AITA for refusing to cook my boyfriend’s birthday dinner?

Venus Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Imagine walking into your boyfriend’s place, expecting a laid-back wine and cheese soirée, only to find a counter piled high with ingredients and an unspoken order to whip up dinner for a dozen guests. This is the sizzling predicament of a 31-year-old sous chef, blindsided by his boyfriend’s assumption that he’d play personal chef for an impromptu birthday bash. When he refused, sparks flew, pizzas were ordered, and the silent treatment ensued. Was he right to stand his ground, or should he have just cooked? Let’s stir this pot of Reddit drama.

In a cozy apartment buzzing with party prep, the chef’s exhaustion collides with his boyfriend’s entitlement. Last year’s collaborative dinner set a precedent, but this surprise workload feels like a slap. This tale of assumptions and arguments dishes up a question: when does love mean labor, and when is it okay to say no?

‘AITA for refusing to cook my boyfriend’s birthday dinner?’

I’m (31M) a sous chef and I’m used to cooking for family and friends. This past weekend, my boyfriend (32M) decided to have some friends over for an early birthday celebration, which I initially thought would be some sort of a wine and cheese party. When I got there, however, I found out he had bought a lot of ingredients and was expecting me to cook dinner for 12!

For a split second I thought we had discussed about it and I simply forgot, but no! He just assumed I’d up for cooking, because I cooked his birthday dinner last year - but on that occasion he had asked me beforehand and we even went through the menu together, and I ended up spending most of that party alone at the kitchen while everybody mingled in the living room.

Plus, that day I had worked the lunch shift, was felling tired and, most of all, I was PISSED that he just assumed I’d be his personal chef. We had an argument and he told me to forget about it because people were arriving, so he just ordering some pizzas.

He spent the whole night ignoring me. I’m torn about apologizing to him or not. At the end of the day, it would just be easier to cook the damn dinner, but I felt I was right to put my foot down. AITA?

This birthday bust-up is a classic case of crossed wires and unmet expectations. The chef, fresh off a grueling lunch shift, was ambushed with an unpaid gig for 12—hardly a romantic birthday surprise. His boyfriend’s assumption that cooking is a given dismisses the chef’s professional toll and personal boundaries. The silent treatment that followed? A petty garnish on an already sour dish.

The chef’s refusal wasn’t just about exhaustion; it was a stand against being taken for granted. His boyfriend, likely dazzled by past culinary wins, overlooked the planning and energy cooking demands—especially after a workday. Last year’s joint effort set a collaborative tone, but this year’s unilateral move turned the chef into hired help, minus the paycheck.

ADVERTISEMENT

This scenario reflects a broader issue: the undervaluing of domestic labor in relationships. A 2022 study from the Journal of Social Issues found that 65% of couples report conflicts over unequal household contributions, often tied to assumptions about “natural” roles (Source). Cooking, especially professionally, is work, not a hobby to be summoned on demand.

Relationship expert Dr. John Gottman notes, “Mutual respect for each partner’s contributions prevents resentment from simmering” (Source). The boyfriend’s failure to ask betrays a lack of respect for the chef’s time. A sincere apology from him, paired with a promise to plan together, could mend this rift.

ADVERTISEMENT

The chef should initiate a calm talk, explaining how the assumption felt dismissive. Proposing a future joint hosting effort—where roles are clear—could restore balance.

Here’s the input from the Reddit crowd:

Reddit served up a feast of support with a side of snark. Here’s the spread:

StAlvis − NTA. an early birthday celebration, which I initially thought would be some sort of a wine and cheese party.. Oh, there was whining, after all!

ADVERTISEMENT

RoyallyOakie − NTA...It would be basic communication and basic decency to ask. On what planet did he think you would walk in and be happy to see a bunch of ingredients waiting for you after cooking for others? Outrageous.

Traveling-Techie − NTA - at the end of the day it would be easier to find a BF who respects you

Saltynut99 − NTA. My boyfriend is a chef and I love his food. I would never demand he cook for me, let alone 12 people without asking beforehand and offering to help.

ADVERTISEMENT

Mother_Tradition_774 − NTA. Your bf was being a jerk. Doesn’t he realize that cooking is work which is why you get paid to do it?

ThingsWithString − NTA. He doesn't respect your profession. Nobody would (I hope) dump a bunch of motorcycle parts on the floor and say 'I want a working bike for my birthday tomorrow.' He did the same to you, assuming that you can start from scratch, the same day, with a bunch of ingredients he chose, dinner for twelve.

That is something you ask for. Not assume, ask. The way he did last year, and somehow lost that capability in the ensuing year. Don't apologize to him; he should be apologizing to you. He allocated a big chunk of your time and energy and is now sulking because you didn't have the time and energy available on demand.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ok_Yesterday_6214 − NTA, he takes you for granted and you were right to put your foot down. You should celebrate with everyone else, not work the entire night and for free as well!

IamAustinCG − NTA- He just sprung it on you that in addition to being his boyfriend, you are his hired help? But also not paid?

brokeanail − NTA. Presumptuous and entitled of him. Even worse since he knew how it went last year.

ADVERTISEMENT

DaphneMoon-Crane − NTA. It's amazing that he loves your food and wants to share it with others, but he's not thinking of the practical side of it. This is your job, and your tired, and you want to be able to enjoy a party as well.

I think this is an instance where you just need to tell him what you told us, that cooking takes planning, you love that he wanted to share your food with friends but you need to be asked in advance and that doesn't mean you will always say yes.

Sometimes you want to be a guest at a party. Maybe sometime in the near future you all could host a dinner party. He can handle the house and tablescape, while you do menu and cook. Best of luck.

ADVERTISEMENT

These hot takes cut through the grease, but do they get to the heart of the matter? Most back the chef, but some suggest a recipe for reconciliation. What’s the best way to serve up boundaries without burning bridges?

This culinary clash boils down to respect—or the lack thereof. The chef’s stand was a refusal to be reduced to a kitchen appliance, but the boyfriend’s cold shoulder shows communication needs a reboot. In relationships, assuming labor is a shortcut to resentment. How would you handle a partner expecting your skills on demand? Share your thoughts below!

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *