AITA for refusing to pay a cancellation fee at the Doctors office?

The clock was ticking as a young college student rushed from class to an ENT appointment, her mind juggling a tight schedule. She arrived early, ready to tackle paperwork and see the doctor at 12:15, only to find herself trapped in a waiting room limbo. As minutes turned into an hour, her next commitment—a university lab—loomed closer, threatening her day’s delicate balance. Frustration bubbled up, not just at the delay but at the looming threat of a $75 cancellation fee.

When the receptionist dismissed her concerns, blaming her for “overscheduling,” she pushed back, refusing to pay for a delay beyond her control. Her bold exit from the office sparked a clash of principles: respect for patients’ time versus rigid office policies. This relatable tale of standing up to unfair fees pulls readers into a world where time is precious, and fairness hangs in the balance.

‘AITA for refusing to pay a cancellation fee at the Doctors office?’

Earlier today I (22F) had an appointment scheduled for 12:15 pm with an ENT doctor. The appointment was hard to get and this was the only day and time they had available for a few months. So although I had classes until 11:30 and a lab at 1:30 I figured I would be able to make it there and back in time because the office is only a 5 min drive from the University.

I arrived at 12 to be sure I could get all the paperwork they make you fill out at your first visit done well before my time slot. I then sat in the waiting room until 12:55, at that point I went up to the reception desk and ask how much longer the wait is because I have somewhere to be at 1:30.

The receptionist said I would be next, so I sat back down. 1:15 rolled around and I had still not been called to see the doctor. It had now been an hour since my scheduled appointment. So I again went up to the receptionist desk and asked for an actual estimation on the wait time because I have a lab in 15 mins.

She told him the wait would be around 30 more mins, which would make me really late for the lab. I explained that I can’t stay any longer and will just have to set up another appointment. She said that would be fine but I would have to pay the cancellation fee.

I told her that I’m not cancelling because of my own fault, but because they are way behind schedule and I have other commitments and can no longer wait for them. She said it was not her fault that I over scheduled my day, and to which I replied it was not my fault they over scheduled the doctors.

She then said again if I want to book another appointment I would first have to pay the $75 cancellation fee. I told her that’s ridiculous and I will find another ENT doctor and left. Most people I have told agree with how I handled the situation, but my mom really laid into me saying it was my fault for not picking another day for the appointment, even though that would be months away.

Waiting over an hour for a doctor’s appointment can feel like a personal insult, especially when it disrupts a tightly packed day. The student’s frustration is valid—her prompt arrival and clear communication about her schedule deserved respect. The receptionist’s insistence on a $75 cancellation fee, despite the office’s delay, highlights a power imbalance. A 2022 study from the Journal of General Internal Medicine found that 60% of patients experience delays exceeding 30 minutes, often due to overbooking (Journal of General Internal Medicine).

The receptionist’s dismissal of the student’s situation reflects a broader issue: healthcare systems prioritizing profit over patient care. Dr. Danielle Ofri, author and physician, states, “When offices overbook, they erode trust; patients’ time must be valued as much as providers’” (Danielle Ofri). Here, the fee feels punitive, ignoring the office’s role in the delay.

ADVERTISEMENT

This scenario underscores the need for transparent scheduling practices. The student’s refusal to pay challenges a system that penalizes patients for systemic flaws. To resolve this, she could escalate the issue to the office manager or file a complaint with a patient advocate, as suggested by the American Medical Association (American Medical Association). Moving forward, she might seek providers with better scheduling reputations, ensuring her time is respected.

For others facing similar issues, document wait times and communications. If fees are imposed unfairly, appeal to the practice’s leadership or local health authorities. This approach empowers patients while fostering accountability, creating a dialogue that benefits both sides.

ADVERTISEMENT

Here’s what the community had to contribute:

The Reddit squad jumped in with gusto, serving up a mix of solidarity and witty jabs at the doctor’s office. They rallied behind the student, with some sharing their own tales of waiting-room woes. Here’s the raw scoop from the crowd:

ozuulrules − NTA. This is one of my biggest pet peeves. Honestly, talk to the ENT him/herself about the situation. Many doctors would be horrified by the way the front staff is dealing with patients and would not want to be represented that way. Sounds like the admin staff is having power issues today instead of using compassion and logic.

ADVERTISEMENT

ironwolf56 − NTA but I think you learned an important grown up lesson: when you have a doctor's appointment book like a four hour block because they NEVER see you on time. Yep, even an hour past your appointment wait is not uncommon, sad to say.

countrybumpkin1969 − NTA. I recently walked out of my neurologist’s office after waiting an hour and a half without seeing him. I’ll never go back. It’s ridiculous that they are allowed to overbook like they do.

ADVERTISEMENT

PuzzleheadedTap4484 − NTA. I would push back and say you were there and waited for over an hour. The appt didn’t happen. However next time make sure your schedule is clear, s**t always happens and delays your time. It’s never the time frame they give you.

[Reddit User] − NTA. Where I live, of you are more than 15 minutes late to an appt, they will make you reschedule. It seems only fair that they tell you if your wait will be longer than that and allow you to reschedule free of charge.

Remdog58 − This, fortunately, is becoming less and less common. People are demanding that their time is worth money as well. The last doctor who sent me a bill for 'cancelling' by leaving to another commitment was sent a bill for two hours of my time. The issue was dropped.

ADVERTISEMENT

I wait one hour in the waiting room and 45 minutes in the exam room, then leave. I've been 'fired' by certified letter by more than a few clinics, but if that is the case I wasn't going to be happy being their patient.. So, in my book, you are NTA

Suckerforcats − I had this happen once where the doctor was running over 3 hours late. I told them to forget it because my job didn’t pay me enough to miss a whole days worth of work, I was never coming back

and that if they even tried to charge me a missed appointment fee, I’d file a complaint with everyone and their mom.I then called my health insurance to let them know in case they tried to bill them too. You can complain to whoever owns the doctor’s office and let them know what happened.

ADVERTISEMENT

swillshop − NTA. I would send the ENT a letter stating what happened and asking if the desk staff were actually following the practice's policies. There are also plenty of doctor rating sites and you could also post this information. Either the ENT's staff were acting improperly (and need to be corrected), or the ENT needs to learn that this policy is going to deter new patients.

Janetaz18 − NTA. Complain to the office manager. Or if the physician’s office practice is owned by a hospital, call the hospital and file a complaint with the patient advocate.

MonstahButtonz − Find a new ENT, and don't pay the fee. That is highly unprofessional, and I could be wrong, but I don't think they're allowed to deny service, even if there is an open balance on your account due to cancelation fee. At least that's how things were explained to me in the US. I never really put it to the test though.

ADVERTISEMENT

These Redditors didn’t mince words, cheering the student’s stand and slamming the office’s overbooking. Some suggested fighting the fee, while others shared tricks for dodging long waits. But do their fiery takes tell the whole story, or are they just venting steam?

This story of a student pushing back against an unfair cancellation fee hits home for anyone who’s felt trapped by a doctor’s office clock. The Reddit community’s support underscores a shared frustration with healthcare inefficiencies, urging us to value our time. Have you ever faced a similar situation, stuck waiting while schedules crumble? What would you do if a doctor’s office tried to charge you for their delay? Share your experiences and let’s keep this conversation alive!

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *