AITA for teaching my (step) son how to shave?

The bathroom mirror fogged up as a 14-year-old boy, armed with a razor and shaky confidence, faced his first real shave. For one stepfather, this was a chance to bond, to pass down a rite of passage with care and a steady hand. But when his wife returned home, the smooth shave sparked an unexpected storm. She felt sidelined, yearning for a moment she believed was hers to share with her son, whose biological father passed away years ago.

This Reddit tale dives into the messy, heartfelt world of blended families, where love and loyalty tangle with unspoken expectations. The stepfather’s well-meaning act stirred a debate about parenting roles, leaving readers wondering: who gets to claim these milestone moments? With emotions running high, this story captures the delicate balance of stepping into a father’s shoes while respecting a mother’s heart.

‘AITA for teaching my (step) son how to shave?’

Let me preface this by saying that I've been with my (33) wife (29) for 7 years now and she's the best, we have a wonderful relationship and she's generally very understanding on all things, except for all things concerning our kids (14m & 10f), both of the little ones are hers from her 'ex' for lack of a better term.

The ex (who I knew before) passed 11 years ago and the wife has done an exceptional job at raising both kids, being a mom and a dad. Now the problem at hand is that my son has started shaving, and not very well if I do say so myself. I'm talking a lot of razor burns, irritation and some cuts.

Being his dad and all I thought it was my responsibility to show him how to do it properly without f*cking his face up every time. So one day when both the girls were out I decided to show him how it's done and I basically shaved him. After shaving I cleaned him up, gave him some tonic and balm and sent him on his way.

So his mom came and he very excitedly showed her his irritation free shave. She told him how good it looked and that's he was getting the hang of it, he told her he didn't but dad did it for him. I could tell that something was off with her so I asked her later on when we were alone if she was alone.

This is when she told me that she was thankful I showed him how to shave but shouldn't have showed him how as she felt like it was an intimate moment he should've shared with his father, but as he wasn't here she would've shown him and I should've have told him to ask his mom, that I robbed her of another intimate moment that she wouldn't be getting with her son.

My view is that I am his father. I taught him how to ride a bike, I held him when he had his nightmares, I wiped his b**t when he broke his arms. We may not share the same DNA but he is my son nonetheless, so I get a right to having these moments with him where she gets more of them with our daughter.

So far everyone whose aware of what happened is split on this. She told my mom and sister, her mom and sisters and some of her friends agree with her. But our dads and my BIL's (both sides of family) agree with me.. Reddit, AITA?

Navigating blended families can feel like walking a tightrope, especially when milestone moments are at stake. The stepfather’s decision to teach his stepson to shave highlights a common tension: balancing parental roles without overstepping boundaries. According to Dr. Patricia Papernow, a renowned expert in stepfamily dynamics, “Stepparents often face the challenge of being a parent figure without the full authority of a biological parent” (Family Process). Here, the wife’s reaction likely stems from grief over her late partner and a desire to preserve her son’s connection to his father’s memory.

ADVERTISEMENT

The stepfather’s perspective is valid—he’s been a father figure for seven years, teaching bike-riding and soothing nightmares. Yet, the mother’s sense of loss is equally real, as she navigates single-parent instincts in a blended family. This clash reflects a broader issue: 40% of stepfamilies report conflicts over parenting roles, per a 2020 study in Journal of Marriage and Family (Wiley Online Library). The mother’s expectation to teach her son herself wasn’t communicated, creating a blind spot.

Dr. Papernow advises clear communication to avoid such missteps: “Stepparents and biological parents must discuss expectations openly to build trust.” The stepfather could acknowledge his wife’s feelings while affirming his role, perhaps suggesting they share future milestones together. Couples counseling, as some Redditors suggested, could help align their parenting visions. For now, validating both perspectives—his bond with his stepson and her emotional stake—can pave the way for mutual understanding.

ADVERTISEMENT

Here’s what Redditors had to say:

The Reddit crew jumped into the fray with a mix of cheers and raised eyebrows, offering candid takes on this family face-off. Here’s what they had to say, raw and unfiltered:

pattisabs − NTA, I think she’s being irrational about this, he’s your stepson and he’s fine with you being involved in that way. If she wanted to teach him she should have done so already rather than letting him do so poorly.

ADVERTISEMENT

whatthefrelll − NTA. I'm sad on your behalf that she doesn't seem to view you as a parent to those kids. It would be different if you'd just gotten together but you have been a father to them for 7 years. Could you suggest some sort of family counselling?

steveholtismymother − NTA. How would she even be *able* to teach him how to shave? Shaving the sensitive skin on your face every day (or fairly often) is very different from e.g. shaving your legs. Or so I assume, as a woman. In any case, it was obvious that the kid did not know how to shave and your wife did nothing about it, so she lost her chance.

ADVERTISEMENT

Frankly it sounds a bit crazy that after 7 years she'd get into a huff about something like this. Is she in general worried about the kids growing up too fast and leaving the nest soon or something, which she's now projecting into this rite of passage for your son?

luna-ljus − NTA - I was giving her the benefit of doubt because it must have been rough to lose her partner at a young age and to be both mother and father, and hats off to her. She's the AH though for telling you, his step father of 7 years, that you shouldn't have done it because it's a job for his father. You are his father, and that was cruel.. Did you explain your view to her? I don't understand how there's any way she could disagree.

MsB0x − NAH - but if she has these expectations about key moments in his life she needs to communicate them with you. She can’t expect you to read her mind about what is and isn’t okay, especially if she’s okay with you taking on other parental duties without issue.

ADVERTISEMENT

imcee − Nta- why did she marry you and bring her kid into it if she doesn't actually want you involved?

SarinaVazquez − NTA.. I robbed her of another intimate moment she wouldn’t be getting with her son You didn’t rob her of anything because this wasn’t a moment that was supposed to be hers to begin with. Your son was robbed of another intimate moment he should’ve spent with his father.

Because of this the next best option is for him to share it with a man he sees as a father figure which would be you, the man who has helped raise him since he was 7. I need to know if she said he was “her son” or not. If she did then she was absolutely TA.

ADVERTISEMENT

yofabgab − NTA. It was an intimate moment for you and your son and I’m glad you were able to share that moment with him. It sounds like it was really special and like he truly appreciated it.

[Reddit User] − NTA if you’re wife feels so strongly about wanting to do certain things she should tell you. But honestly I couldn’t see this playing out any better way. Props to you for being a good father.

lightening_mckeen − NTA what does a woman know about shaving a man's face? If my dad tried telling me how to shave my legs when I was little that woulda been weird. Some 'intimate' moments need to be taught by someone other than a genetic parent.

ADVERTISEMENT

These Redditors rallied behind the stepfather, praising his hands-on parenting, but some saw the mother’s side, urging better communication. Their hot takes spark a question: are they fanning the flames or cutting through the fog?

This story reminds us that blended families are a delicate dance of love, loss, and new bonds. The stepfather’s shaving lesson was a heartfelt act, but it uncovered deeper tensions about roles and rituals. By talking openly, this couple can find a rhythm that honors both their contributions. What would you do if you were caught between stepping up as a parent and respecting someone else’s space? Share your thoughts and experiences below!

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *