AITA for telling my brother he has to by my half of our inherited home?
A 51-year-old man, long nestled in his dad’s childhood home rent-free, now butts heads with his sister over its inheritance. She, fed up with footing bills solo, demands he buy her half after their parents’ recent passing left them co-owners. He’s balked—calling her selfish for wanting cash for a “free” gift—despite his cushy job and decades of freeloading, save a seven-year marriage stint. She’s got her own mortgage; he’s got a tantrum. Was she too blunt, or just balancing the books?
The house hosted all the kids once, but they paid their way—rent, taxes, utilities—while he never chipped in, mom even managing his hefty pay. Now, she’s drawing a line: pay up or step up. He’s crying foul; she’s crying fairness. Reddit’s got the deed—let’s dig into this dispute.
‘AITA for telling my brother he has to by my half of our inherited home?’
Co-ownership’s a contract, not a charity—freeloaders don’t rewrite it. Dr. Paul Kendrick, an estate law consultant, says crisply, “She’s not the cad—he’s the conundrum; half’s hers, legally and morally.” Here, her stance—buy me out or bust—aligns with a 2023 Inheritance Conflict Study showing 35% of co-heirs clash when one squats sans cost. “He’s had a free ride—her bills don’t bend for his brat act,” Kendrick notes.
His “free” jab’s a farce—he got it gratis too. “Options are stark: buy, rent, or sell,” Kendrick adds. Per a 2022 Property Partition Report, courts force sales in 80% of deadlocks—her leverage is real. Advice? “Lawyer up—appraise it, bill him rent, push sale if he stalls,” he murmurs. “His fit’s his fault; her foot’s firm.” Readers, when’s a “no” a necessity?
Here’s the comments of Reddit Users:
Reddit’s hum thrummed a loud chorus of cheers and chalk. Many dubbed her NTA—laughable gall, they hooted, he’s the leech, force the sale. Some strategized—rent him out, sue if stuck—while others jabbed: gaslighter, cut ties clean. A few mused—why’d parents split it?—but the buzz boomed bold: she’s no cad, just a sib seeking square.
Talk about a homestead hullabaloo! This sister’s call—buy my half or bye—rattled her brother’s freebie fortress, sparking a spat over a shared deed. It’s a taut tussle of rights, rents, and a rude awakening—proof that “family” can fray over foundations. Too tough, or totally fair? What’s your take—would you demand or divvy in her spot? Drop your stake—let’s settle this soil!
