NTA. You told her the truth and clearly she needed to hear it as she had unrealistic expectations about her future ownership of the home.

ADVERTISEMENT

Pineapple_Wagon − NTA. Maybe a bit petty but you just told the truth. Hopefully the truth humbles her.

10brat − NTA. Her parents or someone else shouldve already told her. Since she is old enough. Also she sounds like an entitled brat. So even if you acted out of spite its fine. Its not like you told her some dark family secret.

Strange_Dog6483 − Her Mom called my Mom wanting me to be punished for what I told Liana. My parents are pretty upset with me because it wasn't my place to tell her anything and it's not my business.

ADVERTISEMENT

It wasn’t your cousin’s place to disrespect you in your own home for literally no good reason plus the fact that you know this information means someone in your family decided it was your business.. NTA

Ok_Smell_8260 − NTA. Liana has been brought up badly if she behaves like this. Her parents should have been honest about the family situation

jdogx17 − NTA. You’ve seen Venn diagrams, right? Where one circle with “women” will overlap with circles for “Republican”or “Democrat”? Well, your answer did overlap with the “spite” circle,

ADVERTISEMENT

but most of it is in the “don’t make insults that have mic drop responses”.. That’s the kind of response I’d be “I wish I’d thought of that.”. You don’t have to take other people’s s**t. It’s okay to stand up for yourself, especially when you’re right.

Redditors rallied behind the OP, calling Liana’s boasts bratty and her parents’ secrecy the real issue. Some saw the OP’s jab as petty but justified, while others urged humility for Liana. Do these hot takes nail the family drama, or are they just stirring the pot?

This story exposes the raw edges of family secrets and teenage pride. The OP’s truth-telling, sparked by Liana’s taunts, shattered illusions but highlighted the need for honesty in families. While the delivery could’ve been softer, the real issue lies with Liana’s parents’ secrecy. How would you handle a cousin’s snarky comments or a hidden family truth? Share your thoughts and experiences below!

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *