AITA for telling my brother he can’t raise his child in my house?
Imagine sinking every penny you’ve saved since your teens into a dream home, a sanctuary where you can kick back, crank up the video games, and live life on your terms. For one 27-year-old homeowner, that dream came true—until his brother and sister-in-law moved in, rent-free, to save cash. Now, with a baby on the way, the house is about to get a lot noisier, and he’s drawing a line in the sand. Is he wrong to want his space back?
This Reddit tale is a rollercoaster of family loyalty, personal boundaries, and the chaos a newborn can bring. The original poster (OP) loves his brother but isn’t ready to trade his gaming haven for a nursery. As tensions rise, we’re left wondering: can you put your own dreams first when family needs you? Let’s dive into this domestic drama.
‘AITA for telling my brother he can’t raise his child in my house?’
A young man’s hard-earned home becomes a temporary haven for his brother’s family, but a new baby threatens to change the vibe. Here’s the story, straight from Reddit:
This homeowner’s dilemma is a classic clash of generosity versus personal space. The OP’s been a saint, letting his brother and sister-in-law live rent-free, but a baby changes the game—think midnight cries and toys underfoot. Is he wrong to reclaim his home?
Relationship expert Dr. John Gottman notes in a Psychology Today article, “Boundaries in family dynamics are essential for maintaining individual well-being and mutual respect” (Source). The OP’s decision to ask his brother to move out reflects a need to protect his sanctuary, especially since the couple can afford rent but chose not to pay it. Their assumption that they could stay indefinitely, even with a baby, overlooks the OP’s autonomy.
This ties into a broader issue: family entitlement. A 2022 Pew Research study found 43% of young adults live with family to save money, but this can strain relationships when boundaries aren’t set (Source). The brother’s hurt feelings are valid, but planning a family without securing housing suggests poor foresight.
Gottman advises, “Clear communication prevents resentment.” The OP could’ve set expectations earlier, like a move-out timeline. Now, he might offer a firm deadline with support, like helping them find a place.
Heres what people had to say to OP:
Reddit’s got opinions hotter than a summer BBQ, and they’re serving up some real talk on this family feud. Here’s what the community had to say:
![[Reddit User] − NTA. You have been more than generous to them and they should have had time to build up savings. Did they really think this arrangement would be permanent? 'My family also seems to think it is wrong of me to ask them to find their own place when they are expecting a child.' Guess what? Mature people usually have housing arranged before starting a family.](https://en.aubtu.biz/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/254130b-07.png)
![[Reddit User] − This seems a light version of other sub without all the narc parents telling their son to give up a house to his brother, wife and kids. NTA, but you are dumb. Your family will gang up on you and asking you to give your house for free evil laughs hahahah. Be ready to go NC with the rest of your family and be blamed for your brother fk ups.](https://en.aubtu.biz/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/254130b-12.png)
These Reddit takes are spicy, but do they nail the heart of the issue?
This story of a dream home turned family crash pad shows how fast generosity can spark conflict. The OP’s heart was open, but his house isn’t a free hotel—especially with a baby on board. Have you ever had to set boundaries with family crashing your space? Share your thoughts or stories below—what would you do if your home was about to become a nursery?
