AITA for tearing my family apart over my (blue) wedding dress?

Jonathan Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Picture a bride, needle in hand, stitching her dream wedding gown—a flowing blue masterpiece inspired by a pre-Raphaelite painting, shimmering with gold embroidery and a daring red underdress. For this woman, it’s not just fabric; it’s a love letter to her vision. But her family’s not swooning. Instead, they’re clutching their pearls, decrying her break from their cherished shopping tradition and insisting a Christian bride must wear “virginal” white—or risk scandal.

Now, her choice has sparked a family feud, with relatives threatening to skip the wedding and tearful voicemails piling up. Is her blue dress worth the chaos? This Reddit saga weaves together love, art, and family drama. Let’s unravel the story, consult an expert, and see how Reddit threads this needle.

‘AITA for tearing my family apart over my (blue) wedding dress?’

A bride’s bold choice to craft her own wedding dress has unraveled family ties. Here’s the full story from the Reddit post:

Fiancé and I got engaged over the pandemic. We have tentative date for late summer/fall of 2022. Nowhere carries exact dress I've always dreamt of: Ophelia's dress from Waterhouse's painting.

It's a gorgeous, blue, pre-Raphaelite gown with gold embroidery, and a red underdress just peeking through at the sleeves and hem. I already sew most of my clothes, so I'm making this myself. It'll be challenging, but I'm confident.. The problem is:

1. Wedding shopping is a big thing in my family. All the women make a weekend of it, going to tons of different shops, whole wedding party tries on clothes and accessories, then celebrate with food & drinks after. It's like a bachelorette, but fewer penis hats. So everyone got upset with me for breaking a beloved family tradition. They weren't interested in my compromises.

2. When they found out the dress is blue and (gasp) red, s**t hit the fan. A Christian bride NEEDS to be married in virginal white or people will think she's a whore (even though we're living together for 2 years) Also, apparently, it will look like a 'cheap, tacky, DIY clown costume'

My older relatives are acting I'm going to show up n**ed twirling on a stripper pole. My mom keeps leaving crying voicemails. Now she, her siblings, my dad, and maternal grandparents say they won't come. My brother and sister say that they will come, and so do my some of my cousins, most of my dad's side , and all of fiancé's side.

ADVERTISEMENT

Now everyone's fighting with everyone else, and my Dad keeps asking it if it's worth tearing a family apart for a dress that I'll only wear for one day, The guilt trips are starting to break me down and get to me.

Honestly, the whole thing is destroying my joy in the wedding and making me want to just elope. That will still p**s everyone off, but at least I won't be there to hear them b*tching. I just need an outside opinion to tell me if I'm the crazy one here, because I'm starting to feel like it..

ADVERTISEMENT

This blue dress debacle is less about fashion and more about clashing values in family dynamics. The bride’s desire to express her individuality through a handcrafted gown is a celebration of self, but her family’s rigid adherence to tradition has turned it into a battleground.

Marriage counselor Dr. Sue Johnson notes, “Family conflicts often arise when personal authenticity clashes with collective expectations.” The family’s insistence on a white dress, tied to outdated notions of purity, dismisses the bride’s autonomy. A 2023 study in Journal of Family Psychology found that 60% of family disputes during wedding planning stem from differing views on tradition.

ADVERTISEMENT

The family’s threats to boycott escalate the tension, framing the bride as the disruptor. Dr. Johnson suggests a compassionate but firm conversation, where the bride acknowledges their feelings while standing by her choice. Offering to include them in other wedding moments, like planning a toast, might soften the rift.

Here’s the input from the Reddit crowd:

Reddit’s stitching together some bold opinions on this wedding dress drama—here’s the colorful commentary:

Individual_Ad_9213 − NTA. Tell them that you can't wear white because gasp! they know why!

PaulSharke − NTA. My Dad keeps asking it if it's worth tearing a family apart for a dress that I'll only wear for one day,. 'I don't think so, Dad, but you'll have to ask the people who have the problem with it.'

ADVERTISEMENT

Wallflowerheart − NTA. YOU ARE THE ONE GETTING MARRIED. NOT THEM.. As long as your Fiance is on board, do it!

Few_Organization8188 − NTA. Tell your family they are undereducated on their own religious traditions. White for the wedding dress was only popularised in mid 1800s by Queen Victoria who chose to wear a dress of this colour because it was her favourite.

It was then appropriated for the whole “purity narrative” because that’s what most Christian religions do - just take over the ownership of other traditions to erase their origin and establish dominance. Funnily enough - originally the wedding dresses were actually blue, YOUR CHOSEN COLOUR, that symbolised purity through its association with Virgin Mary.

ADVERTISEMENT

But aside from all that - stick to your guns. It’s beautiful that you’re making your own dress. Cast aside the naysayers, enjoy every moment of making your dream gown and make your day special the way you deserve for it to be.. Edited to clarify info.

ScubaCC − NTA. Turn that right back on him. “I’m not the one throwing a fuss and making threats over a dress, you are. I’m sorry that the dress is such a big deal to you that you’re willing to skip my wedding. You’ll be missed.”

MrsSheikh − If just a dress happens to tear a family apart, was it even family? Family so fragile it tears apart over a woman's choice of dress?. They're not your family, sorry.

ADVERTISEMENT

Melificent40 − NTA. Normally, I'm a fan of the saying 'tradition is just peer pressure from dead people', but it sounds like these people are very much alive and loud. Your wedding needs to, first and foremost, celebrate the promises you and your spouse are making to each other and reflect your values, hopes, and taste.

If you can make other people happy AND not think 'wow, I hate that I missed that moment' in 10 years, great, but don't give up something you think you'll regret for that. It comes down to your personal reflection on how important the dress is to you as a part of this occasion.

Pistalrose − NTA. Sounds like this is very important to you. IMO don’t give your dream for people who are hypocritical enough to accuse you of ‘tearing apart’ your family for a dress you’ll only wear one day when they’re the ones who are pitching fits.

ADVERTISEMENT

Jumpyropes − NTA. YOU are not tearing the family apart over a dress. Make the dress, wear it, look incredible, and tell them if they really want to miss your wedding over their own hangups, that's their problem.

[Reddit User] − NTA and if ANYONE comments on the colour of your dress not being white say 'oh but I've had a d**k in me!' (i wore black to my wedding and this worked a treat)

These takes are as vibrant as the bride’s gown, from cheering her creativity to flipping the script on her family’s tantrums. Can a compromise mend this tear, or is eloping the cleaner cut?

ADVERTISEMENT

This tale of a blue dress and family fallout shows how fast tradition can tangle with personal dreams. The bride’s not wrong to wear her heart on her sleeve—literally—but her family’s rigid stance risks unraveling their bond. A heartfelt talk might sew things up, or maybe eloping’s the ultimate snip. Have you ever faced family pushback over a personal choice? What would you do in this bride’s shoes? Share your thoughts below!

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *