AITA For telling a woman that I’m not at fault because she can’t control her dog?

Jonathan Hours
Comments 0 Comments

The sun peeked through the leafy canopy of the local park, casting playful shadows on the winding walking track where a young woman and her sprightly puppy, Tav, were wrapping up their morning stroll. The air buzzed with the hum of a peaceful day—kids giggling in the nearby playground, birds chirping—until a sudden commotion shattered the calm. A woman’s voice, sharp and accusatory, cut through the serenity, blaming our protagonist for her dog’s wild behavior. Caught off guard, the 25-year-old dog owner faced a choice: stay silent or stand her ground.

This wasn’t just a clash of leashes but a moment that sparked a fiery debate about responsibility and public etiquette. With her puppy by her side, she fired back, refusing to shoulder the blame for another’s untrained pet. Was her retort justified, or did she cross a line? Let’s dive into this juicy park drama and see what unfolded.

‘AITA For telling a woman that I’m not at fault because she can’t control her dog?’

Hey y'all! So, this morning I (25f) took my 6 month old lab/malinois mix puppy to the local park for a walk/training session. The way the park is set up is that there is a children's play area and a walking track that starts at the mouth of the play area and loops around the perimeter of the rest of the park (not the play area).

So, on my final lap another couple with a medium mix breed dog gets out of a car and starts walking the path in the opposite way as me (so that we would meet in the middle). Once I notice them getting closer, I stepped off the path and start making my way to the parking lot, cutting through the grass because while my puppy is generally good with passing another dog no problem,

ADVERTISEMENT

I like to minimize the possibility of issues especially with us leaving. I'm still walking in the same direction I was, just about 50ft away from the path more in line with the parking lot. As we come almost parallel with this couple, their dog hits the end of its leash almost yanking the lady off her feet growling and barking and trying to get closer to us.

I keep going, ignoring them and calling my puppy into a close heel to keep him from engaging with the other dog. This woman then proceeds to yell at me telling me that I'm at fault for her dog reacting and that I shouldn't be at the park cause I'm never there when they are and I'm the one causing a scene.

I turn to this woman and tell her 'Don't blame me because you didn't train your dog and can't control him'. I then promptly continued and got to my car, loaded up my dog, and left, the whole time this lady is cussing me out and her dog is going even crazier. I was venting to my mom, and while she was empathetic, she told me that it was rude of me to respond instead of just continuing to walk away. So, AITA?

This park showdown highlights the delicate dance of sharing public spaces with pets. The Reddit user’s decision to sidestep conflict by veering toward the parking lot showed foresight, yet she was still dragged into a verbal tussle. The opposing perspectives are clear: the OP prioritized her puppy’s safety and training, while the other woman deflected her dog’s misbehavior onto a stranger. It’s a classic case of projection, with a hint of entitlement—after all, who claims a park as their exclusive turf?

ADVERTISEMENT

This scenario reflects a broader issue: pet ownership comes with a duty to train and control animals in public. According to the American Kennel Club, over 50% of dog owners struggle with leash reactivity, often due to inconsistent training (source: akc.org). Dr. Patricia McConnell, a renowned animal behaviorist, notes, “Dogs reflect their owners’ efforts—or lack thereof. A reactive dog isn’t a villain; it’s a sign training needs work” (source: patriciamcconnell.com). Here, the other woman’s dog lunging and barking suggests gaps in its socialization, not the OP’s presence.

Dr. McConnell’s insight underscores that the OP’s retort, while sharp, addressed a real issue: accountability. The other woman’s anger likely stemmed from embarrassment, but blaming others doesn’t fix a dog’s behavior. For the OP, staying calm and removing herself was wise, though her words stirred the pot. Moving forward, pet owners can de-escalate by ignoring outbursts and focusing on their own animals. Training classes or behaviorists can help reactive dogs, fostering harmony in shared spaces

Check out how the community responded:

The Reddit crew didn’t hold back, dishing out a mix of sass and support for our park protagonist. Here’s a peek at their candid, sometimes chuckle-worthy takes.

ADVERTISEMENT

carnivorousgrass − NTA. That woman aggro'd at you randomly. Could you have just walked away and ignored her? Yep. Was it rude of you to respond to her? I'd say no. You don't need to take that s**t from some random crazy lady yelling at you. You didn't stay and try to fight her, you just snapped back with a retort to her unjustified yelling and promptly left.

Ill_Industry6452 − NTA. If this is real, that should be a no brainer. You avoided them by walking towards the parking lot. You kept your pup close to you. Her dog was out of control. Your dog didn’t even growl.. Your response was perfect in my opinion.

ADVERTISEMENT

Libba_Loo − she told me that it was rude of me to respond instead of just continuing to walk away.  Hard disagree with mom here. She yelled at you and you answered back. Being polite doesn't mean giving people a pass to talk to you any old way, especially when they're the ones in the wrong.. NTA

NotTheMama4208 − Come on. Obviously NTA. Some people should not have pets or children. Edit: you didn't have to engage her, I agree with that, but you did what I would have done. My judgment stands.

ADVERTISEMENT

thehappymuggle − My dog is the 'I must befriend and play with every dog I see' type of dog. If I didn't have her leashed at the front of the harness, she would attempt to drag me into a stormy ocean if she thought there was a playmate in there. And you know what? That's my problem.

I've trained some of it out of her, but she's hellbent on being a total ring piece some days and will pirouette and prance about like an utter n**ny if she spots another dog. I would never go so far as to blame another dog walker for her fuckery. They're allowed to be there. My dog's one brain cell is my problem and if I acted like it was otherwise, I'd fully deserve a comeback. You're NTA.

ADVERTISEMENT

IamIrene − This woman then proceeds to yell at me telling me that I'm at fault for her dog reacting and that I shouldn't be at the park cause I'm never there when they are and I'm the one causing a scene. That's rich coming from the person who can't control her own dog. The projection coming from that one, wow, lol. Misdirected anger is like that though. She's mad at herself and you were the nearest target available.. Obvious NTA.

lobsterp0t − NTA. My dog sometimes ends up at the end of the lead lunging and barking. She is well trained. It is a behaviour problem not really a training one and it improving gradually with a lot of work on alternatives to deal with frustration and fear.

ADVERTISEMENT

Your reaction was reasonable. I get embarrassed when my dog has a big reaction and so I can understand wanting to blame someone else in the moment because it can be stressful, but that lady was way out of line, and was also incorrect.

hatterson − Your comment back to her may not have been the mister rogers approved response, but it doesn't seem remotely over the top.. NTA.

ADVERTISEMENT

PowerfulScholar8605 − Definitely NTA. This lady is delusional to blame you for her dog's reaction to you being in a place you had every right to be. I don't think your response was even rude, and it was justified, to say the least, with this woman's behavior.

ComplexRoll9655 − NTA, i highly recommend body cams for any such situations in future - since you have a malinoi mix you will be default target blamed for all kinds of insanity - so bodycam is one way to help avoid situations where its your word versus someone elses.. Also, good on you standing your ground. I think people should be called out on their obvious bs.

ADVERTISEMENT

These Reddit hot takes are spicy, but do they nail the truth? Maybe the park’s the real MVP for hosting such drama!

This tale of leashes and loudmouths reminds us that parks are shared spaces where responsibility reigns supreme. The Reddit user held her ground, tossing back a quip that was equal parts truth and zing. Whether you’re Team “Say It Like It Is” or Team “Walk Away,” one thing’s clear: pet etiquette sparks passionate opinions. What would you do if a stranger blamed you for their dog’s chaos? Drop your thoughts below and let’s keep this dog park debate barking!

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *