AITA for telling another parent her childcare concerns are not my problem?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Imagine a friendship forged in kindergarten, full of sleepovers and secrets, suddenly shattered by middle-school drama. That’s the heartache one mom faced when her 12-year-old daughter cut ties with her best friend, Jess, after Jess joined a clique that bullied her. When Jess’s mom, Catherine, begged for help to mend the bond—partly to secure free childcare—this parent drew a line in the sand. With one blunt sentence, she sparked a firestorm.

Was she cold-hearted or just protecting her daughter’s heart? This tale of loyalty, betrayal, and parenting priorities pulls us into a suburban showdown where emotions run high and boundaries are tested. Let’s dive into this messy saga and see who’s really in the right.

 

‘AITA for telling another parent her childcare concerns are not my problem?’

I have a 12 year old daughter. She had a best friend, let's call her Jess. Jess has a single mom, let's call her Catherine. Ever since kindergarten Jess and my daughter have been the best of friends. They did everything together, spent most of their free time together and were there for each other through a lot.

Then over the summer Jess became friends with these girls who don't like my daughter, who have bullied her, and my daughter found out about it when she returned to school after lockdown this September. Apparently one of the girls had a sleepover and Jess cancelled plans with my daughter to go.

Then she found out Jess was making fun of her with the other girls and decided she and Jess were no longer friends. Jess apologized and tried to make it up to my daughter but my daughter is standing firm. Catherine reached out to me and asked me to help get the girls back together again.

I said no, that my daughter made her feelings clear and I wasn't going to get involved. When I didn't do it anyway Catherine reached out again and said it was a shame their friendship went sideways after so many years and how she used to rely on Jess spending time with my daughter because it meant not paying for childcare since she doesn't like Jess being home alone..

I told her that her childcare concerns are not my problem. She blew up at me and said I have known Jess since she was 5 years old and I should care about Catherine's inability to find someone to watch Jess for her when she has to work. She's claiming I'm insensitive and reached out several more times to call me out for it.. AITA?

ADVERTISEMENT

Friendships falling apart is tough, especially when kids are involved, but this mom’s stance is a masterclass in prioritizing her child. Catherine’s plea to reconnect the girls seems less about their bond and more about her own convenience—free childcare. The mom’s refusal, while blunt, reflects a clear boundary: her daughter’s emotional safety comes first. Catherine’s focus on childcare over Jess’s bullying behavior suggests misplaced priorities.

This situation mirrors a broader issue: parental boundaries in blended social circles. A 2023 study by the Pew Research Center found that 62% of parents struggle to balance supporting their child’s social needs with personal obligations (pewresearch.org). Here, Catherine’s reliance on the friendship for childcare clashed with the mom’s duty to protect her daughter from toxic dynamics.

ADVERTISEMENT

Dr. Becky Kennedy, a parenting expert, emphasizes, “Parents must model healthy boundaries to teach kids self-respect. Forcing a friendship after betrayal can undermine a child’s trust” (goodinside.com). The mom’s decision to back her daughter’s choice aligns with this, though her delivery could’ve been softer. Catherine’s reaction, framing it as insensitivity, sidesteps Jess’s role in the fallout.

For resolution, the mom should stand firm but offer empathy, perhaps suggesting Catherine address Jess’s behavior. Catherine could explore community resources for childcare, like after-school programs, to ease her burden without pressuring others. Open dialogue between parents, focusing on the kids’ actions, could prevent further conflict while respecting both families’ needs.

Check out how the community responded:

Reddit’s got some fiery opinions, and they’re serving up justice with a side of sass! The community weighed in on this parenting pickle, and they didn’t hold back. Here’s what they had to say:

ADVERTISEMENT

NuShoozy − NTA and if her biggest concern is her own loss, not her daughter doing something s**tty like that, it's very telling.

marvelgurl_88 − NTA. Apparently your value in your daughters friendship was free daycare, and your daughter had no value because she was tossed away when something “better” came along. They don’t value you and your daughter, you owe them nothing.

thunderstarss − NTA. You're setting a good example for your daughter to stand up for what she believes. It's not her fault that the mother's daughter decided to bully her to impress others. In fact, I think it was manipulative for the other mother to even bring up childcare, and not just genuinely want them to rebuild a friendship.

ADVERTISEMENT

Trin_42 − NTA, the only reason Catherine reaches out is because she no longer had free childcare, not because she wanted to find out what happened or repair the friendship, your daughter doesn’t need friends like that

[Reddit User] − NTA. She should care that her daughter is a jerk and be focused on fixing that and the damage her daughter has caused. Your priority is clearly your daughter's wellbeing not someone else's childcare issue. This is a consequence of her kid's behavior.

[Reddit User] − NTA. Catherine calling you insensitive is pretty rich considering the reason the friendship ended is because her own daughter bullied yours.

ADVERTISEMENT

TaiDollWave − NTA. They're 12 and not 5, how would you even make them be friends anyway? If Catherine feels so strongly about it, she should probably be talking to Jess about why it's wrong to talk to poorly about people and why choices like these can have consequences you don't even consider.

Maybe Catherine can call the parents of one of Jess's new friends and see if they can pal around. It isn't that you don't care about Jess, it's that your back your daughter up, and you're not going to force her to be friends with someone. Especially not someone who decided to be n**ty to her to be part of the in crowd.

FabledFires − NTA She's asking you to expose your daughter to bullying so she can have free childcare, she doesn't actually appear to be sorry for the pain her daughter caused. You're right to protect your child from someone that wants to use you and doesn't care for your daughter's wellbeing.

ADVERTISEMENT

awake_reciever − NTA, your daughter comes first

virtualchoirboy − NTA.. My reply would have been something along the lines of: You're getting angry at the wrong person. Your daughter chose to associate with new friends who proceeded to bully my daughter. Your daughter chose to join in said bullying.

My daughter rightfully ended the friendship to protect herself. If you want to complain to someone, I suggest you talk to your daughter about how she treats other people and how that treatment can have unintended consequences.

ADVERTISEMENT

These Reddit roasts call out Catherine’s motives, but do they oversimplify the pain of a broken friendship? Maybe the real question is how parents navigate loyalty when kids’ bonds break.

This story lays bare the tricky dance of parenting, loyalty, and boundaries. The mom’s blunt refusal to prioritize Catherine’s childcare needs over her daughter’s feelings sparked a heated clash, but it also highlighted the importance of standing by your child. As kids navigate friendships and parents juggle responsibilities, where do you draw the line? If you were in this mom’s shoes, would you push your kid to forgive, or stand firm like she did? Share your thoughts below!

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *