AITA for replacing my MOH in my wedding because she refused to buy her dress?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

The excitement of planning a wedding often comes with unexpected challenges, and this story is no exception. A bride, determined to keep her bridal party’s expenses fair, set clear expectations about dress costs when her special day was on the horizon. In an atmosphere filled with anticipation and the promise of a memorable celebration, every detail from hotel rooms to dress colors was decided in advance.

The narrative takes a twist when long-standing friendship collides with financial reality. The bride’s Maid of Honor, accustomed to sharing memories from childhood to college, made a surprising decision by choosing a dress well beyond the agreed budget. This choice sparked a bitter dispute that not only strained their bond but also raised questions about fairness and the true meaning of being part of an intimate celebration.

‘AITA for replacing my MOH in my wedding because she refused to buy her dress?’

I’m getting married in Sept and all of my bridesmaids and I went dress shopping a couple months ago. For some context we’re all in our mid 20s, employed, with no children, my wedding is out of town for my MOH and a couple other bridesmaids, but I’m getting a hotel room for all out of town bridesmaids for the wedding.

I’ve known my MOH since 5th grade and we were best friends all through school. I moved away for college and we drifted apart, but I’d see her every time I came home. The dress shopping trip was out of town so I paid for the 2 hotel rooms while we were there and I drove, my mom brought my MOH and a couple other bridesmaids a since they still live in my hometown.

For the dresses my only requirement for them were that they had to be a specific blue color and no satin material. We spent the whole afternoon trying on dresses and everyone found one they liked, including my MOH. I’ve been told she picked out a $350 dress when most of my other bridesmaids had dresses in the $100-$150 range.

The next day was spent relaxing at the pool where my MOH began complaining to one of my other bridesmaids about having to pay for her dress. Saying it was my wedding, and if I wanted a specific dress for them to wear I should pay for it, and that I didn’t pay for the bridesmaid dress when I was in her wedding (she got married at 18 and we wore old prom dresses we already had).

My bridesmaid told her I was being pretty reasonable with my request and that she can get any dress she wanted in her budget. MOH disagreed and the bridesmaid shrugged her off, but told me about it later. A month later my MOH called me and asked for me to buy her dress for her. I told her it wouldn’t be fair if I bought her dress and no one else’s and I couldn’t afford to buy everyone’s dress.

She said she is the MOH and that everyone would understand it was a privilege she got. I disagreed and our argument got a little heated. It ended with me saying if she could not get the dress, she couldn’t be in the wedding and I wasn’t budging on this. She hung up on me.

Her mom has since called me saying I’m being very rude for not doing this one thing for her so she can be there on my big day and that I don’t understand what it’s like to not have money for things. I told her I have struggled before too and understand, but said I’m not paying for the dress because it won’t be fair to all of the other bridesmaids.

I’ve since made one of my other bridesmaids that has helped with all of the planning my MOH and I’ve told my ex-MOH she is still invited and sent her an invitation, but some family is telling me I should have just paid for the dress. I know ex-MOH is tight on money, but she’s known she was going to be in my wedding for nearly two years at this point so I thought she would set aside money for it. AITA for not paying for her dress?

Letting your partner meet your family can feel like a monumental step, and similarly, involving close friends in wedding plans can be both exciting and stressful. This story encapsulates the fine balance between personal expectations and financial realities in planning such a momentous occasion. The bride’s situation is intriguing: she clearly communicated a budget-friendly dress requirement to all her bridesmaids, yet her Maid of Honor’s decision to choose a far costlier option stirred more than just a minor disagreement.

This misalignment between expectations and actions led not only to personal disappointment but also to broader questions about mutual responsibility in shared celebrations. Weddings today often reveal deeper social dynamics. With rising costs and economic pressures, it’s not uncommon for financial disagreements to surface during the planning stages. According to numerous reports, many couples find themselves caught between upholding tradition and managing a tight budget.

This case, filled with nuances of long-term friendships versus practical limitations, mirrors a growing trend where clear financial communication becomes paramount. “Explicit communication about financial responsibilities is vital for preventing resentment and misunderstandings in intimate relationships,” states Dr. Susan Heitler, a renowned clinical psychologist and author well-known for her work in resolving relationship conflicts.

Her perspective reminds us that setting clear expectations and discussing money matters openly can alleviate many of the tensions that arise during wedding planning. In the present case, the bride’s upfront approach to establishing a unified budget highlights a proactive strategy that, while not universally appreciated, serves to maintain fairness among all parties. In light of this expert advice, the conflict becomes a cautionary tale about balancing emotional bonds with practical financial decisions.

Had there been a more in-depth conversation about individual budgets ahead of time, the misunderstanding might have been averted. Ultimately, the situation serves as a reminder that healthy relationships—whether romantic or platonic—rely on transparent conversations and mutual respect. The incident invites readers to consider not only the financial aspects of wedding planning but also how clear communication can preserve lifelong friendships.

These are the responses from Reddit users:

Here are some hot takes from the Reddit community – candid and humorous in their own right. These comments offer a range of perspectives, from outright support for the bride’s decision to nuanced takes on financial responsibility, underscoring the reality that while opinions may be diverse, fairness and pre-established expectations remain at the heart of the debate.

Late_Confidence8101 − NTA. It would not be fair to the other bridesmaids if you paid for her dress and not theirs. The most egregious part is the fact that all of your bridesmaids were given your criteria for the dresses and she picked out a $350 dress while the other bridesmaids picked out dresses in the $100- $150 range.

Then she wants you to pay for the $350 dress! If she truly wanted to be in your wedding, she would have save $100-$150 over a two year period. Clearly, her desire was to score an expensive dress that she did not have to pay for. As to her mother's comment, it sounds like you are welcoming her to be there for your big day - just not as a bridesmaid who won't pay for her dress.

somethingstrange87 − NTA. Sometimes brides pay for bridesmaids' dresses. Sometimes they don't. MOH knew you weren't and picked a dress at least twice as expensive as everyone else's, then whined that it was too expensive.

Sea-Tea-4130 − NTA-It’s common to buy your own MOH/bridesmaid dress so if she can’t afford to be in the wedding (understandable if money is an issue), it’s quite alright to replace her. Imo, it was s**tty of her to complain about the dress to others when that was something she could have brought up to you one-on-one which makes me wonder if she is really struggling with money or simply didn’t want to buy the dress. Either way, you made the right decision.

Far_Nefariousness773 − NAH I paid for all my dresses. I set a budget and if you went over, you paid the difference. I didn’t have many just 3 and a MOH and the limit was $300. If my best friend had told me she couldn’t afford it, I would have paid for everything because we are close and she’s my MOH.

As for your response, it’s reasonable. She should have never accepted if she couldn’t afford it when you said they would be paying. I have turned down being a bridesmaid because I don’t want to spend a couple of grand on someone else’s wedding. I rather attend as a guest.

I have been a bridesmaid 2x and it was paid for. People need to have boundaries and priorities for their own pockets. If I can’t afford it without hurting myself, then the answer is no. She should have said no, or explained that if she did, she would need help.. Communication is key here.

Liss78 − if I wanted a specific dress for them to wear I should pay for it, But you didn't. You gave her a color to pick from. She chose a dress that wasn't in her budget. Oh well. She can find something she can afford or she can attend as a guest. She doesn't get to expect you to pay and then get pissed when you don't.

RandomReddit9791 − If she was tight on money she should've said that upfront and asked if you could help her purchase the dress. She certainly shouldn't have picked a $350 dress, complain to a bridesmaid, wait a while then ask you to buy the dress.. She's problematic and you did thebright thing removing her from the bridal party.

Such-Sherbet-1015 − Question -- when did you tell her she was responsible for paying for her dress? On the trip? Months before hand?

Tasty_Doughnut_9226 − Honestly, I don't get this asking people in the wedding party to pay for dresses, hair, etc. If I had had bridesmaids at my wedding I would have been footing the bill for all of it, but I'm in England, so see it's different in other places.. NTA because you're correct it wouldn't be fair and she didn't need to choose a dress that expensive.

Chocolategirl1234 − Coming from the UK, this blows my mind! I assume you’re from the US where I believe it’s culturally normal to expect the bridesmaids to pay for the dress so you’re probably NTA. But here it would be considered very odd to ask your friends to pay for a dress they may well not wear again.

Having-hope3594 − NTA. As long as everyone knew before the shopping trip that they would be expected to pay for their dresses. You have paid for hotel rooms for the shopping trip and will pay at the wedding. 

In conclusion, the intricate dance of wedding planning extends far beyond just choosing a dress. It touches on deeper issues such as financial responsibility, clear communication, and the delicate balance required to maintain long-term relationships.

The bride’s dilemma invites us to reflect on what truly matters in our commitments and how we navigate personal boundaries without compromising cherished bonds. What would you do if you found yourself in a similar situation? Share your thoughts, experiences, and advice in the comments below – let’s start a conversation about where responsibility meets celebration.

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *